What retail traders lose
ESMA and AMF figures on leveraged products, and how to read them without distorting them.
Lesson 88 min
By the end of this lesson
- Quote the share of losing accounts measured by ESMA on CFDs
- Distinguish average loss from median loss in a regulator’s study
- Work out the number of losing accounts from a displayed percentage
Trading adverts show winners. Regulators, for their part, have counted every account. What they measured on leveraged products sold to retail clients, and how to read those figures without distorting them, is what this lesson teaches.
What the regulators measured
- ESMA, March 2018. According to national authorities' analyses, 74 to 89% of retail accounts typically lose money on CFDs, with average losses per client of €1,600 to €29,000 (ESMA, 27 March 2018).
- AMF, October 2014. A study of 14,799 active retail clients of authorised firms, on forex, binary options and CFDs from 2009 to 2012: over four years, more than 89% lost money; average loss of nearly €10,900 per client, median loss of €1,843; over a single year, 75 to 89% lost money depending on the firm, close to 84% across all firms (AMF, Savings Observatory letter no. 10).
- Brazil, academic study. Among people who started day trading index futures between 2013 and 2015 and kept going for more than 300 days, 97% lost money, and only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller (Chague, De-Losso and Giovannetti, 2019).
ESMA 2018, CFDs in Europe, low end of the range: 74 accounts in 100 lose.
Red: losing account. Green: winning or break-even account. Europe and Brazil: no comparable statistic was found for the CEMAC zone.
From memory: what range of losing accounts did ESMA publish for CFDs in 2018?
Reading the figures
Mean and median. The AMF's average loss (nearly €10,900) is far higher than the median (€1,843): a few very large losses pull the average up. Half the clients lost less than €1,843, the other half more.
Winners and losers in the AMF studyFictional
Over four years, 13,224 clients lost nearly €175 million in total; the other 1,575 gained €13.8 million in total.
- Average loss per loser. 175,000,000 ÷ 13,224 ≈ €13,234.
- Average gain per winner. 13,800,000 ÷ 1,575 ≈ €8,762.
- Collective result. 13.8 − 175 = −€161.2 million.
- Share of winners. 1,575 ÷ 14,799 ≈ 10.6%, about one client in ten.
The winners were not only rare: on average they gained less than the losers lost.
Persevering does not help. The AMF followed the roughly 2,000 traders active in each of the four years: more than 82% lost money in 2009 (average loss €4,989), more than 85% over two years (€10,183), nearly 88% over four years (€26,745). The Brazilian study finds no evidence of learning either.
A range, not a single figure. “74 to 89%” groups several countries and providers. That is why ESMA requires every CFD provider to show a standardised warning with its own percentage of losing accounts (ESMA, 1 June 2018): that is the figure to read on a European provider's page.
What “76% of accounts lose money” meansFictional
A fictional provider has 5,000 retail accounts. 76% losing: 5,000 × 0.76 = 3,800 losing accounts, 1,200 not losing. This percentage describes the provider's past, not your chances: it says nothing about which of the 1,200 won by luck.
And in the CEMAC zone?
No statistic on retail losses from leveraged products was found for the CEMAC zone: the figures above come from Europe and Brazil. COSUMAF points out that placing financial instruments with the public is a regulated investment service, subject to prior authorisation (COSUMAF statement).
According to the press, in 2021 COSUMAF warned against companies raising funds without authorisation by promising “100% to 500% of the initial stake”, and pointed to the list of authorised intermediaries on its website (Financial Afrik, 5 June 2021). This comes from a press source, not from COSUMAF's own text. The AMF describes adverts promising quick and large gains as often misleading (AMF, 2014). Nothing in this lesson is investment advice.
Without looking above: what does the AMF's follow-up of “persevering” traders show?
Your turn
Read next: AMF, Lettre de l’Observatoire de l’épargne n°10, « Forex : les particuliers perdants » (2014)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.