Skip to content
Criée

What a round trip costs

Spread and commissions: buying then selling straight back loses money, even when the price does not move.

Lesson 48 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Work out the spread from the best buyer and the best seller
  • Work out the loss on a round trip, spread and commissions included
  • Explain why a large order pays more than the displayed spread
In this lesson4

Buy a security and sell it straight back, without the market moving: you have lost money. This is not a trap, it is the price of a round trip, made of two parts: the book's spread and the intermediary's commissions. Knowing how to work it out is what this lesson teaches, and it is the first thing a trader must earn before earning anything at all.

The spread, the first cost

In a book, the best buyer and the best seller do not show the same price. The gap between them is the spread. Whoever buys right away pays the seller's price; whoever sells right away receives the buyer's price. Doing both in a row means paying the whole spread once.

Writing vv for the best selling price and aa for the best buying price, the spread FF is:

F=v−aF = v - a

Round trip

A purchase followed by the sale of the same security. Its cost combines the spread and the commissions on both orders.

Commissions, the second cost

The AMF lists custody fees and brokerage fees among the costs of investing in shares, and encourages comparing firms (AMF guide to shares). Brokerage is paid on every order: twice per round trip.

The fee schedules of brokers in the CEMAC zone are not given here: no consolidated public schedule was found. The 0.5% commission in the scene is fictional; ask your intermediary for its schedule before any order.

The life of a round trip

Nadège buys 100 shares at market, changes her mind and sells them at market straight away. The trades are computed by the portal's matching engine on a fictional book.

The life of a round trip1/6

Two prices on display

Best bid 9,950, best ask 10,050: a spread of 100. The “middle” price, 10,000, is offered to nobody.

Nadège's account, step by stepFictional

Book: best bid 9,950, best ask 10,050, spread 100. Fictional commission: 0.5% of each order.

  1. Buy 100 at market. The engine fills 60 × 10,050 then 40 × 10,100: 603,000 + 404,000 = 1,007,000 XAF, i.e. 10,070 on average.
  2. Buy commission. 1,007,000 × 0.5% = 5,035 XAF.
  3. Sell 100 at market. 60 × 9,950 then 40 × 9,900: 597,000 + 396,000 = 993,000 XAF, i.e. 9,930 on average.
  4. Sell commission. 993,000 × 0.5% = 4,965 XAF.
  5. Result. Paid 1,007,000 + 5,035 = 1,012,035; got back 993,000 − 4,965 = 988,035. Loss: 24,000 XAF, i.e. 24,000 ÷ 1,007,000 ≈ 2.4%.

The displayed price did not move. To break even, the share would have had to rise by about 2.4% between buying and selling.

Look at step 1: Nadège's quantity is larger than the first ask level (60 shares), so the engine climbs one level for the next 40. A displayed spread of 100 XAF actually costs 10,070 − 9,930 = 140 XAF per share on the round trip. The bigger the order relative to the book, the wider the gap.

From memory: what makes up the cost of a round trip, and why does a large order pay more than the displayed spread?

What frequency costs

Barber and Odean followed 66,465 households at a discount broker from 1991 to 1996: those who traded most earned 11.4% a year, while the market returned 17.9% (Journal of Finance, 2000). FINRA, for its part, points out that frequent trading brings higher costs that erode returns (FINRA, 2026).

Ten round trips in a monthFictional

Each of Nadège's round trips costs about 2.4% of the stake. Ten round trips in a month, on a stake of 1,000,000 XAF committed each time: 10 × 24,000 = 240,000 XAF of costs, i.e. 24% of the stake, to be won back through price rises before the first franc of profit.

Without looking above: what does the Barber and Odean study show about the households that trade most?

Your turn

Best bid 4,980, best ask 5,020. The spread is...

1Best bid 4,980, best ask 5,020. The spread is...

You buy at market, then sell straight back at market. When buying, you pay...

2You buy at market, then sell straight back at market. When buying, you pay...

Buy 500,000 XAF, sell 494,000 XAF, fictional commission 1% on each order. Total loss?

3Buy 500,000 XAF, sell 494,000 XAF, fictional commission 1% on each order. Total loss?

Why can an order for 100 shares pay more than the displayed spread?

4Why can an order for 100 shares pay more than the displayed spread?

Read next: Barber et Odean, « Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth », Journal of Finance (2000)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further