Skip to content
Criée

No-arbitrage and replication

Two investments that pay the same thing are worth the same; otherwise, you collect the gap without risk.

Lesson 18 min

By the end of this lesson

  • State the law of one price and explain why a derivative’s price does not depend on expectations
  • Value an asset by replication from the prices of other traded assets
  • Build, on a numerical example, the arbitrage that exploits a mispriced asset
In this lesson4

Two analysts look at the same option: one expects the share to rise, the other expects it to fall. Yet they should agree on its price. In 1997, the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences rewarded Robert Merton and Myron Scholes for showing that valuing an option requires no risk premium at all: the risk is already in the share price (1997 prize press release). The price of a derivative is deduced from the prices of other assets, not from opinions about the future. What you will learn: recognise two investments that pay the same thing, and build the riskless gain when their prices differ.

One price for one thing

Law of one price

Two assets, or two portfolios, that pay exactly the same sums on the same dates must have the same price today.

The economic historian Karl Gunnar Persson first describes it for commodities: in an efficient market there is in effect only one price for the same commodity, wherever it is traded; if the gap between two markets exceeds transport and transaction costs, traders buy where it is cheaper and sell where it is dearer, and this arbitrage closes the gap (EH.Net Encyclopedia, "The Law of One Price").

Arbitrage

The simultaneous purchase and sale of identical or equivalent instruments, across two or more markets, to profit from a gap between their prices.

The definition is that of the glossary of the CFTC, the US futures market regulator, which adds that in a theoretically efficient market there are no opportunities for profitable arbitrage (CFTC Glossary). In market finance, the target is a precise kind of arbitrage: a strategy that costs nothing today, can never lose and may gain, or that collects money today with nothing to pay later.

No-arbitrage

The assumption that no strategy can collect a riskless gain without putting up any money. It is used to set the price of a derivative.

MIT's finance course puts it first among its six principles, in the form "there is no such thing as a free lunch" (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, lecture 1).

In plain wordsTwo markets, one price

Picture the same basket of tomatoes sold a little cheaper at the market by the shore than at the market by the station. A sharp trader buys at the first, sells at the second and keeps the difference without betting on the future. When many traders do the same, the low price rises, the high price falls and the gap closes. No-arbitrage simply says that such risk-free bargains do not last: two identical things end up at the same price. Except that in finance the buying and the selling happen at the same moment, with no transport and no waiting, so with no risk at all.

The same security is worth 98,000 XAF on one market and 98,500 XAF on another, with no fees. What does an arbitrageur do, and what happens to the gap?

Replicating: making the same thing another way

Two identical investments side by side are rare. Most of the time, you have to build a copy of an asset out of other assets.

Replication

Building a portfolio of traded assets that pays exactly the same sums, on the same dates, as another asset. By the law of one price, this portfolio and the asset have the same price.

Writing n1n_1 and n2n_2 for the quantities of two assets bought, and Z1Z_1 and Z2Z_2 for their prices, the value of the replicating portfolio is:

V=n1 Z1+n2 Z2V = n_1 \, Z_1 + n_2 \, Z_2

A fictitious bond copied with two zero-coupon bondsFictional

Three fictitious securities from the same issuer, with no default risk, per 100 of face value:

  • a 1-year zero-coupon bond, paying 100 in one year, priced at 95.00;
  • a 2-year zero-coupon bond, paying 100 in two years, priced at 90.00;
  • a 2-year bond with a 6% coupon, paying 6 in one year and 106 in two years, priced at 100.00.
  1. Copy the year-1 cash flow: 6 = 0.06 × 100, so 0.06 of the 1-year zero-coupon bond.
  2. Copy the year-2 cash flow: 106 = 1.06 × 100, so 1.06 of the 2-year zero-coupon bond.
  3. Price of the copy: 0.06 × 95.00 + 1.06 × 90.00 = 5.70 + 95.40 = 101.10.
  4. Compare: the bond is priced at 100.00, its copy at 101.10. The bond is 1.10 too cheap.

Building the riskless gain

Rule: buy what is cheap, sell what is dear, in quantities that cancel every future cash flow.

The arbitrage on the fictitious bond, per 100 of face value

1/5Today: buy the bond

You pay 100.00.

The gain of 1.10 is locked in today, whatever rates do tomorrow: nobody needed to forecast anything. As long as the gap exists, arbitrageurs buy the bond and sell the zero-coupon bonds, which pushes the prices towards a single level.

The example assumes you can short-sell, borrow and lend at the same rate, with no fees and no default risk. In real markets these conditions are imperfect: a gap can persist if it does not cover the fees, or if arbitrageurs lack the means to correct it.

The method of this section

The whole section applies this reasoning. MIT's course states it for forward contracts: buying forward, or buying spot with borrowed money, lead to the same asset at expiry, so by no-arbitrage these two methods must cost the same (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, lecture 8, slide 20). The CFA Institute devotes a whole reading to it: explaining how arbitrage and replication are used to price derivatives (CFA Institute, "Arbitrage, Replication, and the Cost of Carry in Pricing Derivatives").

What changes from one lesson to the next is the copying portfolio: the spot asset and a loan for the forward price, two deposits in two currencies for the currency forward, zero-coupon bonds for the zero-coupon curve, the underlying and a deposit for the one-period tree.

From memory: what are the three steps to exploit a price that breaks no-arbitrage?

Your turn

Two portfolios pay exactly the same sums on the same dates. Under no-arbitrage, their prices...

1Two portfolios pay exactly the same sums on the same dates. Under no-arbitrage, their prices...

Fictitious zero-coupon bonds: 1 year at 96, 2 years at 91. A bond paying 5 then 105 is worth, by replication...

2Fictitious zero-coupon bonds: 1 year at 96, 2 years at 91. A bond paying 5 then 105 is worth, by replication...

The bond is priced at 102 while its copy is worth 100.35. For a riskless gain, you...

3The bond is priced at 102 while its copy is worth 100.35. For a riskless gain, you...

According to the 1997 Nobel committee, valuing an option by this method requires...

4According to the 1997 Nobel committee, valuing an option by this method requires...

Read next: CFA Institute, « Arbitrage, Replication, and the Cost of Carry in Pricing Derivatives » (2026)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further