Skip to content
Criée

Greenwashing: comparing the poster with the contents

The SEC’s and the European authorities’ definitions, and the calculation that reveals how green a fund really is.

Lesson 27 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Define greenwashing as the SEC and the European supervisory authorities do
  • Calculate the genuinely green share and amount of a fund from its holdings
  • Name the document that shows what a fund really holds
In this lesson3

A green name, a leaf on the poster, the word "responsible": none of it says what the investment holds. What you take from this lesson: recognising greenwashing by comparing what a product promises with what it holds, with figures to back it up.

Two regulators' definitions

For the SEC, greenwashing is "the act of exaggerating the extent to which products or services take into account environmental and sustainability factors". Funds can overstate their practices while presenting themselves in a way that makes them hard to tell apart from genuinely sustainable funds (SEC, Investor.gov, 2021).

In 2023 the three European supervisory authorities gave a common definition: sustainability-related statements, actions or communications that do not clearly and fairly reflect the underlying sustainability profile of an entity, a financial product or a financial service. They add that it can be intentional or not (ESMA, 2023).

Greenwashing

Presenting a product, a fund or a company as more environmentally friendly or more sustainable than it really is.

A manager sincerely believes the fund is green, but its marketing exaggerates. Is it greenwashing according to the European authorities?

Comparing the poster and the content

The SEC says where to look: the prospectus describes the fund's objective and strategy, and the shareholder report lists its top holdings (SEC, 2021). The test is arithmetic: add up the weight of the holdings genuinely linked to the promise.

Writing p1,…,pkp_1, \dots, p_k for the weights of the holdings linked to the promise, PP for the genuinely green share, MM for the sum invested and VV for the amount that funds green activities:

P=p1+p2+⋯+pkV=M×PP = p_1 + p_2 + \dots + p_k \qquad V = M \times P

The Mangrove Future FundFictional

The poster promises "a 100% responsible investment". The shareholder report lists eight holdings:

  1. Green activities: Kanga Énergie (solar) 12%, Bois Moabi (certified forestry) 10%, Eau de Lobé 8%. Total: 12 + 10 + 8 = 30%.
  2. Oil and coal: Nkolo Pétrole 15%, Bitumix 7%. Total: 22%.
  3. Other activities: bank 20%, telecoms 18%, cement 10%. Total: 48%.
  4. Check: 30 + 22 + 48 = 100%.

For 500,000 FCFA invested, 500,000 × 30% = 150,000 FCFA funds green activities, and 500,000 × 22% = 110,000 FCFA funds oil and coal. The "100%" promise does not hold; the fund is not necessarily dishonest about everything, but its marketing exaggerates.

The fund’s name, then what it holds

Mangrove Future Fund

“Invest for the planet. A 100% responsible investment.”

Fictitious fund. No list of holdings on the poster.

Fictitious fund, companies and weights. Whether an activity counts as “green” also depends on the method used.

Four questions before believing a label

  1. Which method? Does the fund say how it chooses, and with what data? ESG ratings often differ from one another (previous lesson).
  2. Which holdings? The shareholder report shows what is really held.
  3. What share? Add up the weights: a name cannot be measured, a share can.
  4. Who checked? A review by an independent expert guards against exaggeration; the COSUMAF's draft guidelines on green bonds present it precisely as protection against accusations of "greenwashing" (COSUMAF and IFC, 2021, p. 12).

Without looking at the example: what share of the Mangrove Future Fund really funds green activities, and how do you find out?

A green promise often comes on top of other sales arguments. An investment presented as "responsible", profitable and guaranteed all at once should alert you twice: see the lesson on scams. In the CEMAC, offering securities to the public requires prior authorisation from the COSUMAF.

Your turn

According to the SEC, greenwashing means...

1According to the SEC, greenwashing means...

According to the European authorities, greenwashing can be...

2According to the European authorities, greenwashing can be...

A 400,000 FCFA fund has 25% green holdings. Green amount?

3A 400,000 FCFA fund has 25% green holdings. Green amount?

Which document shows what a fund really holds?

4Which document shows what a fund really holds?

Read next: ESMA, « ESAs put forward common understanding of greenwashing and warn on risks » (2023)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further