Fundamental and technical analysis
Two different questions, one mechanism: news only enters the price through orders.
Lesson 39 min
By the end of this lesson
- Distinguish fundamental from technical analysis by the question each asks
- Work out a dividend yield and the price that gives a required yield
- Explain how news enters the price through orders
In this lesson2
A company announces a smaller dividend than expected. An analyst opens the accounts and redoes her sums; a trader looks at his chart and sees red candles. Both will sell, for different reasons. These two ways of deciding have names: fundamental analysis and technical analysis. Telling them apart, and seeing how news enters the price through their orders, is what this lesson teaches.
Two different questions
Fundamental analysis asks: what is this security worth? It starts from what the issuer earns, pays out and expects, and from the economy around it. CME Group's course grounds it in supply and demand and in economic data, such as employment reports (CME Group, “Fundamental Analysis”). The AMF asks the same of shareholders: find out about the company, its prospects and its environment, through its publications, the press and analysts' notes (AMF guide to shares).
Technical analysis asks: where is the price going? According to the same CME Group course, the technical analyst gets information from the market itself, from a single picture, the price chart; the two approaches are often combined (CME Group, “Fundamental Analysis vs Technical Analysis”).
Fundamental analysis
Estimating what a security is worth from what the issuer earns, pays out and expects, and from its economy.
Technical analysis
Looking for clues about coming moves in the chart of past prices and volumes.
CME Group's pages were read in search engine extracts, as the page blocks direct loading.
The analyst's sumFictional
Kapok, a fictional company, trades at 12,000 XAF. It used to pay a dividend of 600 XAF per share; it announces 450.
- Before. Dividend yield at the current price: 600 ÷ 12,000 = 5%.
- After. 450 ÷ 12,000 = 3.75%. At the same price, the share yields less.
- The price that would yield 5%. 450 ÷ 5% = 450 ÷ 0.05 = 9,000 XAF.
If the analyst requires 5%, the share is now worth only 9,000 XAF to her. She will sell at 12,000 and will not buy until the price falls. This is only one line of reasoning among others: another analyst may expect the dividend to recover.
Writing for the dividend per share, for the share price and for the dividend yield, the price that gives a required yield comes from turning the division round:
From memory: what question does each of the two analyses ask?
The life of a piece of news
Neither the analyst nor the trader sets the price. They place orders, and the book does the rest. In the scene, the sales that follow the announcement go through the portal's matching engine: the price drop is computed, not written in advance.
The results come out
Kapok publishes its accounts: the proposed dividend falls from 600 to 450 per share.
The price fell from 12,000 to 11,700 in three orders. It does not drop straight to 9,000: it stops where the remaining buyers agree to pay. The mechanism is the same for any news, whether company accounts, a central bank decision or a political speech: information only moves the price through the orders of those who read it.
Reading the fallFictional
- Change. (11,700 − 12,000) ÷ 12,000 = −300 ÷ 12,000 = −2.5%.
- For a holder of 100 shares. 100 × 300 = 30,000 XAF of unrealised loss, within minutes.
- What is still missing. The analyst's price of 9,000 is far off: if others share her reasoning, more sales may follow; if they do not, the fall may stop here.
On the BVMAC, which trades by auction once a day (BVMAC, session times), news published after 11:00 can only enter the price at the next session's auction: orders build up until then.
Without looking above: by what route does news change the price?
Your turn
Read next: AMF, « Pourquoi et comment investir en direct en actions cotées ? »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.