Skip to content
Criée

The market maker’s job

Earn the spread, fear inventory: shift both prices, widen them when risk rises.

Lesson 69 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate the gain on a round trip from the spread and the quantity
  • Explain how a market maker shifts its prices to run down its inventory
  • State when a market maker’s spread tends to be narrow
In this lesson4

In an order book, someone has to be there when you arrive in a hurry. The student track showed what a liquidity provider changes for a rushed sale (Liquidity and the spread). This lesson stands on the other side of the book. What you will learn: a market maker earns the gap between its two prices on round trips, bears the risk of holding inventory, and manages it by shifting both prices together and widening its spread when the risk grows.

Who is a market maker?

Market maker

A person who is present on the market on a continuous basis to deal on own account, buying and selling by committing its own capital, at prices it sets itself.

In plain wordsThe second-hand phone dealer

Imagine a second-hand phone dealer who is always in his shop: he buys from anyone who wants to sell and sells to anyone who wants to buy, with two prices on display, the second a little above the first. He does not earn by betting on prices, but on that gap, repeated with every customer. His real danger is stock: if he has bought too many phones and prices fall, he loses. So he lowers both prices to clear his stock, and when the outlook is uncertain, he moves the two further apart to protect himself.

This is the definition in the European MiFID II directive (Directive 2014/65/EU, art. 4(1)(7)). The same directive requires a firm that makes markets by algorithm to be present continuously for a specified proportion of trading hours and to sign a written agreement with the venue (art. 17(3)). The obligation is not new: on London's SEAQ system in 1987, market makers in the most active stocks had to maintain continuous firm two-way prices, for at least 1,000 shares (Bank of England, Quarterly Bulletin, 1987 Q1).

In the CEMAC zone

The 2022 regulation states that the market operator “imposes market-making obligations on its members” (Regulation No. 01/22, art. 118). On the BVMAC, each listed security has a specialist brokerage firm, appointed on the issuer's proposal to stabilise trading by taking positions of its own, and the exchange may sign liquidity provision contracts that require a minimum presence on the buy and sell sides, a minimum volume and a price spread (BVMAC general regulation 2025, art. 139 and 140).

From memory: what are the three elements of the MiFID II definition of a market maker?

How it sets its prices

The BIS sums up the logic: market makers set their bid and ask prices based on the cost and risk they expect from holding securities in inventory; spreads are narrow when they believe they can trade quickly and cheaply, or when their funding and hedging costs are low (BIS, “The economics of market-making”, Quarterly Review, March 2015). The AMF notes that in times of stress, the spread quoted by market makers tends to widen.

Two moves follow:

  • Shift. A market maker that has bought too much lowers both prices: it attracts buyers and discourages sellers, which runs down its inventory. If it has sold too much, it raises them.
  • Widen. When the risk of holding inventory grows, it moves its two prices apart: each round trip earns more, to make up for it.

A market maker in the book

Kadi, a fictional market maker, places a buy and a sell of 50 shares. Clients arrive with market orders. The portal's engine computes each trade; Kadi cancels and replaces her two orders after each one. Follow her inventory, her cash and the book.

A market maker holds the spreadComputed by @criee/marche
Inventory
0
Cash
0
Result
0
Bids
Price
Asks
10,250
60
10,200
40
10,150
10,100
10,050
50 K
10,000
9,950
9,900
9,850
40
9,800
60
9,750

In blue, marked K: Kadi’s two orders. Spread shown: 100

Kadi shows her two prices

Kadi buys 50 shares at 9,950 and sells 50 at 10,050. Her spread is 100. She holds no shares and owes nothing: zero inventory.

1/9

What a round trip earns, what inventory costsFictional

Kadi quotes 9,950 bid and 10,050 ask, 50 shares on each side.

  1. Spread. 10,050 − 9,950 = 100 XAF per share.
  2. One round trip. She buys 50 shares at 9,950 (497,500 XAF), then sells them at 10,050 (502,500 XAF). Gain: 502,500 − 497,500 = 5,000 XAF, i.e. 50 × 100.
  3. Inventory that stays. She buys another 50 shares at 9,950 and nobody comes to buy them back. The price falls by 200 XAF: her inventory loses 50 × 200 = 10,000 XAF.
  4. The result. It takes two full round trips (2 × 5,000) to wipe out this single fall. The job is not to guess the price, but not to stay loaded for long.

Writing aa for the market maker's bid, vv for its ask, qq for the quantity of a round trip, ss for the inventory left on hand and bb for the price fall:

f=v−again=q×finventory loss=s×bf = v - a \qquad \text{gain} = q \times f \qquad \text{inventory loss} = s \times b

Without looking back: Kadi has bought too much. What does she do with her two prices, and why?

Earning the spread is not risk-free income: inventory can lose far more than round trips bring in, as in the example. On 6 May 2010, market makers withdrew and market orders were executed at absurd prices (see the next lesson). Nothing here is investment advice.

Your turn

A market maker quotes 4,990 bid and 5,010 ask, 100 shares. One full round trip earns it...

1A market maker quotes 4,990 bid and 5,010 ask, 100 shares. One full round trip earns it...

A market maker that has piled up too many shares will tend to...

2A market maker that has piled up too many shares will tend to...

According to the BIS, a spread tends to be narrow when the market maker expects to...

3According to the BIS, a spread tends to be narrow when the market maker expects to...

On the BVMAC, the specialist brokerage firm for a security is appointed...

4On the BVMAC, the specialist brokerage firm for a security is appointed...

Read next: BRI, « The economics of market-making », Rapport trimestriel, mars 2015

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further