Skip to content
Criée

Microfinance: three categories, a small loan that costs a lot

CEMAC microfinance institutions under the COBAC’s supervision, and a microloan schedule worked out month by month.

Lesson 79 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Distinguish the three categories of microfinance institutions in the 2017 CEMAC regulation
  • Calculate the weight of a fixed file cost according to the size of the loan
  • Explain why good repayment rates do not rule out over-indebtedness
In this lesson3

A market trader who needs 200,000 FCFA for her stock is of little interest to a bank: the file costs almost as much to review as a loan a hundred times larger. Microfinance exists for these needs. What you take from this lesson: knowing what a microfinance institution is in the CEMAC, recognising its three categories, and understanding why a small loan is expensive.

What the CEMAC regulation says

The regulation on the conditions for carrying out and supervising microfinance in the CEMAC, adopted in Douala on 27 September 2017 (text published by the Congo government's General Secretariat), defines microfinance as the activity of licensed entities, which are not banks, that habitually lend and/or collect savings for populations "living mostly outside the traditional banking system" (art. 1).

It sorts microfinance institutions (MFIs) into three categories:

  • 1st category: collects savings from its members and lends to them only; it must operate within a network; no minimum capital is required, but a solidarity fund must cover losses (arts. 30 to 33);
  • 2nd category: collects savings from the public and lends to third parties (art. 41);
  • 3rd category: lends to third parties without collecting savings (art. 44).

Operating requires a licence from the national monetary authority, after the COBAC's binding opinion; an institution operating without a licence can be closed down by the authority (arts. 47 and 48).

Microfinance institution

A licensed institution, not a bank, that lends and/or collects savings for people who have mostly stayed outside the banks. In the CEMAC it is sorted into three categories and supervised by the COBAC.

A cooperative lends only to its members, using their own savings. Which category is it in, and what must it join?

The life of a microloan

The life of a microloan1/6

A need too small for a bank

Brigitte sells wax-print cloth at the market. To buy stock before the holidays she needs 200,000 FCFA. She has neither a bank account nor property to pledge.

Why a small loan is expensive

CGAP, a microfinance research centre, puts it simply: it is inevitably more expensive to make many tiny loans than a few large ones. It reported a median microcredit rate of about 26% a year in 2006 (CGAP, 2009).

Brigitte's loan, month by monthFictional

Brigitte (fictitious) borrows 200,000 FCFA over 6 months, at 2% a month on the outstanding capital. She repays 200,000 ÷ 6 ≈ 33,333 FCFA of capital each month.

  1. Month 1: 200,000 outstanding; interest 200,000 × 2% = 4,000; payment ≈ 37,333.
  2. Month 2: 166,667 outstanding; interest ≈ 3,333.
  3. Months 3 to 6: interest ≈ 2,667, 2,000, 1,333 and 667.
  4. Total interest: 4,000 + 3,333 + 2,667 + 2,000 + 1,333 + 667 = 14,000 FCFA, i.e. 7% of the sum borrowed over 6 months. The stated annual rate would be 2% × 12 = 24%.

Why so expensive? Suppose a fictitious fixed cost of 10,000 FCFA to review and follow up a file. On 200,000 FCFA it weighs 10,000 ÷ 200,000 = 5%; on a 20,000,000 bank loan, 10,000 ÷ 20,000,000 = 0.05%. The same work costs a hundred times more in proportion.

Writing DD for the capital outstanding at the start of a month, ii for the monthly rate and II for that month’s interest; then FF for the fixed cost of a file, PP for the amount lent and ff for the weight of that cost in the loan:

I=D×if=FPI = D \times i \qquad f = \frac{F}{P}

Without a calculator: on a 100,000 FCFA loan, what does a 10,000 FCFA fixed cost weigh, and on 1,000,000?

A microloan is still a debt. CGAP points out that good repayment rates do not prove there is no over-indebtedness, and that most studies carried out where the risk was suspected found significant levels of it (CGAP, 2011). Before borrowing, compare the total cost of interest and fees with what the business earns, and check that the institution is licensed. The 2017 regulation also cites, among its references, the 2012 CEMAC regulation punishing usury.

Your turn

A 1st-category MFI...

1A 1st-category MFI...

An MFI that lends to the public without collecting savings is in the...

2An MFI that lends to the public without collecting savings is in the...

A fixed cost of 10,000 FCFA per file. On a 50,000 FCFA loan, it weighs...

3A fixed cost of 10,000 FCFA per file. On a 50,000 FCFA loan, it weighs...

According to CGAP, good repayment rates...

4According to CGAP, good repayment rates...

Read next: Règlement CEMAC relatif aux conditions d’exercice et de contrôle de l’activité de microfinance (2017)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further