Islamic finance: without interest, who bears the risk?
Riba, gharar, maysir; loan, murabaha and mudaraba compared on the same machine; the 2022 CEMAC framework.
Lesson 59 min
By the end of this lesson
- Define riba and the other prohibitions of Islamic finance according to the IMF
- Calculate a murabaha resale price and the financier’s share in a mudaraba
- State who bears the loss in a loan, a murabaha and a mudaraba
In this lesson3
Lending 1,000,000 FCFA and demanding 1,100,000 back, whatever happens to the project: that is the interest-bearing loan. Islamic finance forbids this pattern, yet it still finances machines, homes and States. What you take from this lesson: understanding what is forbidden, and seeing with figures how the risk is shared differently.
What is forbidden, what is required
The IMF sums up the principles of Islamic finance, which follows Sharia, as follows (IMF, "Islamic Finance" page, 2017):
- riba (interest), gharar (excessive uncertainty), maysir (gambling), short sales and financing activities considered harmful are forbidden;
- the parties share the risks and rewards of a transaction that must have a real economic purpose;
- every sale or lease must involve an underlying asset.
Riba
Interest, that is an extra amount demanded on a sum lent simply because time has passed. Islamic finance forbids it.
What are the two positive principles (not prohibitions) cited by the IMF?
Three contracts for the same machine
The IMF describes the basic contracts (IMF, 2017, appendix I):
- murabaha: the financier buys an asset and resells it to the client at its purchase cost plus an agreed margin, payable later;
- ijara: the financier buys an asset and leases it out, bearing the owner's risks;
- mudaraba: the financier provides the capital, the client manages; profits are shared according to an agreed ratio, losses are borne by the financier alone;
- musharaka: both provide capital and share the profits as agreed.
Hamid's hulling machineFictional
Hamid (fictitious) needs a hulling machine costing 1,000,000 FCFA. Three possible ways to finance it:
- Loan at 10% interest: Hamid repays 1,000,000 × 1.10 = 1,100,000 FCFA, whether his business gains or loses.
- Murabaha, 10% margin: the financier buys the machine for 1,000,000 and resells it to Hamid for 1,100,000, payable over 12 months, i.e. 1,100,000 ÷ 12 ≈ 91,667 FCFA a month. The amount is the same as the loan, but it is the price of a real asset, set once and for all.
- Mudaraba, profit shared 60 / 40:
- if the business gains 30%, the profit is 300,000; the financier receives 1,000,000 + 60% × 300,000 = 1,180,000, Hamid keeps 40% × 300,000 = 120,000;
- if the business loses 20%, 800,000 is left: the financier gets back 800,000 and loses 200,000; Hamid earns nothing and has lost a year's work.
With the loan and the murabaha the loss falls on Hamid; with the mudaraba it falls on the financier's capital.
Writing for the purchase price of the asset, for the agreed margin and for the murabaha resale price; then for the capital provided, for the activity’s profit (or loss, negative), for the share of profit that goes to the financier and for what the mudaraba returns to them:
Hamid (fictitious) needs a hulling machine costing 1,000,000 FCFA. After a year his business is worth the capital plus or minus its result.
Interest-bearing loan
1,000,000 FCFA is repaid plus 10% interest, whatever happens.
Murabaha
The financier buys the machine for 1,000,000 FCFA and resells it for 1,100,000 FCFA, payable later.
Mudaraba
Profit shared 60 / 40; a loss reduces the financier’s capital.
Gain: the loan and the murabaha bring the financier an amount set in advance; the mudaraba gives him a share of the actual profit, larger or smaller.
Fictitious amounts, margin and sharing ratio. Simplified contracts: a real contract also covers late payment, collateral and Sharia compliance.
In the example's mudaraba, the business gains 5%. How much does the financier receive?
In the CEMAC zone
According to the regional business and legal press, the UMAC Ministerial Committee adopted in November 2022 regulation no. 04/22/CEMAC/UMAC/COBAC on Islamic finance, supervised by the COBAC; a bank or a microfinance institution may carry it out exclusively or through an "Islamic window" that requires the COBAC's prior authorisation; the products listed include murabaha, ijara, mudaraba and musharaka (Ecomatin, 2022; Droit Médias Finance).
This information on the CEMAC regulation comes from secondary sources: we have not found the official text online, and the exact adoption date varies between articles. Moreover, Sharia-compliant financing is not risk-free for the client: in a murabaha the price is owed like a debt; in a mudaraba the investor can lose capital.
Your turn
Read next: FMI, « Islamic Finance » (2017)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.