Skip to content
Criée

Teacher sheet

Trading

Who it is for
Mixed audience from the final year of school to adults, especially those who see trading adverts; the four operations and percentages.
Prerequisites
  • Reading an order book: the “Reading an order book” lesson of the student course (/en/etudiant/), or failing that the First steps course (/en/lycee/).
  • Percentages and working out an average.
  • Recommended: the Investing section (/en/investir/) to compare with long-term investing.

Sessions

Session 1 · Styles, candlesticks and analysis75 min

  • Investing or trading: a question of horizon
    • Distinguish an investor from a trader by holding period and source of gain
    • Rank the four trading styles by holding period
    • Work out the cumulative cost of a year of round trips
  • Reading a candlestick
    • Read the open, close, high and low of a candlestick
    • Work out the height of a candlestick’s body and wicks
    • Explain why a daily candlestick at a call auction shrinks to a line
  • Fundamental and technical analysis
    • Distinguish fundamental from technical analysis by the question each asks
    • Work out a dividend yield and the price that gives a required yield
    • Explain how news enters the price through orders
  1. 10 min · Opening question: what are a share’s two sources of gain, and which one matters to a trader?
  2. 20 min · Reading of “Investing or trading”: the style timeline, rank the four styles from longest to shortest, cumulative cost of a year of round trips; quiz
  3. 20 min · Reading of “Reading a candlestick”: an animated session candlestick, body and wicks, and why a daily candlestick at a single auction is just a line; quiz
  4. 20 min · Reading of “Fundamental and technical analysis”: dividend yield, the price that gives a required yield, how news enters the price through orders; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes the question each type of analysis asks

Session 2 · Costs and stop orders60 min

  • What a round trip costs
    • Work out the spread from the best buyer and the best seller
    • Work out the loss on a round trip, spread and commissions included
    • Explain why a large order pays more than the displayed spread
  • Stop, stop-limit and trailing stop orders
    • Predict what a stop or stop-limit order becomes once triggered
    • Work out the average price obtained by a triggered stop order
    • Work out the stop price of a trailing stop after the price rises
  1. 5 min · Recall: one round trip a week for a year, how many times do you pay the spread?
  2. 20 min · Reading of “What a round trip costs”: spread, commissions, why a large order pays more than the quoted spread, the Barber and Odean study; quiz
  3. 20 min · Reading of “Stop orders”: have learners predict what happens to a triggered stop in the book before the animation, average price obtained, trailing-stop level; quiz
  4. 10 min · Debate: does a triggered sell stop guarantee the trigger price? Check with the animation and the AMF mediator case
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes what happens to a stop and a stop-limit when triggered

Session 3 · Leverage and position size60 min

  • Leverage and margin: an account that melts
    • Work out the size of a position from the deposit and the leverage
    • Work out the change in the account caused by a change in price
    • Work out the fall in price that triggers the forced close-out
  • Position size and reward-to-risk ratio
    • Work out a position size from the accepted loss and the stop
    • Work out a reward-to-risk ratio and the minimum win rate
    • Explain why the actual loss can exceed the planned loss
  1. 5 min · Recall: leverage of 5 and a price falling 4%; how much does the account fall?
  2. 20 min · Reading of “Leverage and margin”: the melting-account animation, position size, the fall that triggers forced closure with leverage of 30 and closure at 50%; quiz
  3. 20 min · Reading of “Position size and reward-to-risk ratio”: size from the accepted loss and the stop, minimum win rate for a ratio of 3; quiz
  4. 10 min · Pair exercise: position size for a fictional account, then comparing results and mistakes
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes why the actual loss can exceed the planned loss

