Amsterdam, a share that changes hands
Since the VOC in 1602, an exchange exists because you get your money back by selling your share to someone else, without the company repaying its capital.
Lesson 18 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain why reselling a share changes nothing in the company’s cash
- Calculate the gain or loss of a shareholder who sells their shares
- Distinguish what liquidity guarantees a holder from what it does not
In this lesson5
An exchange exists because a share in a company can change hands. An investor who wants their money back does not ask the company for it: they sell their share to someone else. This simple idea, the transferable share, is what this lesson teaches; it took shape in Amsterdam at the start of the seventeenth century.
Amsterdam, 1602: the VOC
In 1602 the Dutch East India Company, the VOC, was founded in the United Provinces (today's Netherlands) to finance trading voyages to Asia. Its shares could be passed on to another investor. The historians Oscar Gelderblom and Joost Jonker show that, shortly after its foundation, a vigorous secondary market in those shares emerged in Amsterdam. They offered "prospects of speculative gains without serious loss of liquidity", and by 1609 this market was strong enough to dictate terms for new public debt issues (Gelderblom and Jonker, Journal of Economic History, 2004).
Transferable share
A share of capital that can be sold to another investor without the company's consent and without the company paying the money back.
Euronext, which runs the Amsterdam exchange today, calls it "the oldest stock exchange in the world" and the VOC the first company to go to it, in 1602 (Euronext).
"Oldest stock exchange in the world" is the market operator's own account. Commodity markets existed long before; the precise wording, "oldest modern securities market", was not found in an independent source. Remember the date and the mechanism, not the title.
Two different promises
A transferable share settles a conflict. The company wants to keep the money for a long time: a ship sails for years. The investor wants to be able to get it back when needed. With a transferable share, both get what they want:
- the company keeps permanent capital, which it never has to repay;
- the investor keeps liquidity: they can sell their share, at whatever price the market gives that day.
Esther gets her money back without the company payingFictional
The Kapok Company (fictitious) sells shares at 50,000 XAF. Esther buys 4.
- Primary market. Esther pays 4 × 50,000 = 200,000 XAF. The money goes to the company.
- Two years later. Esther needs her money. The company does not buy back its shares: she must find a buyer.
- Secondary market. Joseph buys the 4 shares at 52,000 XAF. Esther receives 4 × 52,000 = 208,000 XAF, 8,000 XAF more than she put in.
- For the company. Nothing changes in its till: it still has 200,000 XAF invested. Only the owner's name changes.
Had the market offered 45,000 XAF, Esther would have received 180,000 XAF and lost 20,000 XAF. Liquidity guarantees that you can sell, not at what price.
From memory: when Esther sells her shares to Joseph, who pays her, and how much does the company receive?
The life of a transferable share
Follow Esther's 4 shares from their creation to their resale. The price of the trade is calculated by the portal's market engine.
The company issues shares
The Kapok Company (fictitious) is preparing a long trading voyage. It sells shares at 50,000 XAF each.
Tulip mania, a different story
Thirty years later, the United Provinces went through tulip mania. According to the Banque de France, between 31 December 1636 and 3 February 1637 the price of the most common bulb rose twelvefold. Many contracts were for bulbs yet to come and were struck before a notary or informally, outside an organised market. The Banque de France also warns that many figures come from pamphlets hostile to speculation and must be read with care (Banque de France, "La crise des tulipes (1637)"). How a bubble works is the subject of the lesson "A bubble inflates, then bursts" in the economy section.
Without looking back: what does tulip mania have in common with VOC shares, and how does it differ?
And in the CEMAC zone
The principle has not changed in four centuries. When a CEMAC company lists its shares on the BVMAC, it receives the money once; after that, the BVMAC serves as the secondary market for shareholders from all six countries. The lesson "Primary and secondary markets: follow the money" in the student path follows that money in detail.
Your turn
Read next: Gelderblom et Jonker, « Completing a Financial Revolution », Journal of Economic History, 2004
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.