Skip to content
Criée

Crowdfunding: what one default wipes out

Lending to ten projects through a platform: working out the return with defaults, and the five risks cited by the AMF.

Lesson 97 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate the return on a portfolio of crowdfunding loans after total defaults
  • List the crowdfunding risks highlighted by the AMF
In this lesson4

An online platform offers you the chance to lend 50,000 FCFA to a neighbourhood bakery, at 8% a year. The project is tangible, the social benefit obvious, the rate attractive. What you take from this lesson: working out what a portfolio of crowdfunding loans really earns when some projects default, and knowing the risks regulators highlight.

What crowdfunding is

Crowdfunding connects project owners with many individuals through a platform. When it is about investing money, it takes the form of a subscription to shares or bonds, or of a loan (AMF, 2025). A simple donation, with no financial return, is not an investment and falls outside this lesson.

Crowdfunding

Funding a project through many individuals, via a platform, in the form of loans, shares or bonds.

The risks listed by the AMF

In June 2025 the French regulator AMF called on investors to show "the greatest vigilance" (AMF, 2025):

  1. Capital loss: you can lose all or part of the sums invested or lent.
  2. Illiquidity: the securities may be hard to sell.
  3. Late payment or default: interest and repayment are never guaranteed.
  4. Recovery costs: they can amount to a significant share of the sums at stake.
  5. Platform shutdown: you might lose access to it, and have to act alone to recover your money.

Equity investment in young companies is, according to the AMF, close to venture capital.

Without rereading the list: what are the five risks cited by the AMF?

One default wipes out a lot of interest

Ten loans of 50,000 FCFA at 8%Fictional

You lend 50,000 FCFA to each of ten (fictitious) projects, repayable in one go after a year, at 8%. Total stake: 10 × 50,000 = 500,000 FCFA. A project that repays returns 50,000 × 1.08 = 54,000; a project in total default returns nothing.

  1. No default: 10 × 54,000 = 540,000. Gain: 40,000, i.e. +8%.
  2. One default: 9 × 54,000 = 486,000. Loss: 500,000 − 486,000 = 14,000, i.e. −2.8%.
  3. Two defaults: 8 × 54,000 = 432,000. Loss: 68,000, i.e. −13.6%.
  4. Everything on one project: 500,000 lent to the bakery; if it defaults, −100%.

One project's interest (4,000 FCFA) does not make up for the loss of one stake (50,000): more than twelve repaid projects are needed to cover a single lost stake. Spreading over ten projects does not remove the risk; it stops it from being total.

Writing nn for the number of loans, mm for the stake in each, rr for the rate, dd for the number of total defaults, VV for what comes back to the lender and ρ\rho for the portfolio return:

V=(n−d)×m×(1+r)ρ=V−n×mn×mV = (n - d) \times m \times (1 + r) \qquad \rho = \frac{V - n \times m}{n \times m}
Ten small loans, a few defaults

You lend 50,000 FCFA to each of ten projects, at 8% over one year. Tap a project to make it default.

Lent: 500,000 FCFA

Recovered: 540,000 FCFA

Return (0 defaults): +8.0%

Fictitious projects, rates and defaults. Here a default is assumed to lose everything; in reality partial recovery is possible but costs fees.

Ten loans of 100,000 FCFA at 10%. How many total defaults does it take to lose money?

In the CEMAC zone

According to the regional legal press, regulation no. 01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF lists crowdfunding advisers among market intermediaries, but the COSUMAF still had to set out their detailed rules in early 2025 (Droit Médias Finance). What is established: placing financial instruments with the public is a regulated service requiring prior authorisation, and the COSUMAF has already warned against illegal public offerings promising "certain gains" (see the lesson on scams).

The CEMAC framework specific to crowdfunding is not confirmed here by an official text read directly. Before lending or investing through a platform, check with the COSUMAF that it is authorised, and only put in sums whose total loss would not change your life. This section is not investment advice.

Your turn

Ten loans of 50,000 FCFA at 8%, one total default. Portfolio return?

1Ten loans of 50,000 FCFA at 8%, one total default. Portfolio return?

According to the AMF, if the platform shuts down...

2According to the AMF, if the platform shuts down...

Buying shares in a young company through a platform is, according to the AMF, close to...

3Buying shares in a young company through a platform is, according to the AMF, close to...

Ten loans of 100,000 FCFA at 10%. From how many total defaults do you lose?

4Ten loans of 100,000 FCFA at 10%. From how many total defaults do you lose?

Read next: AMF, « Financement participatif : l’AMF appelle les investisseurs à la plus grande vigilance sur les risques » (2025)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further