Skip to content
Criée

Earmarked or linked: two sustainable promises

Social bond versus sustainability-linked bond: working out the stepped-up coupon when the target is missed.

Lesson 48 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Distinguish use-of-proceeds bonds from sustainability-linked bonds
  • Calculate a sustainability-linked bond’s coupon when the target is missed
  • Give an example of a project that a social bond can fund
In this lesson3

Two "sustainable" bonds can promise very different things. One promises where the money will go; the other promises an outcome, and pays more if it misses it. What you take from this lesson: telling these two families apart, and working out the coupon of a sustainability-linked bond when the target is missed.

Family 1: use of proceeds

The green bond from the previous lesson belongs here. ICMA defines the social bond on the same model: its proceeds finance only eligible social projects, with the same four components (ICMA, Social Bond Principles, 2025). The COSUMAF's draft guidelines give examples suited to Central Africa: affordable basic infrastructure (drinking water, sanitation, energy), health, education, affordable housing, job creation notably through funding SMEs and microfinance, food security; and target populations such as people below the poverty line, and disabled, displaced or unemployed people (COSUMAF and IFC, 2021, p. 7). A sustainability bond funds a mix of green and social projects.

Social bond

A bond whose money raised is reserved for social-impact projects named in advance, with the same tracking and reporting rules as a green bond.

Family 2: the promised outcome

The sustainability-linked bond works differently. According to ICMA, its financial characteristics can vary depending on whether the issuer meets sustainability objectives set in advance, measured by indicators and compared with targets. The money raised meets the issuer's general needs; a change in the coupon is the most common mechanism; performance is verified by an external expert at least once a year (ICMA, Sustainability-Linked Bond Principles, 2024).

Sustainability-linked bond

A bond whose coupon, or another feature, changes depending on whether the issuer meets a sustainability target set in advance.

A company raises money for its day-to-day needs and promises to cut its emissions, otherwise its coupon rises. Which family?

A missed target costs 5,000 FCFAFictional

Kanga Énergie (fictitious) issues a 1,000,000 FCFA bond at 6% over 5 years. Target: 40% solar electricity by the end of year 3. If the target is missed, the coupon rises to 6.25% (+0.25 point) for years 4 and 5.

  1. Years 1 to 3: 1,000,000 × 6% = 60,000 FCFA a year, i.e. 180,000.
  2. End of year 3: the measured and verified solar share is 30%, below target.
  3. Years 4 and 5: 1,000,000 × 6.25% = 62,500 FCFA a year, i.e. 125,000.
  4. Total: 180,000 + 125,000 = 305,000 FCFA, against 300,000 had the target been met: 5,000 FCFA more for the investor.

The penalty is real but small: it is one of the points ICMA asks to be calibrated so that it is "meaningful" relative to the bond's original characteristics.

Writing NN for the face value, tt for the starting rate, mm for the agreed step-up and CC for the annual coupon after the measurement date:

C={N×tif the target is metN×(t+m)if the target is missedC = \begin{cases} N \times t & \text{if the target is met} \\ N \times (t + m) & \text{if the target is missed} \end{cases}
A coupon that depends on a target

Kanga Énergie (fictitious) promises: “40% of its electricity from solar by the end of year 3”. Otherwise the coupon rises from 6% to 6.25% for the following years. Bond of 1,000,000 FCFA.

Target missed: coupon stepped up

YearRateCoupon
16.00%60,000 FCFA
26.00%60,000 FCFA
36.00%60,000 FCFA
46.25%62,500 FCFA
56.25%62,500 FCFA

Coupons over 5 years: 305,000 FCFA (+5,000 FCFA)

Fictitious issuer, target and rates. Here the money raised meets the issuer’s general needs: it is the outcome that is promised, not the use of the funds.

In the example, had the solar share reached 45%, how much would the investor have received in coupons?

A CEMAC case: Gabon's debt conversion

In August 2023 Gabon refinanced part of its international debt through a 500 million dollar "blue" bond, insured against political risk by the US agency DFC, committing to fund marine conservation (about 163 million dollars over 15 years) and to protect 30% of its sea area (Hunton, counsel to the DFC; Reinsurance News). It is a third model: a commitment by the State in exchange for better financing terms.

These figures come from secondary sources (the official press release was not read directly), and analysts question how these commitments will be monitored over time. More generally, a sustainability promise is only worth its verification: a target that is too easy or a penalty that is too small obliges nobody to do anything.

Your turn

In a sustainability-linked bond, the money raised is used for...

1In a sustainability-linked bond, the money raised is used for...

Face value 2,000,000 FCFA, coupon raised from 5% to 5.5%. Stepped-up coupon?

2Face value 2,000,000 FCFA, coupon raised from 5% to 5.5%. Stepped-up coupon?

A social bond might, for example, fund...

3A social bond might, for example, fund...

According to ICMA, who checks performance against the target each year?

4According to ICMA, who checks performance against the target each year?

Read next: ICMA, Sustainability-Linked Bond Principles (juin 2024)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further