From forward to future
A forward is negotiated by two parties and can be broken; a future, standardised on an exchange, can be sold to anyone.
Lesson 29 min
By the end of this lesson
- Distinguish a forward from a future by the standardisation of its terms
- Explain the counterparty risk of an over-the-counter contract
- Work out the number of standard contracts needed to cover a quantity
The promise in the previous lesson has a name: the forward contract. Signed between two people, it is a forward; made identical for everyone and traded on an exchange, it is a future. What this lesson teaches: a future is a standardised forward contract, and standardisation is what makes it possible to sell it on.
The over-the-counter forward
Forward contract
An agreement between a buyer and a seller on the delivery of a given quantity and quality of a good, on a specific future date, at a price fixed today (CFTC glossary).
Nothing is paid at signature. Only tomorrow's price is fixed. Follow a contract between Mballa, a grower, and Claire, a chocolate maker, then change the ending.
March: the promise
Mballa promises 7 tonnes of beans for 12 August, at 1,500 F a kilo. Nobody pays anything today: they only fix tomorrow’s price.
In the second case the price has risen: Mballa is better off selling elsewhere and breaks his promise. Claire had protected herself against a rise, but her protection depended on a single person. That is counterparty risk.
Counterparty risk
The risk that the person you signed with does not keep their promise at expiry.
From memory: in Mballa and Claire's contract, who is tempted to break the promise when the price rises, and why?
The same contract for everyone: the future
A forward has a second flaw: it is tailored for two people. If Claire wants to get out of it in June, she has to find someone who wants exactly 7 tonnes, delivered on 12 August to her warehouse. The exchange solves this by fixing every term in advance, except the price.
- Quantity
- Negotiated: 7 tonnes
- Quality
- Negotiated: beans chosen together
- Expiry
- Negotiated: 12 August
- Delivery place
- Negotiated: the buyer’s warehouse
- Counterparty
- Whoever signs with you
- Price
- Negotiated
Every term is discussed: the contract fits both signatories’ needs, but it is hard to sell on to anyone else.
Future
A standardised forward contract traded on an exchange: quantity, quality, expiry and place of delivery are set by the exchange; only the price is negotiated.
In plain wordsMade to measure or standard size
A boubou made to measure by the tailor fits one person perfectly: to resell it, you have to find someone of exactly the same size. A garment in a standard size can be resold to anyone of that size. The over-the-counter forward is made to measure: quantity, date and place chosen by two people. The future is the standard size: the exchange fixes everything in advance except the price, and anyone can resell theirs to any buyer. The downside: a standard size never fits quite right.
Two real examples:
- cocoa in London: ICE's London Cocoa contract covers 10 tonnes, quoted in pounds sterling per tonne, with five expiry months a year (March, May, July, September, December) and physical delivery to approved warehouses. ICE presents it as the global benchmark for the price of physical cocoa (ICE, specifications);
- wheat in Paris: Euronext's Milling Wheat contract covers 50 tonnes, quoted in euros per tonne, cleared by Euronext Clearing (Euronext, specifications).
The story of the move from forwards to futures is often told from the Chicago Board of Trade, founded in 1848. The date of the first standardised futures there varies between sources (1864 or 1865), and the CME Group page that tells it could not be read directly: it is not stated here.
How many contracts for 37 tonnes?Fictional
A fictional cooperative wants to fix the price of 37 tonnes of cocoa using a 10-tonne future.
- Divide: 37 ÷ 10 = 3.7 contracts. You cannot buy or sell part of a contract.
- Choose: 3 contracts cover 30 tonnes, 4 contracts cover 40 tonnes.
- The remainder: with 4 contracts, 3 tonnes too many; with 3 contracts, 7 tonnes unprotected.
- The price of the standard: the future is easy to sell on, but it never fits the need perfectly. A forward could have covered exactly 37 tonnes.
Without looking back: which terms of a future does the exchange set, which one stays free, and what does standardisation make possible?
Your turn
Read next: ICE Futures Europe, London Cocoa Futures, spécifications
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.