Corporate debt and the ranking of creditors
In bankruptcy, secured, unsecured, subordinated then shareholders: what each recovers depends on its rank.
Lesson 128 min
By the end of this lesson
- Rank a company’s creditors in their order of payment in bankruptcy
- Work out a creditor’s recovery rate
- Explain why subordinated debt pays more
A company borrows like a State, but it can disappear: in bankruptcy its assets are sold and the money shared among those it owes. Not all creditors are paid at the same time. What you will take from this lesson: ranking a company's creditors in the order they are paid, and working out what each one recovers.
Borrowing from the bank or from the market
FINRA sums it up: companies issue bonds "to raise money for capital expenditures, operations and acquisitions" (FINRA, "Corporate Bonds"). The alternative is a bank loan: a single lender, who negotiates directly and often asks for collateral. A bond, by contrast, splits the loan into securities bought by many lenders. On the BVMAC, the official price list has, alongside government bonds, a "private bonds" section and a "regional bonds" section, for example a 6.20% 2024-2031 issue by the Development Bank of Central African States (BDEAC) (BOC no. 2586).
A company generally pays more than a State to borrow: its credit spread (lesson on the credit spread) is wider, because it can go bankrupt and cannot raise taxes.
The creditors' queue
FINRA describes the order of payment in bankruptcy ("What a Corporate Bankruptcy Means for Shareholders"):
1/41. Secured creditors
Those holding a security interest over a specific asset (a plant, stock) are paid first out of that asset.
Security interest (collateral)
An asset of the borrower set aside to repay a specific debt: if the borrower does not pay, the creditor is paid first out of that asset.
Subordinated debt
A debt whose creditor agrees to be repaid after ordinary creditors in a bankruptcy; it pays more because it is riskier.
In plain wordsWho gets served first
When a company goes bankrupt, what it owns is sold and the money is shared out in an order fixed in advance, like serving a festive meal. First those who were promised an asset as security, the warehouse or the stock; then the ordinary lenders; then those who agreed to go later, in exchange for a better rate; finally the shareholders, if anything is left in the pot. The later you are served, the more likely your plate stays empty, and the more you ask to be paid for waiting your turn.
According to FINRA, a bondholder is more likely than an ordinary shareholder to recover part of their investment in a bankruptcy. More likely, not certain. Writing for the sum paid to a creditor and for the sum owed to them:
The order above is the general rule described by FINRA for the United States. In the CEMAC zone, insolvency proceedings fall under OHADA law, whose detailed order of creditors (employees, tax authorities, secured creditors…) has not been checked for this section. The higher yield of a subordinated or low-rated bond pays for a real risk of loss.
The fictional company Fromager SA is wound up. Its assets fetch the sum shown. It owed 110m F.
1. Secured lender (bank, charge on the plant)
Owed 40m F · paid 40m F (100%)
2. Unsecured bondholders
Owed 50m F · paid 30m F (60%)
3. Subordinated debt holders
Owed 20m F · paid 0m F (0%)
4. Shareholders: whatever is left
0m F
Order of ranks: general rule described by FINRA (United States). In the CEMAC zone, OHADA insolvency law applies; its detailed order has not been checked here.
A fictional company owes 40 to a secured lender and 50 to its unsecured bondholders. Its assets fetch 60. How much does each group receive?
The winding-up of Fromager SAFictional
The fictional company Fromager SA owes 40 million FCFA to its bank (secured on the plant), 50 million to its unsecured bondholders and 20 million to holders of subordinated debt. Its assets fetch 70 million.
- Secured: owed 40, paid 40. 70 − 40 = 30 remains.
- Unsecured bondholders: owed 50, paid 30, i.e. 30 ÷ 50 = 60%. A bondholder who had 10,000 F gets back 6,000 F. Nothing remains.
- Subordinated: owed 20, paid 0.
- Shareholders: 0.
- If the assets fetched 150 million: 40 + 50 + 20 = 110 for creditors, paid in full, and 40 million for shareholders.
The recovery rate of the same security therefore depends on two things: what the assets are worth, and the security's place in the queue.
From memory: put in order of payment ordinary shareholders, subordinated debt, secured creditors and unsecured bondholders.
Key points
- A company borrows from its bank or through bonds; it pays a wider credit spread than a sound State.
- In bankruptcy: secured, then unsecured, then subordinated, then shareholders.
- What a creditor recovers depends on the value of the assets and on its rank.
- The difference between owning (shares) and lending (bonds) is covered in Owning or lending.
Your turn
Read next: FINRA, « What a Corporate Bankruptcy Means for Shareholders »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.