The sukuk: borrowing against a real asset
A leased asset, rent instead of a coupon, a buy-back at maturity; Senegal’s precedent in 2014.
Lesson 67 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain how a sukuk differs from a conventional bond according to the IMF
- Calculate the annual rent paid to the holders of an ijara sukuk
Can a State that does not want to pay interest borrow on the market? Yes, if it sells not a promise of repayment but rights to a real asset that it then rents. That is the sukuk. What you take from this lesson: knowing how a sukuk differs from a bond, and working out what it pays.
What the IMF says
For the IMF, sukuk are "the Islamic equivalent of bonds" and resemble asset-backed securities. A conventional bond is a promise to repay with an interest rate; a sukuk must be built around an underlying asset, its principal is not guaranteed by the structure, and the return follows the performance of the assets (IMF, "Islamic Finance" page, 2017). The IMF put sukuk issuance at 120 billion dollars in 2013.
Sukuk
A certificate giving its holder a share of the rights to a real asset and of the income it produces, used in Islamic finance instead of an interest-bearing bond.
According to the IMF, what is the key difference between a sukuk and a conventional bond?
The life of a lease sukuk (ijara)
First a real asset
A fictitious State owns a covered market. It wants to raise 10,000,000,000 FCFA without paying interest: it will rely on this building.
A covered market, 10 billionFictional
A fictitious State raises 10 billion FCFA through a 5-year ijara sukuk, backed by a covered market. The agreed rent is 6% a year.
- Yearly rent: 10,000,000,000 × 6% = 600,000,000 FCFA, passed on to holders.
- For a holder of one 1,000,000 FCFA certificate: the share is 1,000,000 ÷ 10,000,000,000 = one ten-thousandth; the holder receives 600,000,000 ÷ 10,000 = 60,000 FCFA a year.
- Over 5 years: 5 × 600 million = 3 billion FCFA in rent.
- At maturity: the State buys back the rights to the building at the agreed price, 10 billion; the holder gets back 1,000,000 FCFA.
The amounts look like those of a 6% bond: the difference lies in the nature of the contract, the rent of a real asset rather than interest on money lent.
Writing for the amount raised, for the agreed rent as a percentage, for the annual rent paid to holders, for the value of one certificate and for what its holder receives each year:
In the example, how much does a holder of 3 certificates of 1,000,000 FCFA receive in total over 5 years, buy-back included?
An African precedent in CFA francs
In 2014 Senegal issued its first sovereign sukuk: 100 billion FCFA (about 200 million dollars), an amortising ijara sukuk. The State granted a 99-year usufruct over certain assets, then leased them back in exchange for rent paid to investors; the deal was guaranteed by the Republic of Senegal. The law firm advising on it presents it as the first major sukuk issued by a State in Africa (Clifford Chance, 2014). Senegal belongs to the WAEMU, the other CFA franc zone, not to the CEMAC.
We have found no source confirming that a CEMAC State has issued a sukuk, nor that a sukuk is listed on the BVMAC; Cameroon's 2018 State loan, for instance, was a conventional bond. A sukuk is not risk-free: if the asset or the issuer fails, the holder can lose, and a State's guarantee is only worth as much as its signature.
Your turn
Read next: FMI, « Islamic Finance » (2017)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.