Skip to content
Criée

From brokers’ club to listed company

Four centuries of exchanges on one timeline, and the demutualisation that separates the right to trade from owning the exchange.

Lesson 28 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain who owns a mutual exchange and what demutualisation changes
  • Calculate a former member’s share of the capital after demutualisation
  • Identify who holds the right to trade on the BVMAC
In this lesson4

An exchange is itself a business: it organises the market, collects fees and must be licensed. For a long time it belonged to the brokers who traded on it; today most belong to shareholders, and some are listed. That shift is called demutualisation: it is what this lesson teaches.

Four centuries on one timeline

The timeline follows the dates that made the major venues, from Amsterdam to Abidjan. The plate under some dates says who owned the exchange at that moment.

Four centuries of exchanges1/19

Amsterdam

Transferable VOC shares are resold: a secondary market is born.

The dates come from the market operators themselves: LSEG for London (a price list at Jonathan's Coffee House in 1698, a regulated exchange in 1801), the NYSE for New York, JPX for Tokyo (1878), the JSE for Johannesburg (8 November 1887), the Shanghai Stock Exchange (26 November 1990) and Euronext (22 September 2000).

First, a members' club

On 17 May 1792, 24 brokers in New York signed the Buttonwood Agreement, which the NYSE treats as its date of birth (NYSE). In Nairobi, the exchange was registered in 1954 as a voluntary association of stockbrokers, where prices were negotiated by telephone (NSE). The principle is the same: only members may trade, and they are the ones who own the exchange.

Demutualisation

The change from an exchange owned by its members (the brokers who trade on it) to a joint-stock company whose shareholders can be anyone.

Then a company, sometimes listed

  • Tokyo, 1 November 2001: the exchange becomes a joint-stock company, Tokyo Stock Exchange, Inc. (JPX).
  • New York, 2006: the merger with Archipelago creates NYSE Group, a listed company, "ending member ownership"; in 2013 Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) buys the NYSE (NYSE).
  • Lagos, 2021: the Nigerian Stock Exchange becomes a public company limited by shares on 10 March 2021, then Nigerian Exchange Group Plc is listed on 15 October 2021 (NGX Group).

Why the change? A joint-stock company can raise capital to pay for its computer systems and buy other exchanges, and its decisions no longer depend on the brokers alone. In return, a listed exchange must also please its shareholders, hence closer public scrutiny.

A member's seat becomes sharesFictional

The Kribi exchange (fictitious) has 40 members, each owning one seat. It demutualises.

  1. Conversion. Each seat is swapped for 10,000 shares: 40 × 10,000 = 400,000 shares.
  2. New shareholder. An investor who is not a broker buys 60,000 new shares. Total: 460,000 shares.
  3. Their stake. 60,000 ÷ 460,000 ≈ 13% of the capital. They vote at meetings without ever trading on the market.
  4. The former members. Each goes from 1 seat in 40 (2.5%) to 10,000 ÷ 460,000 ≈ 2.2%.

The right to trade and the ownership of the exchange are now two separate things.

From memory: after demutualisation, do you need to be a shareholder of the exchange to trade on it, and do you need to trade on it to be a shareholder?

And in the franc zone

The African regional exchanges were born as companies. The BRVM and its central securities depository were set up on 18 December 1996 in Cotonou as private limited companies, and the BRVM started trading on 16 September 1998; its head office is in Abidjan (BRVM, history). The BVMAC is a limited company entrusted, "exclusively", with a "public service mission of organising, running and managing the Central African financial market", and must be licensed by COSUMAF (Regulation No. 01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF). Brokers there hold the monopoly on trading: ownership and the right to trade are separate from the start.

Without looking back: name three demutualised exchanges and the year they became so.

Your turn

A 'mutual' exchange belongs...

1A 'mutual' exchange belongs...

According to the NYSE, member ownership ended in...

2According to the NYSE, member ownership ended in...

Kribi (fictitious): 40 seats become 10,000 shares each, then 60,000 new shares are sold. A former member holds about...

3Kribi (fictitious): 40 seats become 10,000 shares each, then 60,000 new shares are sold. A former member holds about...

On the BVMAC, those who may trade are...

4On the BVMAC, those who may trade are...

Read next: NYSE, « History of NYSE »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further