Skip to content
Criée

Paris and London, 1720: two bubbles and their rules

Law’s share multiplied by 40, the South Sea’s by 8, then the fall; the Paris Bourse of 1724 and the Bubble Act came out of it.

Lesson 39 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate the multiple of a rise and the share lost in a fall from two prices
  • Compare the bubbles of the Compagnie des Indes and the South Sea Company
  • Name the rules adopted after 1720 in Paris and London
In this lesson4

In 1720, Paris and London went through their first great bubble in shares. How a bubble works (build-up, euphoria, burst) is the subject of the lesson “A bubble inflates, then bursts”. Here, you measure these two bubbles with two simple calculations and look at what each country took from them. What you will take from it: a rise reads as a multiple, a fall as a share lost, and after 1720 Paris and London responded with rules on where and how the market could operate.

Paris: Law, the bank and the Compagnie des Indes

The economist François Velde, of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, reconstructs John Law’s “System” (Velde, Chicago Fed, 2003):

  • May 1716. Law creates the General Bank, a private bank whose capital is raised through 1,200 shares of 5,000 livres.
  • August-September 1717. His trading company (the Company of the West, later the Compagnie des Indes) is approved; the subscription opens on 14 September 1717, at 500 livres a share, payable in government bills.
  • December 1718. The bank becomes the Royal Bank.
  • January 1720. The share, worth about 250 livres in 1718, peaks at 10,000 livres.
  • Early December 1720. Law leaves France. After 1722, the share is back at roughly its 1718 level.

The market was held in the street. According to Vidal, from 1716 to 1720 the rue Quincampoix was the scene of a frenzy of speculation in Compagnie des Indes shares (E. Vidal, The History and Methods of the Paris Bourse, 1910, pp. 139-140).

London: the South Sea Company

The South Sea Company was both public and private: it received a monopoly of trade with Spain’s South American colonies and, in return, converted British government debt into shares. Harvard also recalls its role in the transatlantic slave trade (Harvard Library, South Sea Bubble exhibition). Its share rose from £128 in January 1720 to £1,050 in June, then fell to £175 in September (New York Fed, Liberty Street Economics).

Speculative bubble

An asset price that rises excessively, beyond its intrinsic value, driven by the hope of selling for more.

Two calculations to compare

Writing PbP_b for the price at the starting low point, PhP_h for the price at the peak and PfP_f for the price after the fall, the multiple of the rise mm and the share lost pp are:

m=PhPbp=Ph−PfPhm = \frac{P_h}{P_b} \qquad p = \frac{P_h - P_f}{P_h}
  • Compagnie des Indes. 10,000 ÷ 250 = 40: the share was multiplied by 40. Back at about 250 livres, it lost (10,000 − 250) ÷ 10,000 = 97.5% of its peak value. Velde speaks of a “40-fold rise and fall”.
  • South Sea Company. 1,050 ÷ 128 ≈ 8.2: multiplied by a little over 8. From June to September, it lost (1,050 − 175) ÷ 1,050 ≈ 83%.

Two bubbles, two sizes: the Paris one rose five times higher, but both wiped out most of their value.

The Kapok Company rises, then fallsFictional

A fictional Kapok Company share is worth 40 guilders in January, 200 in May and 60 in October.

  1. Multiple of the rise. 200 ÷ 40 = 5: the price was multiplied by 5.
  2. Share lost. (200 − 60) ÷ 200 = 140 ÷ 200 = 0.70, or 70% of the peak value.
  3. For the January buyer. Still ahead: 60 ÷ 40 = 1.5, or +50%.
  4. For the May buyer. Down 70%: a bubble mostly ruins those who get in late.

From memory: by how much were Law’s share and the South Sea share multiplied, and how do you calculate the share lost?

What came out of it

In Paris, a place and stockbrokers. An ordinance of 22 March 1720 banned gatherings in the rue Quincampoix; another of 28 March 1720 banned everyone except stockbrokers (agents de change) from gathering to trade. Then, on 24 September 1724, a decree of the Council of State ordered the setting up in Paris of “a place called the Bourse”, entered from the rue Vivienne, and made going through stockbrokers compulsory (Vidal, pp. 140-142). The Paris Bourse was born of a state decision, after the bubble.

In London, a law on joint-stock companies. The Bubble Act of 1720 restricted the creation of joint-stock companies. The historian Ron Harris shows, from sources of the time, that the South Sea Company pushed for it to be passed, and judges its legal and economic effects limited (Harris, Journal of Economic History, 1994). On 2 June 1825, the government asked the Commons to repeal the part of the Act relating to joint-stock companies, which it said had been “a dead letter” after 1720 (Hansard, 2 June 1825).

1716-1825: two bubbles, two responses
  1. 1716

    General BankEurope

    John Law creates his bank in Paris in May.

  2. 1717

    Company of the WestEurope

    Subscription opens on 14 September, at 500 livres a share.

  3. January 1720

    Peak in ParisEurope

    Law’s share peaks at 10,000 livres.

  4. March 1720

    Rue Quincampoix closedEurope

    Gatherings there are banned; only stockbrokers may trade.

  5. June 1720

    Peak in LondonEurope

    The South Sea Company share reaches £1,050.

  6. September 1720

    Fall in LondonEurope

    The South Sea drops back to £175.

  7. December 1720

    Law leavesEurope

    John Law leaves France.

  8. 1724

    The Paris BourseEurope

    A decree of 24 September creates a place called the Bourse, rue Vivienne.

  9. 1825

    End of the Bubble ActEurope

    The Commons repeal its part on joint-stock companies.

Historians do not read 1720 as plain madness. Velde estimates that Law’s shares were overvalued “by a factor of 2 to 5” at the peak and puts this down mainly to his price-support policy: on 5 March 1720, an office bought and sold the shares at a fixed price of 9,000 livres. Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst find little evidence of blind enthusiasm in London and Amsterdam: speculation centred on Atlantic trade and insurance companies, and a bubble “needs a plausible story” (NBER, 2009-2011). Finally, Vidal has Law leaving in May 1720; this lesson uses Velde’s date, which is more recent and based on the archives.

The next crash that changed the rules, that of 1929, is covered in lesson 6 of this section and in the lesson “Crashes: 1929, 2008, 2020”.

Your turn

A fictional share goes from 60 to 300 before falling back. It was multiplied by...

1A fictional share goes from 60 to 300 before falling back. It was multiplied by...

Same share: from 300, it falls back to 75. What share of its peak value has it lost?

2Same share: from 300, it falls back to 75. What share of its peak value has it lost?

In 1720, which share was multiplied by the larger factor?

3In 1720, which share was multiplied by the larger factor?

In Paris, the Council decree of 24 September 1724...

4In Paris, the Council decree of 24 September 1724...

According to Ron Harris, the Bubble Act of 1720 was passed with the backing of...

5According to Ron Harris, the Bubble Act of 1720 was passed with the backing of...

Read next: François R. Velde, « Government Equity and Money: John Law’s System in 1720 France », Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, 2003

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further