Skip to content
Criée

Netting and absorbing a default

The clearing house cuts the amounts to settle and sets in advance who pays if a member defaults.

Lesson 59 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate each member’s multilateral balance from its debts and claims
  • Order the resources of the default waterfall and calculate the remaining loss
  • State which defaults a clearing house must be able to cover
In this lesson4

The derivatives section showed that a clearing house, also called a central counterparty, becomes the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer (lesson on the clearing house). This lesson looks at what it does with that position. What you will learn: by stepping in, it can net all the trades of all its members at once, which sharply reduces the amounts to settle, and it sets in advance, in a waterfall, who pays and in what order if a member defaults.

Netting among many

The PFMI put it in one sentence: central counterparties, that is clearing houses, can significantly reduce participants' risks through the multilateral netting of trades and by imposing more effective risk controls on all participants; they require collateral, the initial margin, and may mutualise certain risks through a default fund (CPSS-IOSCO, PFMI, 2012, §1.13). Netting in general replaces obligations with balances, which reduces the number and value of payments and deliveries (§3.1.7).

Multilateral netting

Working out, for each participant, a single net balance against all the others, instead of all its debts and claims one by one.

In plain wordsThe market's tangled debts

Imagine five traders at the same market who all owe each other money: one for fish, another for rice, a third for cloth. If each paid every debt one by one, money would go back and forth dozens of times. Instead, a trusted person works out each trader's position: everything owed to her, minus everything she owes. In the end a few pay in their balance, the others receive theirs, and everything is settled with far less money moving. Except that everything then rests on that one person: that is why the clearing house demands collateral and sets out a written order in case of default.

Writing SkS_k for the balance of member kk, RkR_k for everything owed to it and DkD_k for everything it owes:

Sk=Rk−DkS_k = R_k - D_k

A positive balance is to be received, a negative one to be paid.

Three brokerage firms, one dayFictional

At the end of the day, the fictional brokerage firms A, B and C owe each other:

  • A owes 500,000 XAF to B;
  • B owes 400,000 XAF to C;
  • C owes 300,000 XAF to A;
  • B owes 200,000 XAF to A.
  1. Gross. Four payments: 500,000 + 400,000 + 300,000 + 200,000 = 1,400,000 XAF.
  2. Pair by pair. Between A and B, 500,000 − 200,000 = 300,000 from A to B. B to C 400,000 and C to A 300,000 remain. Total: 1,000,000 XAF.
  3. All together. A: receives 300,000 + 200,000, pays 500,000, balance 0. B: receives 500,000, pays 600,000, balance −100,000. C: receives 400,000, pays 300,000, balance +100,000.
  4. What really moves. B pays 100,000 XAF to the clearing house, which passes it to C. We go from 1,400,000 to 100,000 XAF, fourteen times less.

From memory: in the example, why does firm A have nothing to pay or receive?

When a member stops paying

Less money to settle also means a clearing house that concentrates risk: if it falls, the whole market falls. So the principles require two things of it.

Enough resources. Every clearing house must be able to withstand the default of the participant, with its affiliates, that would create its largest exposure in extreme but plausible conditions; one that is systemically important in several jurisdictions or has a more complex risk profile must cover the default of the two largest (PFMI, principle 4).

A written order. Prefunded resources are used in sequence, the “waterfall”: the defaulter's initial margin, its contribution to the default fund, a portion of the clearing house's own funds, then the other participants' contributions; the rules must set out this waterfall in advance (PFMI, §3.4.17 and §3.4.24).

Default waterfall

The order, set in advance, in which a clearing house draws on its resources to cover the loss left by a defaulting member, starting with what that member itself posted.

The life of a default down the waterfall

Fictional member D defaults and leaves a loss of 900,000 XAF. Follow the loss as it melts away, level by level.

The life of a default down the waterfall1/6

A member stops paying

Member D defaults. To close out its positions at today’s prices, the clearing house must cover a loss of 900,000 XAF.

The defaulter pays first. Members who did nothing wrong pay last: that is why they have an interest in the clearing house requiring sufficient margin from everyone.

In the CEMAC zone

The 2022 regulation provides for a clearing house, the market's central counterparty, which “monitors positions, calls margins and, where necessary, liquidates its members' positions”; it is a credit institution licensed by the COSUMAF after consulting the BEAC and the COBAC, and credit institutions and brokerage firms of the CEMAC may join it (Regulation No. 01/22, art. 130 to 134).

Whether a clearing house is currently licensed and operating in the CEMAC is not confirmed: no source attests to it. The amounts in the examples are fictional.

Without looking back: in what order does the default waterfall use resources, according to the PFMI?

Your turn

A owes 300 to B, B owes 300 to C, C owes 300 to A. With multilateral netting, the amount to pay is...

1A owes 300 to B, B owes 300 to C, C owes 300 to A. With multilateral netting, the amount to pay is...

The first resource used when a member defaults is...

2The first resource used when a member defaults is...

A clearing house that is systemically important in several jurisdictions must cover the default...

3A clearing house that is systemically important in several jurisdictions must cover the default...

Loss of 700,000; defaulter's margin 500,000; its share of the fund 100,000. Still to cover...

4Loss of 700,000; defaulter's margin 500,000; its share of the fund 100,000. Still to cover...

Read next: CPSS-IOSCO, Principles for financial market infrastructures (avril 2012)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further