Skip to content
Criée

Tontine or fund: borrowing, saving, investing

Depending on their turn, a tontine member borrows or saves without interest; a fund may earn, but advances nothing.

Lesson 89 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate a tontine’s pot, with or without a defaulting member
  • Explain why the first in turn borrows and the last saves without interest
In this lesson4

Ten friends each pay 20,000 FCFA a month; each month one of them leaves with the 200,000. Nobody earns any interest, and yet the tontine provides a real financial service. What you take from this lesson: seeing that, depending on their turn, a tontine member borrows or saves without interest, and comparing this with a fund invested in the markets.

A widespread practice, measured by the World Bank

The World Bank's Global Findex survey calls "semiformal" the savings entrusted to a savings club or to someone outside the family. The most common type of club is the rotating savings and credit association: members pool regular contributions, and the whole amount is paid out to a different member at each round. In 2021, 25% of adults in Sub-Saharan Africa saved in this way, including 16% who did not also save with a formal institution; worldwide the figure is 9% (World Bank, Global Findex 2021, chapter 2.2).

Tontine

A group of people who regularly pay the same amount into a common pot, which is paid out to each member in turn.

The turn changes everything

Ten members, 20,000 FCFA a monthFictional

The pot is worth 10 × 20,000 = 200,000 FCFA. Each member receives 200,000 once and pays 10 × 20,000 = 200,000 in total: nobody gains or loses money. But the timing changes everything.

  1. Brigitte, turn 1: in month 1 she has paid 20,000 and receives 200,000. She has 180,000 FCFA at her disposal straight away, which she will repay in 9 payments of 20,000: an interest-free loan.
  2. Serge, turn 10: he pays 20,000 for 10 months and only receives the 200,000 in month 10. That is interest-free saving, but disciplined: the commitment made to the group helps him pay every month.
  3. The fund: the same 20,000 put in at the start of each month into a fictitious fund earning 0.5% a month. After the first month: 20,000 × 1.005 = 20,100. After 10 months, repeating the calculation: about 205,583 FCFA. Serge would have earned about 5,583 FCFA, if that fictitious return materialised; Brigitte, for her part, could never have had 200,000 FCFA in month 1.

Writing nn for the number of members, cc for each member’s contribution, KK for the pot of one round and KdefaultK_{\text{default}} for the pot once a member has stopped paying:

K=n×cKdefault=(n−1)×cK = n \times c \qquad K_{\text{default}} = (n - 1) \times c

In a 10-member tontine, who gets the better deal: turn 1 or turn 10, and why?

A tontine compared with a fundMonth 0/10

Ten members pay 20,000 FCFA each month. At each round one of them receives the whole pot. Alongside, the same 20,000 FCFA a month put into a fictitious fund earning 0.5% a month.

Tontine: Rose

Paid in: 0 FCFA

Received: 0 FCFA

Receives 200,000 FCFA in month 9, having paid in 180,000 FCFA.

Fund, same contribution

Paid in: 0 FCFA

Value: 0 FCFA

After 10 months: 205,583 FCFA, if the fictitious return materialises; available at the end, not before.

Fictitious members, order and return. Pick a member to follow their accounts; with the default, Oumarou receives the pot in month 2 and then stops paying. Fund return: 0.5% a month, not guaranteed.

The main risk: a member who stops paying

Switch on the default in the animation: Oumarou receives 200,000 in month 2 after paying 40,000, then stops contributing. The pots for months 3 to 10 drop to 9 × 20,000 = 180,000 FCFA: each of the eight following members loses 20,000, i.e. 160,000 in total, exactly what Oumarou did not pay back. In a fund, each person's money is kept separate; in a tontine, it rests on trust between members.

Why is a member's default more serious if they received the pot early?

Tontine, fund, account: three different tools

  • Tontine: an interest-free advance for the first members, savings discipline, no legal protection found in case of default.
  • Fund: a possible return, but no advance, and a value that can fall; a fund offered to the public falls under the COSUMAF (Financial products section).
  • Bank, MFI or mobile money account: formal saving is growing; in Cameroon, mobile money account ownership rose from 15% of adults in 2017 to 42% in 2021, and in Gabon from 7% in 2014 to 57% in 2021 (Global Findex 2021, chapter 1.1).

We have found no COBAC or BEAC text that regulates or excludes rotating tontines: their legal status in the CEMAC is not confirmed here. Beware of "tontines" that promise to multiply your stake: an honest tontine pays back exactly what was paid in; promising more is how a pyramid scheme works (see the lesson on scams).

Your turn

A 10-member tontine at 20,000 FCFA a month. The pot is worth...

1A 10-member tontine at 20,000 FCFA a month. The pot is worth...

The first member paid out in a tontine is, in practice...

2The first member paid out in a tontine is, in practice...

The last member paid out in a tontine is, in practice...

3The last member paid out in a tontine is, in practice...

A member stops paying after month 2. The month 5 pot is worth...

4A member stops paying after month 2. The month 5 pot is worth...

According to Global Findex 2021, what share of adults in Sub-Saharan Africa saved semiformally?

5According to Global Findex 2021, what share of adults in Sub-Saharan Africa saved semiformally?

Read next: Banque mondiale, The Global Findex Database 2021

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further