Several venues for one security
When liquidity is fragmented, you must look for the best result across all venues.
Lesson 89 min
By the end of this lesson
- Distinguish a regulated market, a multilateral trading facility and a dark pool
- Calculate the cost of a purchase routed to the best price of two venues
- Explain why fragmentation between venues does not exist at the BVMAC
In this lesson5
In Europe as in the United States, the same security can trade at the same time on several competing venues, each with its own book. What you will learn in this lesson: when a security's liquidity is fragmented across several venues, the intermediary must compare them all to get the best result for its client, and some of them do not display their orders before the trade.
Three kinds of venue in Europe
The MiFID II directive distinguishes three trading venues (Directive 2014/65/EU, art. 4(1), points 21 to 24):
- the regulated market, a multilateral system operated by a market operator, which brings together the buying and selling interests of multiple third parties under non-discretionary rules;
- the multilateral trading facility (MTF), which does the same but may be operated by an investment firm;
- the organised trading facility (OTF): a multilateral system other than the first two, limited to bonds, structured products, emission allowances and derivatives.
Fragmentation
The situation where the same security trades at the same time on several venues, each with its own order book.
In the United States, the equivalent of the MTF is the alternative trading system (ATS): it meets the definition of an exchange, but is exempt from registering as a national securities exchange if it complies with Regulation ATS and registers as a broker-dealer (SEC, Alternative Trading Systems).
Dark venues
According to FINRA, dark pools are a type of ATS designed, in general, to handle large trades for institutional investors anonymously. They do not display orders before execution, neither their presence, nor their price, nor their size; so they only contribute to public price discovery afterwards, when trades are reported (FINRA, “Can you swim in a dark pool?”, 15 November 2023).
From memory: what does a dark venue hide, and what does it still publish?
Looking for the best price everywhere
With several books, “buying at the best price” means nothing unless you say where. MiFID II requires the intermediary to take all sufficient steps to obtain the best possible result for its client, taking into account price, costs, speed, likelihood of execution and settlement, size and nature of the order (art. 27).
In the United States, Rule 611 of Regulation NMS, adopted in 2005, in principle prohibits “trade-throughs”: executing an order at a price worse than the one displayed by another trading centre. On 11 June 2026, the SEC proposed to rescind it, considering that it has contributed to costs, complexity and fragmentation of trading (SEC, “Regulation NMS Reforms” fact sheet).
The rescission of Rule 611 is only a proposal as of 17 November 2026: its outcome is not known.
The life of an order split across two venues
Awa buys 100 fictional shares, at 10,050 XAF at most. The share trades on exchange A and venue B. Both books are computed by the portal's engine; the broker always takes the cheaper level of the two.
One order, two books
Awa buys 100 shares, 10,050 at most. The same share trades on two venues.
Routing, or sending everything to one placeFictional
Resting sell orders. Exchange A: 30 at 10,000, 50 at 10,050. Venue B: 40 at 9,990, 50 at 10,100. Awa buys 100 shares, at 10,050 at most.
- All on A. 30 × 10,000 + 50 × 10,050 = 300,000 + 502,500 = 802,500 XAF for 80 shares. 20 are missing: nothing else on A is at 10,050 or less.
- Routing, first piece. The cheapest is B at 9,990: 40 × 9,990 = 399,600 XAF.
- Second and third pieces. Then A at 10,000: 30 × 10,000 = 300,000 XAF; then A at 10,050: 30 × 10,050 = 301,500 XAF. B at 10,100 is above the limit.
- Result. 100 shares for 399,600 + 300,000 + 301,500 = 1,001,100 XAF, i.e. 10,011 XAF on average, against 80 shares at 10,031 XAF on average on A alone.
In the CEMAC zone
The CEMAC has only one exchange, the BVMAC, and brokerage firms have the monopoly of trading on it (Regulation No. 01/22, art. 161; BVMAC general regulation 2025, art. 24). Fragmentation between competing venues, as seen in Europe or the United States, does not exist there to our knowledge: this lesson therefore describes foreign markets.
Without looking back: in the example, why does routing buy more shares, and more cheaply, than sending the whole order to exchange A?
Your turn
Read next: Directive 2014/65/UE (MiFID II), texte français
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.