A bubble inflates, then bursts
When the price leaves what the asset earns: displacement, boom, euphoria, burst. Credit amplifies everything.
Lesson 89 min
By the end of this lesson
- Define a bubble by the gap between price and intrinsic value
- Name the four stages of a bubble according to Kindleberger
- Work out the dividend yield and the loss on a purchase made on credit
In this lesson4
In a bubble, people no longer buy a share for what it earns, but because its price is rising and they hope to sell it for more. The price drifts away from what the asset earns, until the day buyers run out. This lesson teaches you to recognise that drift.
Speculative bubble
According to the Banque de France, there is a bubble "when the price of an asset rises excessively, beyond its intrinsic value", a rise "fuelled by speculative behaviour" (Banque de France, « Bulle spéculative », our translation).
Intrinsic value is what the asset really earns, through its dividends or rents. The Banque de France points out that it is hard to measure with certainty: often you only know a bubble was a bubble after it bursts.
The four stages
The Banque de France uses the four stages described by the economist Charles Kindleberger in 1978:
- Displacement. A climate of confidence in the economy pushes prices up moderately.
- Boom. "The initial rise leads to expectations of further price rises" and attracts new buyers.
- Euphoria. "The bubble feeds on itself, sustained by herd behaviour", sometimes by debt.
- Burst. "The bubble bursts when some investors' expectations change", often after an unforeseen event: growth forecasts revised down, a rise in policy rates.
Watch a bubble inflate on a fictional share, then burst. The value stays fixed; the price drifts away from it.
Value = 500 F dividend ÷ 5% required rate. Fictional prices and changes.
The economy is doing well, and so is Iroko. The price rises a little, close to its value.
From memory: name Kindleberger's four stages of a bubble, and one event that can burst it.
The sign that does not lie: what you pay for what you receive
Buying a share at 20,000 CFA francs that pays 500 CFA francsFictional
Iroko shares (fictional) pay a dividend of 500 CFA francs a year. A safe investment pays 5%. In full euphoria, they trade at 20,000 CFA francs.
- What the dividend yields. 500 ÷ 20,000 = 2.5% a year, half as much as the safe investment.
- What you need to earn 5%. 5% of 20,000 = 1,000 CFA francs over the year. The dividend brings 500; the other 500 must come from a rise in the price.
- The price you will need to find. You must sell for at least 20,000 + 500 = 20,500 CFA francs in a year.
- What this means. Your gain depends on a buyer ready to pay even more than you. The day there is none left, the price has no reason to stay above the value: 500 ÷ 0.05 = 10,000 CFA francs.
Writing for the annual dividend, for the share price and for the return on a safe investment, the dividend yield and the value that this dividend justifies in the lesson 1 model are:
Credit, accelerator of bubbles and falls
In 1929, in the United States, many share buyers put down "typically" only 10% of the price and borrowed the rest; borrowed money poured into the stock market and prices soared (Federal Reserve History, "Stock Market Crash of 1929"). Buying on credit multiplies gains, and losses.
A 10% fall with a 10% depositFictional
You buy 10,000 CFA francs of shares with 1,000 CFA francs of your own and 9,000 CFA francs borrowed.
- The price falls by 10%. Your shares are worth 9,000 CFA francs.
- You still owe 9,000 CFA francs. 9,000 − 9,000 = 0: your 1,000 CFA franc deposit has gone.
- The price falls by 20%. Your shares are worth 8,000, you owe 9,000: you are 1,000 CFA francs short, which you must repay.
When prices fall, borrowers must sell to repay, which pushes prices down further: this is what the Banque de France calls the "Minsky moment".
Buying with borrowed money can lose you more than your stake. A promise of quick gains because "everyone is buying" is a warning sign, not proof. Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.
The oldest bubble on record
In the United Provinces (today's Netherlands), between 31 December 1636 and 3 February 1637, the price of the most common tulip bulb was multiplied by twelve, before collapsing. The Banque de France notes that this "tulip crisis" is invoked at every new bubble, but that its scale is debated: some economists consider this speculation rational (Banque de France, « La crise des tulipes (1637) »).
Without looking above: a share pays 300 CFA francs a year and trades at 15,000 CFA francs; a safe investment pays 5%. What does the dividend yield, and what must you hope for to earn 5%?
Your turn
Read next: Banque de France, ABC de l’économie, « Bulle spéculative »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.