Skip to content
Criée

Teacher sheet

Market infrastructure

Who it is for
Mixed audience: curious pupils for the first lessons, finance students, developers of matching engines or post-trade software; calculations with the four operations.
Prerequisites
  • “From order to settlement” and “COSUMAF, BVMAC, BEAC: who does what” in the student course (/en/etudiant/).
  • Reading an order book: “Reading an order book” in the same course.
  • Recommended for developers: The market in code course (/en/developpeur/).

Sessions

Session 1 · From open outcry to the depository75 min

  • From open outcry to the screen
    • Apply price then time priority to say which order is filled first
    • Describe what the CAC system transmitted, executed and published in 1986
    • Place the move from open outcry to screens in Paris and London
  • After execution: four stages
    • Distinguish the commitment created by trading from the transfer made at settlement
    • Recognise clearing among the four stages of post-trade
    • Name the post-trade institutions of CEMAC and the role of the BEAC
  • Central depository and account keepers
    • Distinguish the accounts kept by the central depository and by the account keeper
    • Check the two reconciliation equalities after a transfer of shares
    • Explain in what form a dematerialised security exists
  1. 10 min · Opening question: “An order has just been executed. Does the seller already have the money?” Vote, and keep the answer
  2. 20 min · Reading of “From open outcry to the screen”: the open-outcry animation, why Chantal is served first, what the CAC system did in 1986; quiz
  3. 20 min · Reading of “After execution: four stages”: commitment and transfer, how many securities and how much cash move, CEMAC post-trade institutions; back to the vote; quiz
  4. 20 min · Reading of “Central depository and account keepers”: a security on two levels, who knows whom, the two reconciliation equalities; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes the four post-trade stages in order

Session 2 · Delivering, clearing, making markets80 min

  • Delivery versus payment
    • Distinguish principal risk from replacement-cost risk
    • Calculate the loss of a seller protected by delivery versus payment
    • Date the start of T+1 settlement in the United States
  • Netting and absorbing a default
    • Calculate each member’s multilateral balance from its debts and claims
    • Order the resources of the default waterfall and calculate the remaining loss
    • State which defaults a clearing house must be able to cover
  • The market maker’s job
    • Calculate the gain on a round trip from the spread and the quantity
    • Explain how a market maker shifts its prices to run down its inventory
    • State when a market maker’s spread tends to be narrow
  1. 10 min · Day’s review at /en/revision/: everyone answers the questions that are due, then the ones several people missed are corrected aloud
  2. 20 min · Reading of “Delivery versus payment”: a default with and without DvP in the animation, principal risk and replacement risk, the move from T+3 to T+1; quiz
  3. 25 min · Reading of “Netting and absorbing a default”: build the matrix of debts on the board before the animation, each member’s multilateral balance, the default waterfall; quiz
  4. 20 min · Reading of “The market maker’s job”: the gain on a round trip, what Kadi does with her two prices when she has bought too much; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes why a seller protected by DvP loses at worst the replacement cost

Session 3 · Algorithms, venues and data80 min

  • Algorithms and high-frequency trading
    • Distinguish algorithmic trading, high-frequency trading and simple order routing under MiFID II
    • Explain the part played by the price-blind instruction and the halt on 6 May 2010
    • Calculate the proceeds of a market sale that crosses several levels of the book
  • Several venues for one security
    • Distinguish a regulated market, a multilateral trading facility and a dark pool
    • Calculate the cost of a purchase routed to the best price of two venues
    • Explain why fragmentation between venues does not exist at the BVMAC
  • Reading market data
    • Calculate the mid price from the best limit on each side
    • Calculate the real cost of a large order by reading the depth of the book
    • Distinguish the last price, the top of the book and the consolidated tape
  1. 10 min · Recall: in what order does the default waterfall use its resources?
  2. 25 min · Reading of “Algorithms and high-frequency trading”: the three features of HFT under MiFID II, the price-blind instruction and the halt of 6 May 2010, proceeds of a market sell walking the book; quiz
  3. 20 min · Reading of “Several venues for one security”: regulated market, multilateral system and dark pool, cost of a routed buy, the BVMAC case; quiz
  4. 20 min · Reading of “Reading market data”: mid price, true cost of a large order, last price, top of book and consolidated tape; quiz
  5. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone writes why the naive estimate understates the cost of a large order

Session 4 · Summary and assessment45 min

  • Summary sheet: market infrastructure
    • Recall the nine key ideas and the formulas of the infrastructure section
    • Separate what the sources confirm from what remains unconfirmed in CEMAC
  1. 10 min · Day’s review at /en/revision/: everyone answers the questions that are due, then the ones several people missed are corrected aloud
  2. 15 min · The “market infrastructure” summary: in pairs, explain in three sentences why a seller does not deliver before being paid, then sort what is confirmed and unconfirmed in the CEMAC
  3. 15 min · Assessment at /en/infrastructure/evaluation/, alone and without notes: 15 questions drawn from the quizzes, 11 correct answers for the certificate, to print or photograph
  4. 5 min · Wrap-up: everyone notes the concept to review

Tips

Quiz answer keys

36 questions, with the right answer and its explanation.

From open outcry to the screen

  1. On an electronic book, at the same price, the order served first is...

    → the one that arrived earliest

    Time priority is applied by time-stamping: at the same price, the first to arrive is the first served.

  2. According to the COB, the CAC system broadcast in real time...

    → the five best offers, with sizes

    The 1986 report mentions the five best limit offers to buy and to sell with their sizes.

  3. The Paris CAC system had been adapted from a system...

    → of the Toronto exchange

    The COB writes that it was adapted from the CATS system used by the Toronto Stock Exchange.

