Skip to content
Criée

Teacher sheet

Sustainable and alternative finance

Who it is for
Mixed audience: pupils in their last two years of school, finance students, members of savings groups, developers; the four operations and percentages.
Prerequisites
  • Bonds, coupons and risk: the First steps course (/en/lycee/).
  • Funds and their holdings: “A fund, a shared basket” in the Financial products section (/en/produits/).
  • Percentages.

Sessions

Session 1 · ESG, greenwashing, the green bond75 min

  1. 10 min · Opening question: “A fund shows a green leaf in its advert. What does that tell you?”
  2. 20 min · Reading of “ESG criteria”: the animated sort, three pillars, a company’s average score, why a best-in-class fund can hold an oil company; quiz
  3. 20 min · Reading of “Greenwashing”: behind the label, the SEC and European supervisors’ definition, the truly green share of the Mangrove Avenir fund, the document that shows what the fund holds; quiz
  4. 20 min · Reading of “The green bond”: the four components according to ICMA, the allocated share of funds raised, why the coupon does not depend on the project’s success; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: back to the green leaf, everyone writes what they would check

Session 2 · Sustainable promises and Islamic finance75 min

  1. 10 min · Recall: the four components of a green bond, without rereading the list
  2. 20 min · Reading of “Earmarked or linked”: the animated linked coupon, use of proceeds or sustainability target, the coupon when the target is missed; quiz
  3. 25 min · Reading of “Islamic finance”: riba and other prohibitions according to the IMF, the resale price in a murabaha, the financier’s share in a mudaraba, who bears the loss; quiz
  4. 15 min · Reading of “The sukuk”: how it differs from a bond according to the IMF, the annual rent for three certificates of an ijara sukuk; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes who bears the loss in a loan, a murabaha and a mudaraba

Session 3 · Microfinance, tontines and crowdfunding75 min

  1. 10 min · Day’s review at /en/revision/: everyone answers the questions that are due, then the ones several people missed are corrected aloud
  2. 20 min · Reading of “Microfinance”: the three categories of the 2017 CEMAC regulation, the weight of a 10,000 FCFA fixed cost on a 100,000 loan, what good repayment rates do not prove; quiz
  3. 25 min · Reading of “Tontine or fund”: have learners describe a tontine they know without personal amounts, then the animation; the pot with a defaulting member, why the first in line borrows and the last saves; quiz
  4. 15 min · Reading of “Crowdfunding”: ten loans of 100,000 FCFA at 10%, how many defaults to lose money, the risks cited by the AMF; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes why a default is worse when it hits a member paid early

Session 4 · Summary and assessment45 min

  1. 10 min · Day’s review at /en/revision/: everyone answers the questions that are due, then the ones several people missed are corrected aloud
  2. 15 min · The “sustainable and alternative finance” summary: flashcards, comparing how a project losing 20% shares its loss, then the sheet’s quiz
  3. 15 min · Assessment at /en/durable/evaluation/, alone and without notes: 15 questions drawn from the quizzes, 11 correct answers for the certificate, to print or photograph
  4. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone notes the promise they can now check

Tips

Quiz answer keys

41 questions, with the right answer and its explanation.

ESG criteria: sorting companies beyond their accounts

  1. A company's governance is mainly about...

    → the make-up of its board

    Governance is about how the company is run: board of directors, transparency, shareholder rights.

  2. Can a best-in-class fund hold an oil company?

    → Yes, the sector's best one

    Best-in-class excludes no sector: it keeps the best-scored companies in each, including a polluting sector.

  3. Scores E = 6, S = 9, G = 3. The average score is...

    → 6

    (6 + 9 + 3) ÷ 3 = 18 ÷ 3 = 6.

  4. Two agencies score the same company. According to the SEC, their scores...

    → can differ very markedly

    There is no official SEC score, and private ratings often differ significantly.

Greenwashing: comparing the poster with the contents

  1. According to the SEC, greenwashing means...

    → overstating how environmental factors count

    The SEC defines it as exaggerating the extent to which a product takes environmental and sustainability factors into account.

  2. According to the European authorities, greenwashing can be...

    → intentional or not intentional

    The 2023 common definition says it can be intentional or not, and can affect companies, products and services.

  3. A 400,000 FCFA fund has 25% green holdings. Green amount?

    → 100,000 FCFA

    400,000 × 25% = 400,000 × 0.25 = 100,000 FCFA.

  4. Which document shows what a fund really holds?

    → the shareholder report

    The shareholder report lists the top holdings; the name and the poster prove nothing.

The green bond: the money follows the project

  1. Which of these is not one of ICMA's four components?

    → the issuer's credit rating

    The four components are use of proceeds, project evaluation and selection, management of proceeds and reporting. The credit rating is not one of them.

  2. 8 billion raised, 6 billion allocated to projects. Share allocated?

    → 75%

    6 ÷ 8 = 0.75, i.e. 75%. The remaining 2 billion must be reported as unallocated.

  3. The plant produces less than planned. The green bond's coupon...

    → stays the same amount

    The coupon is set by the bond contract; it depends on the issuer's ability to pay, not on the plant's output.

  4. According to the draft guidelines, on whether a bond is green, the COSUMAF...

    → relies on external experts

    The text says it does not rule on environmental or social aspects and relies on the independent experts' conclusions.

Earmarked or linked: two sustainable promises

  1. In a sustainability-linked bond, the money raised is used for...

    → the issuer's general needs

    According to ICMA, the proceeds meet general needs; the outcome, measured by indicators, is what is promised.