Session 4 · Losses, psychology, summary and assessment75 min

  • What retail traders lose
    • Quote the share of losing accounts measured by ESMA on CFDs
    • Distinguish average loss from median loss in a regulator’s study
    • Work out the number of losing accounts from a displayed percentage
  • Overconfidence and the disposition effect
    • Recognise overconfidence and the disposition effect in a decision
    • Work out the rise needed to wipe out a fall in price
    • Explain why deciding before the trade limits the effect of both biases
  • Summary: trading
    • Recall the calculations for spread, leverage, position size and ratio
    • Compare what stop, stop-limit and trailing stop orders become when triggered
  1. 5 min · Recall: what range of losing accounts did ESMA publish for CFDs?
  2. 20 min · Reading of “What retail traders lose”: the hundred-accounts animation, mean and median loss, number of losing accounts from a percentage; quiz
  3. 15 min · Reading of “Overconfidence and the disposition effect”: spotting the two biases, and why deciding before the trade limits them; quiz
  4. 10 min · The “trading” summary: answer its two recall questions aloud (does the stop guarantee the price? leverage 20 and closure at 50%)
  5. 20 min · Assessment at /en/trading/evaluation/, alone and without notes: 15 questions drawn from the quizzes, 11 correct answers for the certificate, to print or photograph
  6. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes the rule they would set themselves before any trade

Tips

Quiz answer keys

44 questions, with the right answer and its explanation.

Investing or trading: a question of horizon

  1. A trader's gain comes mainly...

    → from the change in price

    The security is held too briefly to collect dividends: the trader wins or loses on the gap between buying and selling.

  2. A trader opens and closes every position within the same session. The style is...

    → day trading

    Day trading closes everything within the session; swing holds for days to weeks, position for months.

  3. Fictional cost of 0.2% per round trip, 100 round trips in the year. Cumulative cost?

    → 20% of the stake

    100 × 0.2% = 20% of the stake, to be earned before any profit.

  4. Why does day trading have nothing to grip on the BVMAC?

    → only one auction per day

    One auction a day gives one price per session: you cannot buy and sell at two different prices within the day.

  5. Scalping, swing, day trading and position are...

    → usages specific to the industry

    No regulator defines them: they are usage names, sorted by holding period.

Reading a candlestick

  1. Open 9,800, close 9,650. The body is...

    → red, 150 XAF tall

    Close below open: red body. Its height is 9,800 − 9,650 = 150 XAF.

  2. Open 10,000, close 10,100, high 10,250. The upper wick measures...

    → 150 XAF

    From the top of the body (the close, 10,100) to the high: 10,250 − 10,100 = 150 XAF.

  3. The colour of the body is decided by comparing...

    → the close with its open

    Green body if the close is above the open of the same period, red otherwise.

  4. A line chart of closing prices only loses...

    → the session's two extremes

    It keeps one price per period: the high and the low disappear.

  5. On a security auctioned once a day, the daily candle is...

    → a stroke without body

    One price per session: the four prices are equal and the drawing shrinks to a stroke.

Fundamental and technical analysis

  1. Dividend 300 XAF, price 6,000 XAF. The dividend yield is...

    → 5%

    300 ÷ 6,000 = 0.05, i.e. 5%.

  2. A trader decides by looking only at the price chart. This is...

    → technical analysis

    Technical analysis gets its information from the price chart, not from the accounts.

  3. After bad news, the new price is set by...

    → the book's orders

    Nobody sets the price: it comes from matching buy and sell orders.

  4. Dividend 450 XAF; you require 5%. The price that suits you is...

    → 9,000 XAF

    450 ÷ 0.05 = 9,000 XAF.

  5. On the BVMAC, news published at 14:00 enters the price...

    → at the next session

    The auction takes place once a day, at 11:00: the news waits for the next session.

What a round trip costs

  1. Best bid 4,980, best ask 5,020. The spread is...

    → 40 XAF

    5,020 − 4,980 = 40 XAF.

  2. You buy at market, then sell straight back at market. When buying, you pay...

    → the best ask price

    When buying, you take the seller's offer; when selling, you take the buyer's bid, which is lower.

  3. Buy 500,000 XAF, sell 494,000 XAF, fictional commission 1% on each order. Total loss?

    → 15,940 XAF

    Commissions: 5,000 + 4,940 = 9,940. Price gap: 6,000. Total: 15,940 XAF.

  4. Why can an order for 100 shares pay more than the displayed spread?

    → it empties the first ask level

    Beyond the quantity at the best level, the order executes at the next levels, dearer when buying, cheaper when selling.

Stop, stop-limit and trailing stop orders

  1. Once its stop price is reached, a stop order becomes...

    → a market order

    The stop becomes a market order; it is the stop-limit that becomes a limit order.

