Skip to content
Criée

Covid, the DSSI and the Common Framework: Zambia and Ghana

A pause in 2020, a method for unsustainable debts, then two African defaults and their restructurings, step by step.

Lesson 710 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Distinguish a suspension of debt service from a debt treatment
  • Calculate the nominal haircut in a Eurobond exchange
  • Place in time Zambia’s default and Ghana’s suspension
In this lesson4

In spring 2020, the pandemic closes borders and sends the revenue of many poor countries tumbling just as their health spending soars. The G20 first proposes a pause, then a method for treating debts that have become unsustainable. Zambia and Ghana, which stopped paying part of their debt, went through this method. What you will take from this lesson: telling a suspension of debt service from a debt treatment, and following, in two real cases, the stages of a recent restructuring.

A pause: the DSSI

On 15 April 2020, G20 finance ministers write: "We support a time-bound suspension of debt service payments for the poorest countries that request forbearance". It starts on 1 May 2020 and is to last until the end of 2020 (G20, communiqué of 15 April 2020). It is extended to 30 June 2021 (G20, 13 November 2020), then to the end of December 2021 (French Treasury, 2021).

The World Bank's assessment: 48 countries took part out of 73 eligible, and 12.9 billion dollars of debt service was suspended between May 2020 and the end of 2021 (World Bank, DSSI page). Senegal is among the countries that signed with the Paris Club, on 21 July 2020 (Paris Club, Senegal's agreements).

Debt service suspension

The postponement, for a limited time, of interest and repayments due: the sums are not cancelled, they will be paid later.

What Kalao gains, and what it still owesFictional

Kalao, a fictional eligible country, was due to pay 60 million dollars to official creditors between May and December 2020. It joins the suspension. We take the terms announced by the G20 in November 2020 for the extension: repayment over 5 years, after 1 year of grace.

  1. In 2020. Kalao keeps 60 million for its health spending.
  2. In 2021. Grace year: it repays nothing of this sum.
  3. From 2022 to 2026. It repays 60 ÷ 5 = 12 million a year, on top of its normal debt service.
  4. The bottom line. Nothing is wiped out: the suspension buys time, not debt relief. If the debt was already unsustainable, the problem comes back in 2022.

A method: the Common Framework

On 13 November 2020, the G20 adopts the Common Framework for debt treatments "for DSSI-eligible countries, with broad creditors' participation including the private sector". Two rules mark this framework: "In principle, debt treatments will not be conducted in the form of debt write-off or cancellation"; and comparability of efforts measured on debt service, the present value of debt and duration (G20, 13 November 2020). Four countries applied: Chad, Zambia, Ethiopia and Ghana (Paris Club, Common Framework). The first agreement is Chad's, in November 2022, already covered in the lesson on default.

What is the difference between the DSSI and the Common Framework?

Zambia: default in 2020, agreements in 2023 and 2024

According to the IMF, Zambia is in debt distress, "defaulting on its Eurobonds in November 2020", in default on its Eurobonds in November 2020, while accumulating arrears to other creditors (IMF, country report, 2022). The stages:

  1. 1 February 2021: request for a treatment under the Common Framework (Paris Club).
  2. 16 June 2022: the official creditor committee is formed, co-chaired by France and China (same source).
  3. 31 August 2022: IMF programme of SDR 978.2 million, about 1.3 billion dollars (IMF, press release 22/297).
  4. 22 June 2023: agreement with official creditors; the IMF calls it "unique and innovative", with a baseline and a contingent treatment (IMF, press release 23/235); memorandum of understanding signed on 14 October 2023 (IMF, press release 23/468).
  5. 25 March 2024: agreement with Eurobond holders, exchange settled on 11 June 2024 (IMF, press release 24/242).

More than three and a half years separate the default from the bond exchange.

Ghana: suspension in 2022, exchange in 2024

On 19 December 2022, Ghana's Ministry of Finance suspends payments on part of its external debt (Eurobonds, commercial loans, most bilateral debt), "an interim emergency measure", and finds that its public debt, "both external and domestic, is unsustainable" (Ghana Ministry of Finance). The stages:

  1. February 2023: domestic debt exchange, with about 85% of eligible holders taking part (Ministry of Finance).
  2. 17 May 2023: IMF programme of SDR 2.242 billion, about 3 billion dollars (IMF, press release 23/151).
  3. 12 January 2024: agreement in principle with official creditors under the Common Framework (IMF, press release 24/08).
  4. 11 June 2024: memorandum with official creditors, covering 5.1 billion dollars of bilateral debt; "The weighted average maturity was extended from 2029 to 2038" (Paris Club, Ghana record).
  5. October 2024: exchange of 13 billion dollars of Eurobonds, more than 98% acceptance, with a "37 percent reduction in nominal value, equivalent to US$5 billion" (Ghana Ministry of Finance).

Check the last figure: 37% × 13 billion ≈ 4.8 billion, which the ministry rounds to 5 billion. This is the holders' nominal haircut.

The amount of the Zambian coupon left unpaid in 2020 and the haircut obtained from Zambia's Eurobond holders were found only in the press: they are not given here. DSSI figures differ between the announcement and the assessment (77 eligible countries and 14 billion dollars announced by the French Treasury in April 2020, 73 eligible and 12.9 billion suspended according to the World Bank). Ghana's haircut is given as 4.7 billion dollars by some press articles, not verified.

From memory: in what year did Zambia default, and what nominal haircut did Ghana obtain on its Eurobonds?

Your turn

Under the DSSI, the sums due in 2020 are...

1Under the DSSI, the sums due in 2020 are...

Eurobonds of 10 billion, nominal haircut of 37%. Holders give up...

2Eurobonds of 10 billion, nominal haircut of 37%. Holders give up...

According to the G20 text, Common Framework treatments are in principle carried out...

3According to the G20 text, Common Framework treatments are in principle carried out...

Which country defaulted on its Eurobonds in November 2020?

4Which country defaulted on its Eurobonds in November 2020?

Read next: Banque mondiale, « COVID 19: Debt Service Suspension Initiative »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further