Skip to content
Criée

Crypto-assets: a price with no issuer who pays

Where their price comes from, what regulators say about them, and their status in the CEMAC zone.

Lesson 79 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain where the price of a token that pays no income comes from
  • Calculate the effect of a fall followed by a rise of the same percentage
  • Spot the warning signs and the framework set by the COSUMAF
In this lesson3

A share entitles you to part of the profits, a bond to coupons and a repayment. A crypto-asset may entitle you to nothing of the kind: nobody has then committed to pay you anything at all. What this lesson gives you: being able to explain where a crypto-asset's price comes from, what its status is in the CEMAC zone, and which risks regulators highlight.

A price with no issuer who pays

The COSUMAF general regulation speaks of digital assets, tokens defined by the regional financial market regulation (COSUMAF general regulation 2023, art. 336). For a token like the ones in this lesson, no company has promised a dividend or a repayment: its price depends only on what the next buyer will agree to pay.

Crypto-asset

A digital token that can be bought, held and transferred. Unlike a share or a bond, it may entitle you to no income and no repayment.

−50%, then +50%Fictional

You buy fictional tokens for 200,000 F.

  1. The price falls 50%. 200,000 × (1 − 0.50) = 100,000 F.
  2. The price rises 50%. 100,000 × (1 + 0.50) = 150,000 F.
  3. Outcome. After a fall and a rise of the same percentage, 50,000 F is missing, i.e. 25% of the stake. To get back to 200,000 F after −50%, you need +100%.

The more a price swings, the more this mechanism costs.

A token loses 80%. How much must it rise to get back to its starting price?

What regulators say

The three European supervisory authorities issued a joint warning on 17 March 2022: many crypto-assets are "highly risky and speculative" and are not suited to most retail consumers; consumers face the very real possibility of losing all their invested money, should be alert to misleading advertisements, including via social media and influencers, and particularly wary of promised fast or high returns; they have little recourse or protection (ESMA, EBA, EIOPA, 17 March 2022).

The risk does not come only from the price. In December 2022 the SEC charged the founder of the FTX platform with hiding the diversion of customers' funds to a related trading firm (SEC, press release 2022-219). When a platform holds your tokens, the balance on your screen is only a promise from it.

The life of a token (fictional)1/6

An advert promises everything

On social media a platform touts the fictional MANGO token: “+300% guaranteed”. Regulators urge caution about such promises of fast or high returns.

Status in the CEMAC zone

  • The financial market regulator. The COSUMAF general regulation defines digital asset service providers (DASPs: buying and selling, custody, trading platform, advice…) and makes their licence subject to conditions: adequate resources, sufficient capital, security, internal control and anti-money-laundering arrangements (COSUMAF general regulation 2023, definitions and art. 336).
  • The banking supervisor. According to the specialist legal press, COBAC decision D-2022/071 of 6 May 2022 forbids the zone's banks, financial, microfinance and payment institutions to hold, exchange or convert cryptocurrencies, or to settle related transactions in CFA francs; it refers to the Central African law of 22 April 2022 governing cryptocurrency (Droit Médias Finance).
  • The warnings. The same source reports a COSUMAF statement targeting unlicensed entities promising "100% to 500%" of the stake, and the suspension of the marketing of crypto-assets (Droit Médias Finance).

Two points are not confirmed. The text of the COBAC decision was not read directly, and the date of the COSUMAF statement (a 4 June) is given without a year by the source. We found neither a COSUMAF instruction detailing DASP licensing nor a list of licensed providers: do not infer from an advert that a platform is authorised in the zone. Check with the COSUMAF. Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.

Name two risks of a crypto-asset that do not exist, or not in the same way, for a unit of a licensed fund.

Your turn

Where does the price of a token that pays no income come from?

1Where does the price of a token that pays no income come from?

A token goes from 10,000 F to 5,000 F, then rises 50%. It is worth...

2A token goes from 10,000 F to 5,000 F, then rises 50%. It is worth...

An advert promises “+300% guaranteed” on a token. According to European regulators, that is...

3An advert promises “+300% guaranteed” on a token. According to European regulators, that is...

In the CEMAC zone, which text defines digital asset service providers?

4In the CEMAC zone, which text defines digital asset service providers?

A platform holds your tokens and freezes withdrawals. Your displayed balance is...

5A platform holds your tokens and freezes withdrawals. Your displayed balance is...

Read next: EBA, ESMA, EIOPA, mise en garde sur les cryptoactifs (17 mars 2022)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further