The Paris Club and rescheduling
Since 1956, creditor States have negotiated together: their principles, the terms from Toronto to Cologne, and two real agreements in the CEMAC.
Lesson 39 min
By the end of this lesson
- Say who negotiates at the Paris Club and on what principles
- Put the Toronto, London, Naples, Lyon and Cologne terms in order
- Calculate what a treatment cancels or reschedules
When a State owes money to a dozen countries at once, negotiating with each one separately would never end, and every creditor would want to be paid before the others. Since 1956, the main creditor States have negotiated together, in Paris. What you will take from this lesson: saying who negotiates at the Paris Club and by what rules, putting its successive terms in order, and working out what a treatment cancels or pushes back.
A club without statutes
The Paris Club's first agreement is signed on 16 May 1956 with Argentina; the first agreement with an African country, Zaire, dates from 1976 (Paris Club, history). Today it has 22 permanent members and has signed nearly 480 agreements with more than a hundred countries, for more than 616 billion dollars (French Treasury, "Le Club de Paris fête ses 70 ans").
The Club describes itself: "The Paris Club has remained strictly informal", it has no legal basis. Its decisions are taken by consensus among creditors, and it follows six principles: solidarity, consensus, information sharing, case by case, conditionality and comparability of treatment (Paris Club, principles).
Paris Club
The informal group of major creditor States that negotiate together, in Paris, the treatment of the debt owed to them by States in difficulty.
Two principles deserve a word. Conditionality: the Club only negotiates with a country that needs debt relief, commits to reforms and has "a demonstrated track record of implementing reforms under an IMF program" (lesson on structural adjustment). Comparability of treatment: the country must not accept from its other creditors, commercial or bilateral, terms less favourable to it than those of the Club (Paris Club, principles).
Rescheduling
The negotiated postponement of a debt's maturities: the sums due are spread over a longer period, often after a grace period without repayment.
Increasingly generous terms
For the poorest countries, the Club first rescheduled, then cancelled a growing share of eligible debt. The Club's official pages give the sequence (Toronto, London, Naples, Lyon, Cologne):
| Terms | Adopted | Cancellation of eligible debt |
|---|---|---|
| Toronto | October 1988 | 33.33% |
| London | December 1991 | 50% |
| Naples | December 1994 | 50% to 67% |
| Lyon | November 1996 | up to 80% |
| Cologne | November 1999 | up to 90%, or more if necessary |
The first agreement on Toronto terms is signed with Mali, in 1988. For countries that are not among the poorest, the Club adopts the case-by-case "Evian approach" in October 2003 (Paris Club, history). The Lyon and Cologne terms are linked to the HIPC Initiative, the subject of the next lesson.
Senegal shows the whole sequence for a single country: an ad hoc agreement in 1987, Toronto terms in 1989, 1990 and 1991, London in 1994, Naples in 1995 and 1998, Cologne in 2000, exit from the HIPC Initiative in 2004 (Paris Club, Senegal's agreements).
Put in chronological order: Naples, Toronto, Cologne, London, Lyon.
Two agreements in the CEMAC
Gabon, 11 June 2004. Gabon obtains classic terms: 716 million dollars treated, repaid over 14 years including 3 years of grace, after an IMF arrangement of 28 May 2004 (Paris Club, Gabon 2004 record). There is no cancellation: only a rescheduling.
Cameroon, 24 January 2001. Cameroon obtains Cologne terms, with a 90% cancellation rate on eligible debt: 1.3 billion dollars treated, of which 900 million cancelled (Paris Club, Cameroon 2001 record).
Cancel or postpone, for KalaoFictional
Kalao owes 500 million dollars to Club members, all of it eligible. Two fictional treatments are on the table.
- Naples terms at 67%. Cancelled: 67% × 500 = 335 million. Still owed: 500 − 335 = 165 million, rescheduled.
- Classic terms, 14 years including 3 of grace. Nothing is cancelled. The 500 million is repaid over 14 − 3 = 11 years, about 500 ÷ 11 ≈ 45.5 million a year from the fourth year, plus interest.
- What creditors lose. In the first case, 335 million of face value. In the second, no face value, but they wait: the lesson on default shows that postponing also costs the creditor.
- A real ratio, for comparison. Cameroon 2001: 900 ÷ 1,300 ≈ 69% of the amount treated was cancelled. The 90% rate applies only to part of that amount, the debt eligible for cancellation.
For Cameroon's 2006 agreement, the Club's record shows 1,090 million dollars cancelled, while its press release, read only as an extract, mentions 921 million: the gap has not been explained. The amounts of other African agreements are not all shown by the Club's website, which is often unreachable.
Since November 2020, the G20 Common Framework has had Club creditors and other States negotiate together; its first agreement, for Chad in 2022, brought together China, France, India and Saudi Arabia (IMF, press release 22/379). The French Treasury lists the following agreements, Zambia, Ghana and Ethiopia (French Treasury): see the lesson on Covid and the Common Framework.
From memory: what is the difference between Gabon's treatment in 2004 and Cameroon's in 2001?
Your turn
Read next: Club de Paris, « Historical development »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.