Delivery versus payment
Linking securities and cash removes the risk of losing everything; only the price gap remains.
Lesson 48 min
By the end of this lesson
- Distinguish principal risk from replacement-cost risk
- Calculate the loss of a seller protected by delivery versus payment
- Date the start of T+1 settlement in the United States
In this lesson5
A trade has two legs: securities going one way, money going the other. If one leaves before the other and the counterparty disappears in between, you lose everything. What you will learn in this lesson: delivery versus payment, which links the two legs, removes the risk of losing the full value of the trade; all that remains is the risk of having to redo it at a worse price.
Two risks, two sizes
The international principles distinguish two forms of credit risk on an unsettled transaction (CPSS-IOSCO, PFMI, 2012, §2.5):
Principal risk
The risk of losing the full value of a transaction, for example irrevocably delivering a security without receiving payment for it.
Replacement-cost risk
The risk of losing the unrealised gain on an unsettled transaction when the counterparty defaults: the cost of redoing the same transaction at current prices.
The first is counted on the whole value; the second on the price gap between the deal and the default. For a share, the difference is an order of magnitude.
Writing for the quantity, for the agreed price and for the price at which the deal must be redone:
Herstatt, 26 June 1974
The textbook case is that of a German bank. The German authorities closed Herstatt bank when it had already received Deutsche marks from its counterparties but had not yet paid the matching US dollars in New York. The risk of delivering one currency without receiving the other has carried its name ever since (BIS, Quarterly Review, December 2019).
The answer: linking the two legs
Delivery versus payment
A settlement method in which delivery of the security occurs if and only if payment occurs.
In plain wordsYou don't let go of the goat's rope
At the market, you don't let go of your goat's rope until the notes are in your hand: the animal and the money change hands at the same moment. If you handed over the goat first and the buyer vanished, you would lose everything: that is principal risk. Delivery versus payment brings the same caution to the stock market: the security only leaves if the money arrives. If the buyer goes bankrupt, the seller keeps the security; they just have to sell it to someone else, perhaps a little cheaper. That small gap is replacement-cost risk, the only one left.
This is the PFMI definition (§1.12), and their principle 12 makes it a requirement: an infrastructure that settles two linked obligations should eliminate principal risk by conditioning the final settlement of one on the final settlement of the other. Principle 8 adds that settlement should be final at the latest by the end of the value date, principle 9 that it should take place in central bank money where practical (PFMI, principles 8, 9 and 12).
From memory: what is the difference in size between principal risk and replacement-cost risk?
The life of a default, with or without the link
Patrice sells 100 fictional shares at 10,000 XAF. The buyer goes bust before paying, and the price falls to 9,600. Compare the two worlds.
A trade agreed
Patrice sold 100 shares at 10,000: he expects 1,000,000 XAF.
Shortening the wait
Between trading and settlement, replacement-cost risk grows with time, because prices have more time to move. Hence the race to a short cycle:
- United States: move from T+2 to T+1 for transactions from 28 May 2024; a Monday sale settles on Tuesday (SEC, investor bulletin on T+1).
- European Union: move to T+1 on 11 October 2027 (ESMA, 16 October 2026).
T+1 means one business day after the trade date, written T.
On the BVMAC, no published text sets the settlement cycle. The only clue: the official price list of Wednesday 2 September 2026 computes accrued interest to Monday 7 September, three business days later. Whether settlement is delivery versus payment is not verified either: to our knowledge, the depository's rules are not published online.
What a default costs, and how long you are exposedFictional
Patrice sells 100 fictional shares at 10,000 XAF. The buyer defaults; the price has fallen to 9,600.
- Value of the trade. 100 × 10,000 = 1,000,000 XAF.
- Without delivery versus payment. Patrice has delivered: he loses 1,000,000 XAF, the principal risk.
- With delivery versus payment. He keeps his shares and sells them again at 9,600: he loses 100 × (10,000 − 9,600) = 40,000 XAF, the replacement-cost risk. That is 25 times less.
- Duration. A brokerage firm sells 2,000,000 XAF of shares every day. At T+3, three days of sales await settlement: 6,000,000 XAF exposed. At T+1, only one: 2,000,000 XAF.
Without looking back: in the example, why does moving from T+3 to T+1 divide the exposure by three?
Your turn
Read next: CPSS-IOSCO, Principles for financial market infrastructures (avril 2012)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.