Skip to content
Criée

Overconfidence and the disposition effect

Trading too often, holding on to losers: two slopes measured on thousands of accounts, and the counter.

Lesson 98 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Recognise overconfidence and the disposition effect in a decision
  • Work out the rise needed to wipe out a fall in price
  • Explain why deciding before the trade limits the effect of both biases
In this lesson3

The figures in the previous lesson do not come only from costs and leverage. They also come from two slopes of the mind that research has measured on thousands of accounts: believing yourself more skilful than you are, and refusing to sell at a loss. Recognising these two slopes, and the counter that neutralises them (deciding beforehand), is what this lesson teaches.

Overconfidence

Brad Barber and Terrance Odean studied 66,465 households at a discount broker from 1991 to 1996. The households that traded most earned 11.4% a year, while the market returned 17.9%; the average household turned over 75% of its portfolio every year. According to the authors, overconfidence can explain this level of trading and the poor performance that comes with it (Barber and Odean, Journal of Finance, 2000).

Overconfidence

The tendency to overrate one's knowledge or skill, which leads to trading too often.

What 6.5 points a year costFictional

Suppose, for illustration, that the study's rates repeat five years in a row, which nothing guarantees. Starting stake: 1,000,000 XAF.

  1. At the market's pace, 17.9%. 1,000,000 × 1.179 multiplied five times ≈ 2,278,080 XAF.
  2. At the most active traders' pace, 11.4%. 1,000,000 × 1.114 multiplied five times ≈ 1,715,639 XAF.
  3. Gap. 2,278,080 − 1,715,639 = 562,441 XAF, more than half the starting stake.

The AMF sees the same slope on forex and CFDs: clients who placed at least 250 orders in four years lost €18,741 on average; those who placed 1,000 or more, €31,349 (AMF, 2014). More orders, more losses.

From memory: in the Barber and Odean study, how much a year did the households that traded most earn, and how much did the market return?

The disposition effect

Terrance Odean analysed 10,000 accounts at a broker: investors show a strong preference for selling their winners rather than their losers, and this behaviour is not justified by subsequent performance (Odean, “Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses?”). This is the disposition effect: holding losers too long, selling winners too soon.

Disposition effect

The tendency to sell winning securities too soon and hold losing ones too long.

Roland has two holdings, a winner and a loser, and must sell one. Follow what he chooses.

The life of a losing position1/5

Two holdings, two moods

Roland bought 50 Kapok and 50 Baobab at 10,000. Kapok is worth 11,000 (+10%), Baobab 8,000 (−20%).

Roland's accountFictional

Roland holds 50 Kapok and 50 Baobab, fictional companies, each bought at 10,000.

  1. Kapok is worth 11,000: a paper gain of 50 × 1,000 = 50,000 XAF.
  2. Baobab is worth 8,000: a paper loss of 50 × 2,000 = 100,000 XAF.
  3. He sells Kapok. He banks a 50,000 XAF gain and keeps a 100,000 XAF paper loss.
  4. What Baobab needs to get back to 10,000. (10,000 − 8,000) ÷ 8,000 = a 25% rise, although it only lost 20%.

Roland's purchase price matters to no buyer. The only useful question: would he buy Baobab at 8,000 today?

Writing P0P_0 for the purchase price and P1P_1 for the price after the fall, the rise hh needed to get back to the purchase price is:

h=P0−P1P1h = \frac{P_0 - P_1}{P_1}

The counter: decide beforehand

Both slopes have one thing in common: they act during the trade, when the price moves and emotion speaks. The counter is to decide everything beforehand, in writing:

  1. the accepted loss and the position size (lesson 7);
  2. the exit level for a loss and the target;
  3. the maximum number of trades in the week, to curb overconfidence;
  4. a trading journal, reread every month, to compare what you think you do with what you do.

The studies cited cover the United States (1991 to 1996) and France (2009 to 2012); no comparable study of investors in the CEMAC zone was found. Knowing your biases does not remove them, and no plan makes trading profitable: it limits decisions taken in the heat of emotion.

Without looking above: what is the disposition effect, and which question helps you escape it?

Your turn

The disposition effect is the tendency to...

1The disposition effect is the tendency to...

According to Barber and Odean, what can explain the excessive number of trades is...

2According to Barber and Odean, what can explain the excessive number of trades is...

A share bought at 10,000 is worth 7,500. Rise needed to get back to 10,000?

3A share bought at 10,000 is worth 7,500. Rise needed to get back to 10,000?

In the AMF study, clients who placed 1,000 orders or more lost on average...

4In the AMF study, clients who placed 1,000 orders or more lost on average...

The counter common to both slopes is to...

5The counter common to both slopes is to...

Read next: Odean, « Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses? »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further