Crashes: 1929, 2008, 2020
What makes a fall run away, what slows it, and why climbing back takes longer than falling.
Lesson 99 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain how forced sales make a crash run away
- Work out the rise needed to get back to the level before a fall
- Describe the role of circuit breakers in slowing a fall
In this lesson4
A crash is a sudden fall in prices, over a few days or weeks, when a crowd of investors wants to sell at the same time and buyers back away. Crashes are not alike, but they follow the same mechanics: a fear that spreads through forced sales, then brakes that slow it down. This lesson teaches you to recognise both.
Crash
A very large and very fast fall in prices across a whole market, when sell orders overwhelm buy orders.
Three crashes, sourced figures
Choose a year: the index plate drops to what is left of its peak, and the events roll by.
3 September 1929 → 8 July 1932
- Peak: 381.17 points. Many bought on credit, putting down 10%.
- Monday 28 October: almost −13% in one day. Tuesday 29: almost −12%.
- Mid-November: almost half the value has gone.
- 8 July 1932: 41.22 points, 89% below the peak.
- 1929. The Dow Jones peaked at 381.17 points on 3 September 1929. On Monday 28 October it lost nearly 13%, on Tuesday 29 nearly 12%; on 8 July 1932 it closed at 41.22 points, 89% below its peak. Many had bought on credit with a 10% deposit (Federal Reserve History, "Stock Market Crash of 1929").
- 2008. US house prices fell by about 30% from mid-2006 to mid-2009; Lehman Brothers bank filed for bankruptcy on 15 September 2008; the S&P 500 lost 57% between October 2007 and March 2009 (Federal Reserve History, "The Great Recession", "Support for Specific Institutions").
- March 2020. With the pandemic, US market-wide circuit breakers were triggered four times in the month, which the US Congressional Research Service calls unprecedented (CRS, Insight IN11339).
From memory: which crash made the Dow Jones lose 89%, and what had swollen buying beforehand?
Why the fall runs away
- Forced sales. Whoever bought on credit must sell when the price falls, to repay (lesson 8). Their sales push the price down further, which forces other borrowers to sell.
- Contagion. One failure brings others: those the company or bank owed money to are no longer paid. In 2008, the failure of Lehman Brothers raised fears for every bank that had dealt with it.
- The empty book. In an order book, buyers withdraw their orders or lower their limits; sellers accept any price. The equilibrium price drops very fast (lesson 7).
What slows the fall
- Circuit breakers. In the United States, an intraday fall in the S&P 500 of 7%, 13% or 20% halts all exchanges for 15 minutes, or stops them until the end of the day (CRS). The pause leaves time to read the information rather than sell in panic.
- Price limits. At the BVMAC, the official price list shows for each share an upper and a lower limit 10% around the reference price (official price list of 2 September 2026): one session cannot make a price fall without limit.
- Central banks. In 2008, the Fed cut its rate from 5.25% (September 2007) to 0-0.25% (December 2008); on 15 March 2020, it cut it again to 0-0.25% (Federal Reserve History, Fed statement). The Federal Reserve's own essay on 1929 judges, on the contrary, that its response at the time turned what might have been a short recession into the country's longest and deepest depression.
Circuit breaker
An automatic pause in trading when prices fall too far within the day. It does not remove the fall; it leaves time to think.
Climbing back takes longer than falling
Why −50% needs +100%Fictional
- The fall. An index goes from 1,000 to 500 points: −50%.
- The climb back. To get back to 1,000, it must gain 500 points from 500: 500 ÷ 500 = +100%.
- With 1929. From 41.22 to 381.17 points: 381.17 ÷ 41.22 ≈ 9.25. The index had to be multiplied by more than nine, about +825%, to regain its peak.
- The rule. After a fall of x%, you need a rise of more than x% to get back to the starting point, because you climb from a lower base.
Writing for the level before the fall and for the level after it, the rise needed to get back to the starting point is:
The exact size of the fall in US indices in February and March 2020 is not given here: only secondary sources were found. Past crashes do not say when the next will come, or whether there will be one: nobody knows. Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.
Without looking above: an index loses 20%. By how much must it rise to get back to where it started?
Your turn
Read next: Federal Reserve History, « Stock Market Crash of 1929 »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.