Why derivatives exist
A derivative fixes tomorrow’s price today: it is first of all a way to hand a price risk to someone willing to carry it.
Lesson 18 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain what a derivative is for and what its underlying is
- Distinguish a hedger from a speculator on a futures market
- Work out what a price fixed in advance avoids or misses
In this lesson4
In March, a cocoa grower does not know what her crop will be worth in December. A chocolate maker does not know what she will have to pay for it. Both carry the same risk, tomorrow's price, but in opposite directions. That is what a derivative is for, first of all: moving that risk to someone willing to carry it. This is what this lesson teaches.
A contract derived from something else
Derivative
A contract whose value depends on the price of something else, called the underlying: a commodity (cocoa, wheat), a share, a currency, an interest rate. It fixes today what will happen on a future date, the expiry.
CEMAC law uses the phrase "financial contracts or forward financial instruments". It lists their families: futures and forwards, option contracts, swaps, forward rate agreements, settled by physical delivery or in cash (Regulation No. 01/22, art. 8). The key word is "forward": without a future date, there is no derivative.
Underlying
The good, security or index whose price determines the value of a derivative.
In plain wordsThe sheep ordered for the festival
Three months before the festival, a family orders a sheep from the breeder, at a price fixed straight away, delivered and paid for on the day. The order itself cannot be eaten: its value comes from the price of sheep at the market. If that price climbs before the festival, the family has made a good deal and the breeder a bad one; if it falls, the other way round. That is a derivative: a contract for a future date whose value derives from the price of something else, here the sheep, called the underlying.
Two fears that fit together
Nadège sells cocoa: she fears a fall. Claire buys it: she fears a rise. Pick a December price, then compare with a price fixed back in March.
Cocoa price in December, at harvest
Nadège, grower
What she receives
2,000,000 F
Claire, chocolate maker
What she pays
2,000,000 F
The price falls to 1,000 F: Nadège only gets 2,000,000 F for her crop; Claire pays less.
Without an agreement, one gains exactly what the other loses compared with the March price. With a price fixed in advance, neither benefits from a good move, but neither suffers the bad one. Each has swapped a chance of gain for certainty.
From memory: what risk do Nadège and Claire share, and why does a price fixed in March suit them both?
Hedging or betting
The US futures regulator, the CFTC, distinguishes two profiles (CFTC glossary):
- the hedger seeks to reduce the risk of loss from an adverse price change: that is Nadège or Claire;
- the speculator does not hedge: they take on the risk to seek a profit.
The speculator is not an intruder. When no chocolate maker wants to buy in March, the speculator is the one who agrees to take Nadège's risk. Lessons 5 and 6 come back to each of them.
Hedge
Taking a position that gains when your business loses, to stabilise what you will receive or pay.
What certainty costs and bringsFictional
Nadège expects 2,000 kg. The price fixed in March is 1,500 F a kilo.
- With the fixed price: 2,000 × 1,500 = 3,000,000 F, whatever happens.
- No agreement, December price at 1,000 F: 2,000 × 1,000 = 2,000,000 F. The agreement would have saved her a 1,000,000 F shortfall.
- No agreement, December price at 2,000 F: 2,000 × 2,000 = 4,000,000 F. The agreement would have cost her 1,000,000 F.
- On Claire's side, the same sums, the other way round: what Nadège misses is what Claire saves, and vice versa.
Hedging does not make money on average: it makes the result predictable.
A huge market
These contracts are no curiosity. The Bank for International Settlements counts 846 trillion dollars in notional amount of over-the-counter derivatives at the end of June 2025, for a gross market value of 21.8 trillion (BIS, statistics at end-June 2025). The notional is the size of the goods or sums the contracts cover, not the money that changes hands.
The notional amount is neither a possible loss nor wealth: it measures the size of the underlyings. Market value, nearly forty times smaller here, is closer to what is really at stake.
Without looking back: what is a derivative for, first of all, and what is the difference between a hedger and a speculator?
Your turn
Read next: CFTC, glossaire des marchés à terme
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.