From voice to screen: showing a price, executing an order
Nasdaq shows prices in 1971, Toronto executes by computer in 1977; Paris, London, Tokyo and then New York empty their floors.
Lesson 58 min
By the end of this lesson
- Distinguish a system that shows prices from a system that executes orders
- Put the end of the trading floors in order, from Toronto to New York
- Say how the BRVM and the BVMAC trade today
The lesson “From open outcry to the screen” shows what an electronic order book changes: a written rule, price then time priority, instead of the voice. This one goes one step further back, into history. What you will take from it: computers first entered the exchange to show prices, then to execute orders, and it was the second step that emptied the trading floors, from Toronto to New York.
Open outcry
Trading where brokers gathered in a room strike deals by voice or hand signals, without recording who came first.
Showing a price
The 1867 ticker printed prices after the trade (lesson 4). In the 20th century, screens showed prices before the trade. In 1960, at the NYSE, an automated system replaced the quotation department, where clerks passed on the latest prices (NYSE).
On 8 February 1971, Nasdaq started: a system in which market makers in stocks not listed on an exchange updated their buying and selling prices on screen. Nasdaq calls itself the “first electronic stock market”, but at the start it was a quotation system: electronic execution came later (Nasdaq, 2021). The screen says at what price you can trade; the deal is still struck between people, often by telephone.
Executing an order
In 1977, the Toronto exchange launched what it presents as the world’s first “Computer Assisted Trading System” (CATS) (TMX Group, timeline). It was no longer just the price that went through the machine, but the meeting of buyer and seller.
Paris took up the same idea. From June 1986, its computerised continuous market, the CAC (“cotation assistée en continu”), was adapted from the Toronto system: it executed orders according to a priority set by time stamping and broadcast the five best offers; by the end of 1986, 36 stocks were traded on it (COB, 1986 annual report, p. 17).
The same order, two systemsFictional
Kossi (fictional) wants to buy 100 fictional Kapok shares. The screen shows a best selling offer at 1,010 FCFA.
- Display system. His broker reads 1,010 on screen, calls the market maker, negotiates and closes the deal by phone. If the price has moved in the meantime, he starts again.
- Execution system. His broker enters a buy order limited to 1,010. The machine matches it at once with the displayed offer: 100 × 1,010 = 101,000 FCFA, without a call.
- The difference. In the first case, the screen informs and a person makes the match; in the second, the machine makes the match, according to a rule everyone knows.
From memory: what sets the 1971 Nasdaq apart from Toronto’s CATS in 1977?
The floors empty
Once execution was handed to the machine, the trading room lost its purpose:
- London, 27 October 1986. The “Big Bang” completed its reforms; business left the floor for dealing rooms, in front of SEAQ screens, at a speed the Bank of England called “unexpected” (Bank of England, 1987).
- Paris, July 1987. Last session of the “corbeille” at the Palais Brongniart (INA).
- Toronto, 1995-1997. Its floor closed: it became the largest exchange in North America without a floor (TMX Group).
- Tokyo, 30 April 1999. The floor closed (JPX).
- New York, 2006. The merger with Archipelago, the first all-electronic exchange in the United States, brought the end of open outcry on the NYSE floor (NYSE).
- Chicago, 2015. CME Group announced the closure of most of its futures trading pits (CME Group).
On 23 March 2020, the NYSE operated for the first time with no trading floor at all, because of Covid-19; it partly reopened it on 26 May (NYSE).
- 1960
Automated quotationsAmericas
At the NYSE, a machine replaces the quotation department.
- 1971
NasdaqAmericas
Market makers’ prices appear on screen; the deal remains human.
- 1977
CATS in TorontoAmericas
The first computer assisted trading system, according to TMX.
- 1986
Paris and LondonEurope
The CAC, adapted from CATS, in June; London’s Big Bang on 27 October.
- 1987
End of the corbeilleEurope
Last open outcry session at the Palais Brongniart, in July.
- 1999
Tokyo and AbidjanWorld
Tokyo’s floor closes on 30 April; the BRVM has traded electronically since 24 March.
- 2006
New YorkAmericas
Open outcry disappears from the NYSE floor.
- 2015
ChicagoAmericas
CME Group closes most of its futures pits.
Without looking back: in what order did London, Tokyo and the NYSE give up open outcry?
And in the franc zone
The regional exchanges were born in the screen era. The BRVM moved to decentralised electronic trading on 24 March 1999, to daily trading on 12 November 2001 and to continuous trading on 16 September 2013 (BRVM, history); see “The BRVM: one exchange, eight branches”. The BVMAC trades electronically, by auction and continuously according to its general rules (BVMAC general rules 2025), with an auction every business day since late 2023 (Notice no. 057/2023/BVMAC/DG).
The exact closing date of the Toronto floor (often given as 23 April 1997) was only seen in secondary sources; TMX does not state it on its timeline. The text of CME Group’s 2015 press release could not be read. Finally, whether an open outcry session ever existed at the BVMAC or the Douala Stock Exchange is not confirmed.
Your turn
Read next: TMX Group, « Historical Timeline »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.