Skip to content
Criée

New York: from Buttonwood to the ticker

A wall from 1653, an agreement of 24 brokers in 1792, a call market in 1817, then continuous trading and the ticker: Wall Street takes shape.

Lesson 49 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Describe how securities were traded at 40 Wall Street in 1817
  • Explain what the ticker changed for an investor far from the exchange
  • Date the Buttonwood Agreement and the 1817 constitution
In this lesson5

The lesson “From brokers’ club to listed company” tells who owned the NYSE, from the club of 1792 to the listed company of 2006. This one tells how trading worked there and how the price left the room. What you will take from it: New York moved from a call market, where securities were dealt one by one twice a day, to a continuous market, and the ticker carried the price of each trade far beyond Wall Street.

A wall, then a street

Wall Street owes its name to a stockade. According to the New York City municipal archives, the wall of New Amsterdam was ordered in March 1653 by Director General Petrus Stuyvesant and the city council, against the English, during the First Anglo-Dutch War (1652-1654); on 28 July 1653, the town was surrounded by palisades on the land side, and the wall stood for 46 years (NYC Municipal Archives, 2017). The NYSE, for its part, links the stockade to the founding of New Amsterdam in 1624 (NYSE, “History of NYSE”).

The two sources give the stockade different dates: 1624 for the NYSE, 1653 for the city archives, which quote the council’s minutes. This lesson uses 1653. The archives article leaves the exact origin of the street’s name to another post, which was not read.

1792: an agreement between 24 brokers

According to the NYSE, the Buttonwood Agreement was signed on 17 May 1792 by 24 brokers, “as a response to the first financial panic” in the young nation. It set rules for trading and set commissions, to “promote public confidence in the markets” and to ensure that deals were done between trusted parties. Trading nevertheless continued informally in nearby coffeehouses (NYSE).

1817: a call market

On 8 March 1817, the brokers adopted a constitution creating the New York Stock & Exchange Board, the forerunner of the NYSE. It set out detailed rules and fines for disorderly brokers. The new exchange rented a room at 40 Wall Street. The brokers met there twice a day to trade a list of 30 stocks and bonds: from the podium, the president called out each security in turn, and the brokers shouted bids and offers from the chairs assigned to them. This is the origin of the word “seat”, which has since meant a membership (NYSE).

Waiting your turn in a call marketFictional

A fictional exchange calls 30 securities, twice a day, at 2 minutes per security.

  1. Length of one call. 30 × 2 = 60 minutes to get through the list.
  2. Security no. 25. It is called after 24 × 2 = 48 minutes. A buyer who arrives at minute 50 has missed it.
  3. Next chance. At the second call of the day, several hours later.
  4. In a continuous market. Each security has its own spot and can be traded at any time during the session: the buyer no longer depends on the order of the list.

From memory: in 1817, how many times a day did the brokers meet, and how was a security traded?

1865-1886: continuous trading, the ticker, the telephone

In 1865, the exchange moved into its first permanent home, on part of its present Broad Street site. A few years later, rising volumes pushed it to switch to simultaneous trading in all stocks, in a continuous market: each stock was assigned to a fixed spot, and brokers moved around the floor to trade directly with one another (NYSE).

The price left the room. The NYSE dates the arrival of the stock ticker to 1867, which made it possible to send market information quickly across the United States. Its inventor, Edward Calahan, let exchanges send by telegraph the name and price of every stock sold (National Inventors Hall of Fame). In 1878, the exchange installed telephones; on 15 December 1886, more than a million shares changed hands in a single day for the first time (NYSE).

Stock ticker

A device linked to the telegraph that printed, far from the exchange, the name and price of each security traded.

Without looking back: what does the ticker give an investor in Chicago in 1870?

1903-1929: the great hall

In 1903, the exchange moved into the building designed by George B. Post. In 1928, a quotation department sent the latest prices to member firms continuously. On 29 October 1929, more than 16 million shares changed hands (NYSE): this is the crash that lesson 6 links to the birth of market regulators.

New York, from the wall to the great hall
  1. 1653

    The wallAmericas

    New Amsterdam surrounds itself with a stockade against the English.

  2. 1792

    Buttonwood AgreementAmericas

    24 brokers set rules and commissions, after a panic.

  3. 1817

    ConstitutionAmericas

    The New York Stock & Exchange Board settles at 40 Wall Street: a call market.

  4. 1865

    First permanent homeAmericas

    Then the move to continuous trading, each stock at its own spot.

  5. 1867

    Stock tickerAmericas

    The price of each trade goes out by telegraph.

  6. 1878

    TelephoneAmericas

    The exchange installs its first telephones.

  7. 1886

    A million sharesAmericas

    First day with more than a million shares traded, on 15 December.

  8. 1929

    CrashAmericas

    More than 16 million shares traded on 29 October.

The National Inventors Hall of Fame dates the invention of the ticker to 1863, the NYSE its introduction to 1867: the device may have been designed before it reached the exchange, but no source read says so. Also, one historical study considers the story that makes the Buttonwood Agreement the NYSE’s founding act a legend; this lesson therefore says the NYSE “traces” its birth to it.

Your turn

In 1817, at 40 Wall Street, securities were traded...

1In 1817, at 40 Wall Street, securities were traded...

Where does the word “seat” for an NYSE membership come from?

2Where does the word “seat” for an NYSE membership come from?

For an investor far from New York, the ticker mainly brought...

3For an investor far from New York, the ticker mainly brought...

The Buttonwood Agreement, which the NYSE treats as its birth, dates from...

4The Buttonwood Agreement, which the NYSE treats as its birth, dates from...

The constitution of the New York Stock & Exchange Board was adopted on...

5The constitution of the New York Stock & Exchange Board was adopted on...

Read next: NYSE, « History of NYSE »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further