  2. Sell stop at 9,900; the engine fills 30 × 9,800 and 30 × 9,700. Average price?

    → 9,750 XAF

    (30 × 9,800 + 30 × 9,700) ÷ 60 = 585,000 ÷ 60 = 9,750 XAF.

  3. Stop-limit triggered, limit 9,850, best bid 9,800. What happens?

    → nothing sells, the order waits

    A sale limited to 9,850 refuses any lower price: the order joins the book and waits.

  4. Trailing stop 300 below the price. The price rises from 10,000 to 10,600. The stop is now...

    → 10,300 XAF

    The stop follows the rise at a fixed distance: 10,600 − 300 = 10,300 XAF.

  5. On the BVMAC, under the 2025 general rules, the orders admitted are...

    → limit and market orders only

    The rules admit the limit order and the market order; other types may be authorised later.

Leverage and margin: an account that melts

  1. Deposit 50,000 XAF, leverage 20. The position is worth...

    → 1,000,000 XAF

    20 × 50,000 = 1,000,000 XAF.

  2. Leverage 10, the price rises by 2%. The account...

    → gains 20%

    10 × 2% = 20%. Leverage multiplies gains too.

  3. Leverage 5, close-out when funds fall to 50% of margin. Price fall that closes the account?

    → 10%

    50% ÷ 5 = 10%.

  4. According to ESMA (2018), the maximum leverage on a CFD on an individual share is...

    → 5 to 1

    5:1 for individual shares; 30:1 is reserved for major currency pairs.

  5. After the close-out, the price climbs back above the purchase price. The account...

    → recovers nothing, the position is closed

    The position no longer exists: the price recovery no longer affects the account.

Position size and reward-to-risk ratio

  1. Capital 2,000,000 XAF, accepted loss 1%, distance to the stop 500 XAF. Size?

    → 40 shares

    2,000,000 × 1% = 20,000 XAF; 20,000 ÷ 500 = 40 shares.

  2. Entry 5,000, stop 4,800, target 5,600. The reward-to-risk ratio is...

    → 3

    Targeted gain 600, risk 200: 600 ÷ 200 = 3.

  3. Ratio of 1. Minimum win rate to avoid a loss, before costs?

    → 50%

    1 ÷ (1 + 1) = 50%.

  4. What mainly sets the planned maximum loss on a trade is...

    → the size and the stop

    Planned loss = number of shares × distance to the stop: both together.

  5. The stop is placed at 9,600. Can the real loss exceed the planned loss?

    → yes, the price is not guaranteed

    The stop triggers a market order, executed at the price the book offers, sometimes much lower.

What retail traders lose

  1. According to ESMA (2018), the share of retail accounts losing money on CFDs is...

    → 74 to 89%

    National authorities measured 74 to 89% of losing accounts.

  2. Average loss €10,900, median €1,843. This means that...

    → a few huge losses lift it

    An average far above the median signals a few very large losses.

  3. A provider shows “80% of accounts lose money” on 2,000 accounts. Losing accounts?

    → 1,600

    2,000 × 0.80 = 1,600 losing accounts.

  4. Among the traders the AMF followed for four years, over time the share of losers...

    → rises further

    More than 82% in the first year, nearly 88% over four years: experience did not help.

  5. For the CEMAC zone, the statistic on losses from leveraged products is...

    → not found so far

    No such statistic was found: the lesson's figures come from Europe and Brazil.

Overconfidence and the disposition effect

  1. The disposition effect is the tendency to...

    → keep the losers, sell the winners

    Odean observed it on 10,000 accounts: gains are banked quickly, losses are not realised.

  2. According to Barber and Odean, what can explain the excessive number of trades is...

    → their own overconfidence

    The authors link the high level of trading, and the poor performance, to overconfidence.

  3. A share bought at 10,000 is worth 7,500. Rise needed to get back to 10,000?

    → 33%

    (10,000 − 7,500) ÷ 7,500 = 2,500 ÷ 7,500 ≈ 33%.

  4. In the AMF study, clients who placed 1,000 orders or more lost on average...

    → more than the others

    €31,349 on average, against €18,741 for those with 250 orders or more: more orders, more losses.

  5. The counter common to both slopes is to...

    → decide before the trade

    Set the size, exit level and target in writing before buying, before emotion has a say.