From open outcry to the screen
On an electronic book the voice no longer counts: a written rule, price then time priority, decides by time-stamp.
Lesson 18 min
By the end of this lesson
- Apply price then time priority to say which order is filled first
- Describe what the CAC system transmitted, executed and published in 1986
- Place the move from open outcry to screens in Paris and London
In this lesson5
For more than a century, shares were traded standing up, by calling out prices around a trading ring. This portal is named after that practice: Criée, open outcry. Within a few years, at the end of the 1980s, the major exchanges replaced the voice with an electronic order book. What you will learn in this lesson: on an electronic book, who is served first no longer depends on your voice or your place in the room, but on a written rule, price then time priority, applied by time-stamping and visible to all.
What open outcry left to chance
In open outcry, a broker calls out what he is buying or selling, and at what price. The deal is struck between those who hear each other. Three questions remain open: who spoke first, what the best price in the room really was, and how to prove it afterwards.
Open outcry
A way of trading where brokers gather in a room and strike deals by voice or hand signals. The order in which bids are made is not recorded when they are expressed.
Paris, June 1986: a book on screen
The 1986 annual report of the Commission des opérations de bourse, the forerunner of the AMF, describes the change. Introduced from June 1986, the computerised continuous market called CAC (“cotation assistée en continu”, computer-assisted continuous trading) allows trading from 10:00 to 17:00 through a network of screens. It transmits orders instantly, executes them by a priority set by time-stamping, and broadcasts in real time the five best offers to buy and to sell with their sizes. The system was adapted from that of the Toronto Stock Exchange; at the end of 1986, 36 securities were traded on it (COB, 1986 annual report, p. 17).
Three words in that text sum up the lesson: time-stamping (we know who arrived first), priority (a rule decides), broadcasting (everyone sees the best limits). The last session of the trading ring at the Palais Brongniart was filmed in July 1987 (INA, « Fin de la corbeille à la Bourse de Paris », 10 July 1987).
From memory: what are the three functions of the CAC system described by the COB in 1986?
London, Chicago: the floor empties
In London, the “Big Bang” reforms were completed on 27 October 1986. A few months later, the Bank of England noted that business was moving off the floor into dealing rooms, where trades are made by telephone on the basis of prices shown on the screens of the SEAQ system, and found the speed of this decline “unexpected” (Bank of England, Quarterly Bulletin, 1987 Q1).
Open outcry held out longer in futures. In February 2015, CME Group announced the closure of most of its futures pits in Chicago and New York, keeping most of its options pits (CME Group, press release of 4 February 2015).
The text of the CME Group press release could not be read directly. The figure quoted by the press, open outcry down to about 1% of futures volume, is therefore not confirmed by the primary source.
The life of an order, from the floor to the screen
Follow the same order from Awa, first called out, then entered on screen. On screen, the queue is computed by the portal's engine: two buyers at the same price, then a seller arrives.
An order on paper
Awa wants to buy 30 fictional Kapok shares, at 10,000 XAF at most. She hands her order to her broker.
In the CEMAC zone
The BVMAC trades electronically: its general regulation provides for two electronic trading modes, the call auction and continuous trading (BVMAC general regulation 2025, art. 14). The Market mechanics track details the daily call auction at 11:00. For the wider history of exchanges, see the section on the world's stock exchanges.
Whether an open outcry session ever existed on the BVMAC or on the Douala Stock Exchange before their merger is not confirmed: no source was found.
The same market, by voice then by bookFictional
Three buyers and one seller in a fictional Kapok share.
- Chantal buys 30 shares at 10,000, arrived at 09:02.
- Awa buys 30 shares at 10,000, arrived at 09:05.
- Didier buys 30 shares at 9,950 and shouts very loudly.
- Bertrand wants to sell 40 shares, at 9,950 at least.
- By open outcry. Bertrand hears Didier first. He sells him 30 shares at 9,950, while two buyers were paying 10,000. Money left on the table: 30 × (10,000 − 9,950) = 1,500 XAF.
- On the book, price priority. The buys at 10,000 go ahead of the one at 9,950.
- On the book, time priority. At 10,000, Chantal (09:02) comes before Awa (09:05). Bertrand sells 30 to Chantal, then 10 to Awa, at the price of the resting orders, 10,000.
- Amount. 40 × 10,000 = 400,000 XAF. Awa still has 20 shares to buy; Didier is not served.
Without looking back: in the example, why is Chantal served before Awa, and why is Didier not served at all?
Your turn
Read next: COB, rapport annuel 1986 (système CAC, p. 17)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.