Skip to content
Criée

ESG criteria: sorting companies beyond their accounts

What environmental, social and governance cover, and why exclusion, best-in-class and best-in-universe give different baskets.

Lesson 18 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Distinguish what the environmental, social and governance pillars cover
  • Calculate a company’s average ESG score from its three scores
  • Explain why a best-in-class fund can hold an oil company
In this lesson4

A company's accounts say what it earns. They do not say how much it pollutes, how it treats its staff or who really controls it. ESG criteria look at those three angles, and are then used to sort companies. What you take from this lesson: knowing what each letter covers, and seeing that the same list of companies gives different baskets depending on the sorting rule.

Three letters, three questions

The US SEC's bulletin on ESG funds describes the three pillars as follows (SEC, Investor.gov, 2021):

  • E, environmental: the company's impact (energy used, pollution) and the risks climate change poses to it;
  • S, social: its relationships with people, staff, customers, communities, and right down its supply chain (human rights, health, safety);
  • G, governance: how it is run (transparency, ethics, shareholder rights, make-up of the board of directors).

ESG criteria

Non-financial criteria, environmental, social and governance, used to assess a company in addition to its financial results.

A company hides a large debt from its shareholders. Which pillar is hit first?

A score is not an official measure

There is no official SEC ESG score. Private ratings exist, but they "often differ significantly from each other", and some of the data used is not verified (SEC, 2021). An ESG score is therefore an opinion built with a method, not an accounting figure.

Four sorting rules

The French regulator AMF describes the main strategies of socially responsible investment, or SRI (AMF, 2021). Four of them are enough to see the essentials:

  • sector exclusion: whole sectors are left out, without looking at the scores;
  • best-in-class: the best-scored companies in each sector are kept, with no sector excluded; a fund can therefore hold the "top pupil" of a polluting sector;
  • best-in-universe: the best-scored companies across all sectors are kept, which creates sector biases;
  • shareholder engagement: the investor stays a shareholder and votes at the general meeting to make the company change.

The AMF adds that exclusions alone are not enough to make an SRI fund.

Six companies, four basketsFictional

Each company is scored from 0 to 10 on E, S and G. The average score is (E + S + G) ÷ 3.

  1. Nkolo Pétrole: (3 + 7 + 9) ÷ 3 = 6.33. Bitumix (coal): (1 + 4 + 6) ÷ 3 = 3.67.
  2. Fanga Banque: (6 + 7 + 8) ÷ 3 = 7.00. Crédit Moabi: (6 + 6 + 6) ÷ 3 = 6.00.
  3. Cacao Lobé: (7 + 8 + 6) ÷ 3 = 7.00. Palmeraie Ivindo: (3 + 5 + 4) ÷ 3 = 4.00.

The baskets:

  • Keep everything: average (6.33 + 3.67 + 7 + 6 + 7 + 4) ÷ 6 = 5.67.
  • Exclude fossil fuels: Fanga, Moabi, Cacao, Palmeraie; average (7 + 6 + 7 + 4) ÷ 4 = 6.00. Palmeraie Ivindo, poorly scored, stays: exclusion does not look at scores.
  • Best-in-class: the best in each sector, Nkolo Pétrole, Fanga, Cacao; average (6.33 + 7 + 7) ÷ 3 = 6.78. An oil company is in the basket.
  • Best-in-universe, threshold 6.5: Fanga and Cacao; average 7.00, but no energy company left.

Writing EE, SS and GG for a company’s three scores and NN for its average score:

N=E+S+G3N = \frac{E + S + G}{3}
Four ways to sort six companies

No filter: all six companies.

  • Nkolo PétroleEnergy, fossil
    E
    3
    S
    7
    G
    9

    Average score: 6.33

  • BitumixEnergy, fossil
    E
    1
    S
    4
    G
    6

    Average score: 3.67

  • Fanga BanqueBanking
    E
    6
    S
    7
    G
    8

    Average score: 7.00

  • Crédit MoabiBanking
    E
    6
    S
    6
    G
    6

    Average score: 6.00

  • Cacao LobéFarming
    E
    7
    S
    8
    G
    6

    Average score: 7.00

  • Palmeraie IvindoFarming
    E
    3
    S
    5
    G
    4

    Average score: 4.00

Companies kept: 6 / 6

Basket average score: 5.67

Sectors represented: 3 (2 fossil)

Fictitious companies and scores. Two real agencies can score the same company very differently.

Why can a best-in-class fund hold an oil company, while a fund that excludes fossil fuels cannot?

A good ESG score promises no return. As with any fund, you can lose money in an ESG fund, and its performance may be higher or lower than the market's (SEC, 2021). How funds themselves work is explained in the Financial products section.

And in the CEMAC zone?

No source found describes an ESG fund sold in the CEMAC or an ESG rating published by the COSUMAF: this lesson stays general. The rule of caution is the same everywhere: read the method before believing the label.

Your turn

A company's governance is mainly about...

1A company's governance is mainly about...

Can a best-in-class fund hold an oil company?

2Can a best-in-class fund hold an oil company?

Scores E = 6, S = 9, G = 3. The average score is...

3Scores E = 6, S = 9, G = 3. The average score is...

Two agencies score the same company. According to the SEC, their scores...

4Two agencies score the same company. According to the SEC, their scores...

Read next: SEC, Investor.gov, « Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Funds – Investor Bulletin » (2021)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further