Skip to content
Criée

The HIPC Initiative and the MDRI

A 150% threshold, decision point, completion point, multilateral cancellation: how twelve CEMAC and UEMOA countries had their debt reduced.

Lesson 410 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate a debt-to-exports ratio and compare it with the initiative’s threshold
  • Distinguish the decision point from the completion point
  • Name the CEMAC and UEMOA countries concerned and the two absent ones
In this lesson5

Rescheduling is not enough when the debt can never be paid: it only pushes the problem back. In 1996, the IMF and the World Bank launch an initiative to wipe out part of the debt of the poorest countries, provided they pass two stages. Twelve of the fourteen CEMAC and UEMOA countries benefited from it. What you will take from this lesson: calculating a debt-to-exports ratio and comparing it with the threshold, telling the decision point from the completion point, and saying which countries in our two zones are concerned.

The HIPC Initiative, 1996 then 1999

"The IMF and World Bank launched the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative in 1996" (IMF, HIPC factsheet). After a review in 1999, the initiative is enhanced and its thresholds lowered (IMF and World Bank, 2001):

  • The exports threshold. The net present value of debt must not exceed 150% of exports (against 200 to 250% before).
  • The fiscal threshold, for very open countries: 250% of government revenue (against 280%), if exports are at least 30% of GDP and revenue at least 15% of GDP.

Net present value counts each future repayment for what it is worth today: a very low-rate, very long debt weighs less than its face amount (see the lesson on the amortisation schedule).

HIPC

Heavily indebted poor country: a country admitted to the initiative launched in 1996 by the IMF and the World Bank to reduce its debt to a level judged sustainable.

Two stages

  1. The decision point. The IMF and World Bank boards find that the country is eligible; "The international community commits to reducing debt to a level considered sustainable". Interim relief can begin.
  2. The completion point. The country must "successfully implement key reforms agreed at the decision point" and apply its poverty reduction strategy. The relief then becomes final (IMF, HIPC factsheet).

There is no fixed date between the two: the completion point is "floating", it depends on the country's progress (IMF and World Bank, 2001).

Completion point

In the HIPC Initiative, the stage at which the IMF and the World Bank find that the country has carried out the agreed reforms: the debt relief becomes final.

A country has just reached its decision point. Has its debt already been wiped out?

The calculation: is Kalao eligible?

Writing DD for the net present value of external debt and XX for annual exports:

r=DXeligible if r>150 %r = \frac{D}{X} \qquad \text{eligible if } r > 150\,\%

Kalao's ratioFictional

Kalao, a fictional low-income country, has an external debt of 1,200 million dollars in face amount. Part of it is at very low rates: its net present value is only 900 million. It exports 400 million a year.

  1. The ratio. 900 ÷ 400 = 2.25, or 225%.
  2. The comparison. 225% is above the 150% threshold: the debt is judged unsustainable relative to exports.
  3. The target. To get back to 150%, the net present value must fall to 150% × 400 = 600 million.
  4. The relief needed. 900 − 600 = 300 million, in present value, shared among all creditors.
  5. The face-amount trap. Calculated on 1,200 million, the ratio would have been 300%: it is indeed the net present value that the threshold counts.

The MDRI, 2005

In 2005, the G8 proposes to go further. The IMF names the scheme the "Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI)" (IMF, note 05/164): countries that reach the completion point get 100% cancellation of their eligible debt to the IMF, the World Bank (IDA) and the African Development Fund (IMF, HIPC factsheet). The IMF starts in January 2006, with 3.4 billion dollars for 19 countries, including Benin, Burkina Faso, Mali, Niger and Senegal (IMF, MDRI questions and answers).

Cameroon in 2006. The IMF and IDA confirm its completion point in May 2006: it obtains about 1.267 billion dollars of HIPC relief (in 1999 present value) and 1.130 billion under the MDRI (IMF, press release 06/85).

Our two zones

The IMF's 2015 annual report gives the dates under the enhanced initiative (IMF, table 2.4):

CountryZoneDecision pointCompletion point
Burkina FasoUEMOAJuly 2000April 2002
BeninUEMOAJuly 2000March 2003
MaliUEMOASeptember 2000March 2003
NigerUEMOADecember 2000April 2004
SenegalUEMOAJune 2000April 2004
CameroonCEMACOctober 2000April 2006
Central African RepublicCEMACSeptember 2007June 2009
CongoCEMACMarch 2006January 2010
Guinea-BissauUEMOADecember 2000December 2010
TogoUEMOANovember 2008December 2010
Côte d'IvoireUEMOAApril 2009June 2012
ChadCEMACMay 2001April 2015

All eight UEMOA countries and four of the six CEMAC countries have therefore reached the completion point. Gabon and Equatorial Guinea appear neither in this table nor in the list of 39 countries in the IMF factsheet.

The reason for the absence of Gabon and Equatorial Guinea is not given in any page read for this lesson. Total relief amounts vary with the basis of calculation: 76.2 billion dollars for the HIPC Initiative in end-2017 present value according to the IMF, "around USD 99 billion" for HIPC and MDRI combined according to the World Bank. The two figures cannot be compared directly.

From memory: what debt-to-exports threshold does the enhanced initiative use, and at which stage does the relief become final?

Your turn

NPV of debt 750, exports 300. The debt-to-exports ratio is...

1NPV of debt 750, exports 300. The debt-to-exports ratio is...

At which stage of the HIPC Initiative does the relief become final?

2At which stage of the HIPC Initiative does the relief become final?

Which CEMAC countries do not appear in the HIPC list?

3Which CEMAC countries do not appear in the HIPC list?

The MDRI cancels eligible debt to the IMF, IDA and the...

4The MDRI cancels eligible debt to the IMF, IDA and the...

Read next: FMI, fiche « Debt Relief Under the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative » (2023)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further