Skip to content
Criée

Crashes: 1929, 2008, 2020

What makes a fall run away, what slows it, and why climbing back takes longer than falling.

Lesson 99 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain how forced sales make a crash run away
  • Work out the rise needed to get back to the level before a fall
  • Describe the role of circuit breakers in slowing a fall
In this lesson4

A crash is a sudden fall in prices, over a few days or weeks, when a crowd of investors wants to sell at the same time and buyers back away. Crashes are not alike, but they follow the same mechanics: a fear that spreads through forced sales, then brakes that slow it down. This lesson teaches you to recognise both.

Crash

A very large and very fast fall in prices across a whole market, when sell orders overwhelm buy orders.

Three crashes, sourced figures

Choose a year: the index plate drops to what is left of its peak, and the events roll by.

Three crashes, three fallsDow Jones
Peak
Left11%

3 September 1929 → 8 July 1932

  1. Peak: 381.17 points. Many bought on credit, putting down 10%.
  2. Monday 28 October: almost −13% in one day. Tuesday 29: almost −12%.
  3. Mid-November: almost half the value has gone.
  4. 8 July 1932: 41.22 points, 89% below the peak.

From memory: which crash made the Dow Jones lose 89%, and what had swollen buying beforehand?

Why the fall runs away

  1. Forced sales. Whoever bought on credit must sell when the price falls, to repay (lesson 8). Their sales push the price down further, which forces other borrowers to sell.
  2. Contagion. One failure brings others: those the company or bank owed money to are no longer paid. In 2008, the failure of Lehman Brothers raised fears for every bank that had dealt with it.
  3. The empty book. In an order book, buyers withdraw their orders or lower their limits; sellers accept any price. The equilibrium price drops very fast (lesson 7).

What slows the fall

  • Circuit breakers. In the United States, an intraday fall in the S&P 500 of 7%, 13% or 20% halts all exchanges for 15 minutes, or stops them until the end of the day (CRS). The pause leaves time to read the information rather than sell in panic.
  • Price limits. At the BVMAC, the official price list shows for each share an upper and a lower limit 10% around the reference price (official price list of 2 September 2026): one session cannot make a price fall without limit.
  • Central banks. In 2008, the Fed cut its rate from 5.25% (September 2007) to 0-0.25% (December 2008); on 15 March 2020, it cut it again to 0-0.25% (Federal Reserve History, Fed statement). The Federal Reserve's own essay on 1929 judges, on the contrary, that its response at the time turned what might have been a short recession into the country's longest and deepest depression.

Circuit breaker

An automatic pause in trading when prices fall too far within the day. It does not remove the fall; it leaves time to think.

Climbing back takes longer than falling

Why −50% needs +100%Fictional

  1. The fall. An index goes from 1,000 to 500 points: −50%.
  2. The climb back. To get back to 1,000, it must gain 500 points from 500: 500 ÷ 500 = +100%.
  3. With 1929. From 41.22 to 381.17 points: 381.17 ÷ 41.22 ≈ 9.25. The index had to be multiplied by more than nine, about +825%, to regain its peak.
  4. The rule. After a fall of x%, you need a rise of more than x% to get back to the starting point, because you climb from a lower base.

Writing P0P_0 for the level before the fall and P1P_1 for the level after it, the rise hh needed to get back to the starting point is:

h=P0−P1P1h = \frac{P_0 - P_1}{P_1}

The exact size of the fall in US indices in February and March 2020 is not given here: only secondary sources were found. Past crashes do not say when the next will come, or whether there will be one: nobody knows. Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.

Without looking above: an index loses 20%. By how much must it rise to get back to where it started?

Your turn

What makes a crash run away is mainly...

1What makes a crash run away is mainly...

An index loses 50%. To get back to its level, it must gain...

2An index loses 50%. To get back to its level, it must gain...

A circuit breaker is used to...

3A circuit breaker is used to...

Which date marks the failure of Lehman Brothers?

4Which date marks the failure of Lehman Brothers?

How many times were US circuit breakers triggered in March 2020?

5How many times were US circuit breakers triggered in March 2020?

Read next: Federal Reserve History, « Stock Market Crash of 1929 »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further