Derivatives, contracts on a future price
Futures, options, leverage: recognising a derivative and understanding why it can lose you everything.
Lesson 510 min
By the end of this lesson
- Recognise a derivative and tell a futures contract from an option
- Calculate the result of an option or of a forward sale
- Calculate the leverage effect of a deposit on a fall in the underlying
In this lesson4
A share or a bond is a piece of a company or of a debt. A derivative is neither: it is a contract whose value depends on the price of something else. This lesson is an overview, to help you recognise a derivative and understand why it can win or lose a lot with little money; the Derivatives section studies them in detail.
A contract on a price
The SEC defines derivatives as instruments "whose performance is derived, at least in part, from the performance of an underlying asset, security or index" (SEC, Investor.gov, "Derivatives"). What you follow is called the underlying: a share, an index, a currency, a commodity.
Derivative
A contract whose value depends on the price of another asset, the underlying. You can buy one without owning that underlying.
Two families are enough to start with.
- A futures contract binds both parties: one will buy, the other will sell, at a price fixed today, on a future date. On an exchange, a clearing house becomes each party's counterparty and guarantees completion (SEC, "Commodities").
- An option gives its buyer "the right – but not the obligation – to buy or sell a security at a fixed price within a specific period of time" (SEC, "Options"). That right has a price: the premium.
What is the difference between a futures contract and an option for the person who buys it?
The life of a futures contract
A cocoa farmer and a chocolate maker, both made up, have opposite fears about the price of cocoa. Follow the contract that binds them, from signing to expiry.
Two opposite fears
Estelle will harvest 10 tonnes of cocoa in six months and fears the price will fall. Samuel, a chocolate maker, will have to buy some and fears it will rise. Both are fictional, as are the prices.
The same contract, with a final price of 1,400 F instead of 1,000 F, would have reversed the roles: Samuel would have paid 1,200 F for cocoa worth 1,400 and gained 2,000,000 F compared with the market, while Estelle would have "missed" that rise. Either way, each got what they were after: a price known in advance. That is hedging. Someone who buys the same contract with no cocoa to sell or process is making a bet on the price: that is speculation.
An option, in figures
Samuel buys an option instead of a contractFictional
Samuel buys an option giving him the right to buy 10,000 kg of cocoa at 1,200 F a kilo in six months. He pays a premium of 50 F a kilo: 10,000 × 50 = 500,000 F, straight away.
- Cocoa rises to 1,400 F. Samuel exercises: he buys at 1,200 F what is worth 1,400 F. Gain per kilo: 1,400 − 1,200 = 200 F, less the 50 F premium, i.e. 150 F. In total: 10,000 × 150 = 1,500,000 F.
- Cocoa falls to 1,000 F. Samuel does not exercise: he buys at the market, at 1,000 F. He has lost the premium, 500,000 F, and nothing more.
The option protects against a rise while letting him benefit from a fall, at the cost of the premium.
Writing for the final price of the underlying, for the strike price and for the premium, the result of the call option, per unit, is:
Leverage, in one example
On a futures market you do not pay for the whole contract when you sign: you post a deposit, a fraction of its value. That is what creates leverage.
10% deposit, 10% fallFictional
A speculator buys a contract for 10,000 kg of cocoa at 1,200 F: 12,000,000 F of cocoa. He posts only 10% as a deposit, a fictional rate: 1,200,000 F.
- The price falls 10%, to 1,080 F. Loss: 10,000 × (1,200 − 1,080) = 1,200,000 F, the whole of his deposit.
- The price rises 10%, to 1,320 F. Gain: 1,200,000 F, i.e. 100% of his deposit.
A 10% move in the underlying becomes a 100% gain or loss on the stake.
Writing for the fall in the underlying, for the contract value and for the margin deposit, the loss as a share of the deposit is:
Leverage
Taking a position much bigger than the money committed. Gains and losses are multiplied in the same proportion.
In plain wordsA lorry booked with a small deposit
Imagine a trader who books a whole lorry of plantain bunches by paying only a small deposit. If the price of plantain rises a little, the gain applies to the whole lorry, and it is huge compared with the deposit. But if the price falls a little, the loss also applies to the whole lorry: it can swallow the entire deposit, or even more. That is leverage: a small deposit commits a large sum, both ways.
Leverage is why regulators restrict the derivatives sold to retail investors. For CFDs, contracts that track the change in a price with leverage, the European Securities and Markets Authority imposed a warning in 2018: "Between 74-89% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs" (ESMA notice). This measure is European; it has no legal force in the CEMAC zone, but the risk is the same everywhere. Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.
With a deposit of 5% of the contract's value, how far must the underlying fall to wipe out the whole stake?
Your turn
Read next: SEC, Investor.gov, « Commodities »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.