Skip to content
Criée

Structural adjustment and its conditionality

Loans in return for reforms: what an IMF or World Bank programme contains, what UNICEF and the evaluators criticise, and what changed in 1999.

Lesson 210 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Distinguish the four tools of IMF conditionality
  • Calculate the budget effort required by a deficit target
  • Present the criticisms of adjustment and the institutions’ response with their sources
In this lesson4

A State in a debt crisis needs foreign currency straight away. The IMF and the World Bank can lend it some, but not for nothing: the State commits to changing its economic policy. In the 1980s and 1990s, these commitments took the name of structural adjustment. What you will take from this lesson: saying what an adjustment programme and its conditionality are, putting a figure on a deficit target, and presenting the criticisms together with the institutions' response.

Two institutions, one logic

The World Bank grants its first structural adjustment loan on 25 March 1980: 200 million dollars to Turkey, to "reduce inflation, increase foreign exchange earnings, and improve domestic resource mobilization" (World Bank, historical timeline).

The IMF creates its Structural Adjustment Facility (SAF) on 27 March 1986, then the Enhanced Structural Adjustment Facility (ESAF) on 29 December 1987, to lend at very low rates to low-income countries (IMF, chronology). Each SAF loan rests on a policy framework paper prepared with the World Bank; 37 of the 62 eligible countries borrowed from it (IMF, Silent Revolution, ch. 14).

Structural adjustment

A set of economic reforms (budget, exchange rate, prices, public sector) that a State commits to carrying out in exchange for loans from the IMF or the World Bank.

Conditionality

The IMF sums it up like this: "When a country borrows from the IMF, the government agrees to adjust its economic policies", and these adjustments "are conditions for IMF loans" (IMF, "IMF Conditionality" factsheet). The same factsheet sorts these conditions into four tools:

  1. Prior actions, to be taken before the agreement.
  2. Quantitative performance criteria, figures to be met (a deficit ceiling, a reserves floor).
  3. Indicative targets, numerical benchmarks that are not criteria.
  4. Structural benchmarks, reforms to carry out (a law, a privatisation, an audit).

Conditionality

The set of economic policy commitments that a State makes in order to receive, tranche by tranche, a loan from the IMF or the World Bank.

A deficit criterion for KalaoFictional

Kalao's fictional programme sets a criterion: the public deficit must go from 8% to 5% of GDP in one year. GDP is 2,000 billion FCFA.

  1. Starting deficit. 8% × 2,000 = 160 billion.
  2. Target deficit. 5% × 2,000 = 100 billion.
  3. Effort required. 160 − 100 = 60 billion, in new revenue or spending cuts.
  4. The political choice. If Kalao finds only 20 billion in revenue, it must cut 40 billion of spending. On a budget of 400 billion, that is 10%: salaries, investment, health or schools.
  5. The check. If the criterion is not met at the review, the next tranche of the loan can be delayed.

What is the difference between a quantitative performance criterion and a structural benchmark?

What people say about it

The debate is old and heated. The positions below are presented with their sources, without settling between them.

UNICEF. As early as 1983, a UNICEF study concluded "that poor children were suffering the worst effects of the recession". The agency observes that cuts in public spending "adversely affected the social sector, including health and education". In 1987, Adjustment with a Human Face (Cornia, Jolly, Stewart) appears, and its title becomes famous (UNICEF, Sixty Years for Children); the study calls for policies that protect women and children during crises (UNICEF, "Moving with the times").

The countries concerned. At the Harare seminar organised by the World Bank in 1994, African participants express "genuine concerns about the pace and sequencing of reforms" and point to falls in real per capita spending on health and education (World Bank, Discussion Paper 288).

The IMF's external evaluators. In 1998, an external evaluation of the ESAF reports among borrowing countries "a feeling of loss of control over the policy content and the pace of implementation of reform programs" (IMF, External Evaluation of the ESAF).

The institutions. The same 1994 seminar sums up the World Bank's position: "adjustment has not failed, but some countries have failed to adjust". In 1998 the IMF Board judges the reforms as "generally having positive effects on growth and income distribution", despite temporary costs for some groups, and rejects some of the evaluators' conclusions (IMF, 1998). The IMF also writes that the claim that the ESAF does not reduce poverty "is not supported by the facts" (IMF, "Is It Working?").

The 1999 response

In 1999, the two institutions introduce Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs), which must be "genuinely country-owned and reflect the outcome of an open participatory process" (IMF and World Bank, 1999). The ESAF becomes the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) (IMF, Finance & Development, 2021). In 2004, the IMF's Independent Evaluation Office judges PRSPs generally better than earlier strategies, but notes that "results in terms of ownership are mixed" (IMF, IEO, 2004).

No World Bank evaluation dealing specifically with adjustment loans in Africa was read for this lesson. The effects of adjustment on growth and poverty remain debated: this lesson reports positions, it does not measure these effects.

From memory: what criticism did UNICEF make in 1987, and what reform did the institutions introduce in 1999?

Your turn

A public deficit ceiling written into an IMF programme is...

1A public deficit ceiling written into an IMF programme is...

GDP of 1,000, deficit to be brought from 6% to 4%. The effort required is...

2GDP of 1,000, deficit to be brought from 6% to 4%. The effort required is...

'Adjustment with a Human Face', published in 1987, is a study by which body?

3'Adjustment with a Human Face', published in 1987, is a study by which body?

In 1999, PRSPs must above all be...

4In 1999, PRSPs must above all be...

Read next: FMI, « External Evaluation of the ESAF » (1998)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further