  4. The Bank of England found the speed of the London floor's decline...

    → faster than expected

    The 1987 bulletin calls the speed at which the floor lost importance unexpected.

After execution: four stages

  1. Right after trading, the buyer holds...

    → a right to receive the shares

    Trading creates a commitment; the shares only reach the buyer's account at settlement.

  2. Replacing many trades with one balance per participant is...

    → clearing

    Clearing works out what each party really has to deliver and pay.

  3. The 2012 PFMI contain...

    → twenty-four principles

    The PFMI contain 24 principles, published by the BIS and IOSCO.

  4. In the CEMAC, the financial market's settlement bank is...

    → the BEAC, on an interim basis

    The BEAC has held this role on an interim basis since 2019, together with that of central securities depository.

Central depository and account keepers

  1. The central securities depository keeps an account...

    → for each account keeper

    In indirect holding, the depository knows the keepers; each one then keeps its clients' accounts.

  2. In the CEMAC, account keeping is reserved for...

    → credit institutions and brokerage firms

    Article 162 of Regulation 01/22 reserves it for credit institutions and brokerage firms licensed for it.

  3. A transfer of 40 shares between two keepers, at the depository, changes the total issued by...

    → exactly zero shares

    One account is debited and the other credited by the same number: the total stays that of the issue.

  4. A dematerialised share exists in the form of...

    → an entry in an account

    The PFMI describe dematerialised securities as electronic records only.

Delivery versus payment

  1. Delivering a security without being paid exposes you to...

    → principal risk

    Principal risk is the risk of losing the whole value of the trade.

  2. With delivery versus payment, the security is delivered...

    → if and only if payment occurs

    The two legs are linked: one does not happen without the other.

  3. A sale of 50 shares at 8,000, the buyer defaults, the price falls to 7,800. With delivery versus payment, the seller loses...

    → 10,000 XAF

    He keeps his shares and sells them 200 XAF cheaper: 50 × 200 = 10,000 XAF.

  4. In the United States, the standard settlement cycle moved to T+1...

    → in May 2024

    The rule, adopted in February 2023, applies to transactions from 28 May 2024.

Netting and absorbing a default

  1. A owes 300 to B, B owes 300 to C, C owes 300 to A. With multilateral netting, the amount to pay is...

    → nothing at all

    Each receives as much as it pays: all three balances are zero.

  2. The first resource used when a member defaults is...

    → the defaulter's initial margin

    The defaulter pays first with what it posted; the other members are called on last.

  3. A clearing house that is systemically important in several jurisdictions must cover the default...

    → of its two largest members

    PFMI principle 4 then requires it to cover the two participants that would create the largest exposure.

  4. Loss of 700,000; defaulter's margin 500,000; its share of the fund 100,000. Still to cover...

    → 100,000 XAF

    700,000 − 500,000 − 100,000 = 100,000 XAF, then taken from the clearing house's own funds.

The market maker’s job

  1. A market maker quotes 4,990 bid and 5,010 ask, 100 shares. One full round trip earns it...

    → 2,000 XAF

    A spread of 20 XAF per share, on 100 shares: 2,000 XAF.

  2. A market maker that has piled up too many shares will tend to...

    → lower both its prices

    By lowering both prices, it attracts buyers and discourages sellers: its inventory runs down.

  3. According to the BIS, a spread tends to be narrow when the market maker expects to...

    → trade quickly and cheaply

    Spreads are narrow when market makers believe they can trade quickly and cheaply.

  4. On the BVMAC, the specialist brokerage firm for a security is appointed...

    → on the issuer's proposal

    The BVMAC appoints it on the issuer's proposal (BVMAC general regulation 2025, art. 139).

Algorithms and high-frequency trading

  1. Software that only routes orders to the exchange is, under MiFID II...

    → neither of the two

    The definition excludes systems that merely route or confirm orders.

  2. On 6 May 2010, the large seller's algorithm targeted...

    → a share of recent volume

    It targeted 9% of the previous minute's volume, without regard to price or time.

  3. The E-Mini contract stabilised after...

    → a five-second trading pause

    The automatic CME mechanism paused the contract for 5 seconds, at 2:45:28 p.m.

  4. Book: 30 at 9,950, 30 at 9,900. A market sale of 40 brings in...

    → 397,500 XAF

    30 × 9,950 + 10 × 9,900 = 298,500 + 99,000 = 397,500 XAF.

Several venues for one security

  1. An MTF differs from a regulated market mainly in...

    → who may legally operate it

    An MTF may be operated by an investment firm; its rules remain non-discretionary.

  2. According to FINRA, a dark venue does not display...

    → its orders before execution

    It shows neither the presence, nor the price, nor the size of orders before the trade; trades are reported afterwards.

  3. A offers 20 shares at 5,000, B 30 shares at 4,990. To buy 30 shares at the best price, you pay...

    → 149,700 XAF

    B's 30 shares at 4,990 are enough: 30 × 4,990 = 149,700 XAF.

  4. In the CEMAC, trading on the BVMAC is the monopoly of...

    → brokerage firms

    Brokerage firms licensed by the COSUMAF have the monopoly of trading on the BVMAC.

Reading market data

  1. Best bid 4,980, best ask 5,020. The mid price is...

    → 5,000

    (4,980 + 5,020) ÷ 2 = 5,000.

  2. The last price tells you...

    → the price of the last trade

    It tells you what happened, not what is still possible: for that, you need the book.

  3. Asks: 30 at 2,000, 30 at 2,010. Buying 50 shares costs...

    → 100,200 XAF

    30 × 2,000 + 20 × 2,010 = 60,000 + 40,200 = 100,200 XAF.

  4. A consolidated tape is used to...

    → combine data from all venues

    It provides a consolidated view of activity across all venues trading the same security.