Skip to content
Criée

Amsterdam: a building, then the first derivatives

From the Warmoesstraat to Hendrick de Keyser’s exchange (1611), and from the forward contracts of 1607 to options: what VOC shares gave rise to.

Lesson 28 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Place Amsterdam’s trading spots before and after the 1611 exchange
  • List, in order, the first derivatives traded in Amsterdam
  • Calculate the gain or loss on a short sale in a fictional example
In this lesson5

The lesson “Amsterdam, a share that changes hands” explains why the shares of the VOC, founded in 1602, gave rise to a secondary market. This one looks at where and how they were traded. What you will take from it: in under ten years, the transferable share gave Amsterdam a dedicated building and the first derivatives, including the short sale.

Before 1611: the street, the bridge, the chapel

Until 1611, trading in Amsterdam happened in the open air. First in the Warmoesstraat, a narrow street between the port and Dam Square, sometimes so full of traders that nobody could get through. In 1561, the city named the Nieuwe Brug, a bridge over the Damrak, as the new trading place; in bad weather, merchants went back to shelter in the Warmoesstraat. From 1586, they could use St Olof’s Chapel, empty since 1578: it became Amsterdam’s first exchange building. The city only decided in 1607 to build a real exchange (Petram, The Low Countries, no. 21).

1602: a subscription open to all

The VOC raised its capital through a public subscription. Article 10 of the founding deed said that “all residents of these Countries” could take part. In Amsterdam, 1,143 people subscribed more than 3.5 million guilders. The company was set up for 21 years, against three to four years for the companies before it; so as not to put savers off, the first page of the register said that shares could be transferred by the bookkeeper (Petram).

Transferable share

A share of capital that can be sold to another investor without the company’s consent and without the company paying the money back.

The first known seller was Jan Allertsz.: when the VOC asked for the first instalment, he did not have the money and sold his share. Every transfer then had to be recorded in the VOC’s books, for a fee (Petram). That slowness pushed merchants to invent something simpler.

From memory: where did people trade in Amsterdam in 1561, in 1586, and after 1611?

Hendrick de Keyser’s exchange

In 1611, the exchange designed by Hendrick de Keyser came into use: a rectangular inner courtyard surrounded by a covered gallery, inspired, like those of London and Rotterdam, by the Antwerp model. People came every day except Sunday to learn the exchange rates, the price of VOC shares, marine insurance premiums and commodity prices, and could also strike more complex deals there (Petram). Harvard’s Baker Library also dates its opening to 1611 (Baker Library).

The first derivatives

Recording every sale in the books took time and cost fees. Merchants found ways to bet on the price without changing the owner’s name every time (Petram):

  • 1607, forward contracts. Five years after the VOC was founded, people were already agreeing to deliver shares later, at a price fixed today. The mechanism is covered in the lesson “From forward to future”.
  • 1608, short selling. A group of merchants sold forward large numbers of shares they did not own, to push the price down and profit from it.
  • A few years later, repos. Shares were pledged to borrow money, which was then used to buy those same shares: even with little capital, people could take large positions.
  • Mid-17th century, options. A lively trade in options grew up; long-term investors passed the risk of short-term price swings to speculators.

Short sale

Selling securities you do not yet own, betting on a fall, in order to buy them back more cheaply before you have to deliver them.

Joris sells what he does not haveFictional

Joris (fictional) promises to deliver, in three months, 2 shares in the Kapok Company (fictional) at 500 guilders each. He does not own them.

  1. What he will receive. 2 × 500 = 1,000 guilders, on delivery.
  2. If the price falls to 420. He buys 2 shares for 2 × 420 = 840 guilders, delivers them and collects 1,000: a gain of 1,000 − 840 = 160 guilders.
  3. If the price rises to 560. He has to pay 2 × 560 = 1,120 guilders to deliver and collects only 1,000: a loss of 120 guilders.
  4. The risk. The gain is capped (the price cannot fall below zero), the loss is not: the higher the price goes, the bigger it gets.

Without looking back: in what order did forward contracts, short sales and options appear in Amsterdam?

1688: the share price becomes news

By the late 17th century, the VOC share price could be read like a newspaper. In summer 1688, the English consul Daniel Petit watched the VOC price to guess what a large fleet being prepared was for. At the end of August, the price plunged: Petit concluded that the fleet was aimed at England and warned London. William III landed in England in early November 1688 (Petram).

Amsterdam, from the bridge to the exchange
  1. 1561

    The Nieuwe BrugEurope

    The city moves trading from the Warmoesstraat to a bridge over the Damrak.

  2. 1586

    St Olof’s ChapelEurope

    Amsterdam’s first exchange building, out of the wind.

  3. 1602

    VOC subscriptionEurope

    1,143 subscribers in Amsterdam, transferable shares.

  4. 1607

    Forward contractsEurope

    VOC shares are already sold for later delivery.

  5. 1608

    Short salesEurope

    Merchants sell shares they do not own, to push the price down.

  6. 1611

    De Keyser’s exchangeEurope

    Courtyard and gallery: the exchange opens every day except Sunday.

  7. Mid-17th century

    OptionsEurope

    A lively trade in options grows up.

  8. 1688

    The price as newsEurope

    The VOC’s fall tells the English consul a fleet is aimed at England.

You often read that Amsterdam banned short selling as early as 1610: this was not found in the sources consulted, so it is not stated here. The title of “world’s oldest exchange” is claimed by Euronext; Petram, for his part, credits Bruges with the first daily market and Amsterdam with the first trading of shares on an exchange. The date the building was demolished varies between sources (1835 or 1837) and is not used.

Your turn

Before the 1611 exchange, Amsterdam merchants traded, among other places...

1Before the 1611 exchange, Amsterdam merchants traded, among other places...

In what order did these practices appear in Amsterdam, according to Petram?

2In what order did these practices appear in Amsterdam, according to Petram?

Joris (fictional) short-sells 3 shares at 500 guilders and buys them back at 450. His result?

3Joris (fictional) short-sells 3 shares at 500 guilders and buys them back at 450. His result?

Same sale of 3 shares at 500 guilders, but Joris has to buy back at 580. His result?

4Same sale of 3 shares at 500 guilders, but Joris has to buy back at 580. His result?

Hendrick de Keyser’s exchange came into use in...

5Hendrick de Keyser’s exchange came into use in...

Read next: Lodewijk Petram, « From Bruges to Amsterdam: The Roots of Stock Exchange Trading in the Low Countries », The Low Countries, n° 21

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further