  2. Face value 2,000,000 FCFA, coupon raised from 5% to 5.5%. Stepped-up coupon?

    → 110,000 FCFA

    2,000,000 × 5.5% = 110,000 FCFA, i.e. 10,000 more than the initial 100,000.

  3. A social bond might, for example, fund...

    → an affordable drinking-water network

    Affordable basic infrastructure, such as drinking water, is among the social projects listed.

  4. According to ICMA, who checks performance against the target each year?

    → a qualified external verifier

    ICMA asks for independent, external verification, at least once a year, by a qualified auditor or consultant.

Islamic finance: without interest, who bears the risk?

  1. In Islamic finance, riba means...

    → interest on a loan

    Riba is interest; the IMF lists it among the forbidden practices, along with gharar and maysir.

  2. In a mudaraba the project loses money. According to the IMF, the loss is borne by...

    → the capital provider

    In a mudaraba, losses are borne by the financier alone; the entrepreneur loses his work, not capital.

  3. Murabaha: machine bought for 800,000 FCFA, 12.5% margin. Resale price?

    → 900,000 FCFA

    800,000 × 1.125 = 900,000 FCFA, i.e. a 100,000 margin.

  4. Mudaraba 60 / 40, capital 1,000,000, profit 200,000. The financier receives...

    → 1,120,000 FCFA

    1,000,000 + 60% × 200,000 = 1,000,000 + 120,000 = 1,120,000 FCFA.

The sukuk: borrowing against a real asset

  1. According to the IMF, a sukuk must be built around...

    → a real underlying asset

    The IMF stresses that a sukuk must be structured around an underlying asset, and its principal is not guaranteed by the structure.

  2. A 4 billion FCFA sukuk, rent of 5% a year. Yearly rent?

    → 200 million FCFA

    4,000,000,000 × 5% = 200,000,000 FCFA.

  3. Senegal's first sovereign sukuk, in 2014, was for...

    → 100 billion FCFA

    100 billion FCFA, about 200 million dollars, in an ijara structure.

  4. According to the IMF, a sukuk's principal...

    → is not guaranteed upfront

    The principal is not guaranteed by the structure: return and repayment follow the assets. A State can add its own guarantee, as in Senegal.

Microfinance: three categories, a small loan that costs a lot

  1. A 1st-category MFI...

    → lends only to its members

    It collects savings from its members and lends to them only, within a network (arts. 30 and 33).

  2. An MFI that lends to the public without collecting savings is in the...

    → third category

    The third category grants loans to third parties without collecting savings (art. 44).

  3. A fixed cost of 10,000 FCFA per file. On a 50,000 FCFA loan, it weighs...

    → 20% of the loan

    10,000 ÷ 50,000 = 0.2, i.e. 20% of the loan.

  4. According to CGAP, good repayment rates...

    → do not rule it out

    CGAP stresses that good repayments do not prove borrowers are free of over-indebtedness.

Tontine or fund: borrowing, saving, investing

  1. A 10-member tontine at 20,000 FCFA a month. The pot is worth...

    → 200,000 FCFA

    10 × 20,000 = 200,000 FCFA, paid to a different member each month.

  2. The first member paid out in a tontine is, in practice...

    → an interest-free borrower

    They receive the pot straight away and then repay it through their contributions, without interest.

  3. The last member paid out in a tontine is, in practice...

    → an interest-free saver

    They pay in throughout the cycle and only receive at the end the exact amount paid: saving with no return.

  4. A member stops paying after month 2. The month 5 pot is worth...

    → 180,000 FCFA

    Only 9 contributors are left: 9 × 20,000 = 180,000 FCFA.

  5. According to Global Findex 2021, what share of adults in Sub-Saharan Africa saved semiformally?

    → 25%

    25% in Sub-Saharan Africa, against 9% worldwide.

Crowdfunding: what one default wipes out

  1. Ten loans of 50,000 FCFA at 8%, one total default. Portfolio return?

    → −2.8%

    9 × 54,000 = 486,000 FCFA recovered for 500,000 lent: −14,000, i.e. −2.8%.

  2. According to the AMF, if the platform shuts down...

    → you might lose all access

    The AMF warns that you might no longer have access to the platform and have to act yourself to recover the sums.

  3. Buying shares in a young company through a platform is, according to the AMF, close to...

    → traditional venture capital

    The AMF compares equity crowdfunding to venture capital: total loss possible, resale uncertain.

  4. Ten loans of 100,000 FCFA at 10%. From how many total defaults do you lose?

    → a single default suffices

    9 × 110,000 = 990,000, less than the 1,000,000 lent: a single total default already means a loss.

Summary: sustainable and alternative finance

  1. A fund with a green name holds 18% oil. The first reflex...

    → read the shareholder report

    The shareholder report lists the holdings actually held; there is no official ESG score.

  2. A 6 billion green bond, 4.5 billion allocated. Share allocated?

    → 75%

    4.5 ÷ 6 = 0.75, i.e. 75%; 1.5 billion remains to be allocated and must be reported.

  3. A 2 billion FCFA sukuk, rent of 7% a year. Yearly rent?

    → 140 million FCFA

    2,000,000,000 × 7% = 140,000,000 FCFA.

  4. An 8-member tontine at 25,000 FCFA. Turn 1 gets an interest-free advance of...

    → 175,000 FCFA

    The pot is 8 × 25,000 = 200,000; they have paid 25,000: they have 175,000 at their disposal, to repay in 7 payments.