Scams: when a gain is “guaranteed”
Spotting the signs of a fraudulent offer, understanding how a pyramid collapses, checking COSUMAF licensing before paying in.
Lesson 99 min
By the end of this lesson
- Spot the warning signs of a fraudulent investment offer
- Explain where the gains paid by a Ponzi scheme come from
- Convert a promised monthly return into a compounded annual return
In this lesson3
Every lesson in this section says the same thing: a higher expected return means more risk. A scam almost always begins by denying that rule. What this lesson teaches: spotting the signs of a fraudulent offer, understanding why a pyramid always ends up collapsing, and knowing what to check before paying in a single franc.
The rule the fraudster erases
The AMF puts it bluntly: "There is no miracle investment! A high return can never be guaranteed." It advises fleeing aggressive sales methods, because "a good deal today will still be one tomorrow", and being wary of a stranger, even one recommended by someone close, who offers an investment that is both profitable and guaranteed, reserved for a privileged few, with benefits if you sign quickly (AMF, "Éviter les arnaques", 2023).
What “10% a month” means, step by stepFictional
- One month. 100,000 × 1.10 = 110,000 FCFA.
- Twelve months. With compound interest, 100,000 × 1.10¹² ≈ 313,843 FCFA.
- The annual rate. 313,843 ÷ 100,000 ≈ 3.14: the promise amounts to multiplying the money by more than three in a year, i.e. about +214%.
- The comparison. In the lesson on compound interest, 5% a year took 100,000 FCFA to 105,000 FCFA in one year. A promise forty times stronger, and "guaranteed", contradicts the rule of risk and return.
From memory: which three words, together in the same offer, should make you run according to the AMF?
The Ponzi scheme
The SEC describes the mechanism: a Ponzi scheme pays existing investors with money collected from new investors. Its organisers often promise high returns with little or no risk, but do not invest the money; they use it to pay those who joined earlier and keep some for themselves. With no real earnings, the scheme needs a constant flow of new money, and it collapses when recruitment slows or when many participants want to cash out (Investor.gov, "Ponzi Scheme").
Ponzi scheme
A fraud that pays earlier participants "gains" taken from the money of newer ones, until the inflows are no longer enough.
Follow the 100,000 FCFA of Régine, an invented saver. The amounts in the cash box are recalculated every month from the newcomers' deposits.
The promise
A stranger, recommended by a friend: “10% a month, guaranteed, only for a few people, you must sign this week.”
Régine saw payments arrive for seven months: that is what makes the pyramid believable. Among its red flags, the SEC lists overly consistent returns regardless of market conditions, unregistered investments, unlicensed sellers, secret or overly complex strategies, and difficulty getting your money out (Investor.gov).
In Central Africa: the COSUMAF has already issued warnings
In 2023, the COSUMAF published a warning about an outfit based in Douala that was inviting the public to subscribe for shares in its capital "promising certain gains over horizons of 1, 2 and 3 years". The outfit was not on the list of licensed firms; the COSUMAF served it with an order to stop, asked the authorities to bring the matter before the courts, and urged the public not to subscribe (COSUMAF communiqué published by the BVMAC).
It pointed out on that occasion that placing financial instruments (shares, bonds and so on) with the public is a regulated investment service, subject to prior authorisation, and that any breach of the rules on public offerings is punishable by the penalties in articles 264 onwards of Regulation No. 01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF (same communiqué; see also the warning "United Forest Finance").
Public offering
Offering financial securities for the public to buy; in the CEMAC, it is regulated and subject to COSUMAF authorisation.
1/4Too good?
A high gain presented as guaranteed, or risk-free, is enough to end the conversation.
This portal cites no real company as an example: Régine's pyramid is invented. The COSUMAF and AMF warnings are real; read them on their official sites before any investment. For a victim of fraud, the AMF states that "the only solution is to file a complaint" (AMF, "Victime d'une arnaque : comment déposer une plainte ?"); that document describes the French procedure.
Without looking above: why does a Ponzi scheme always end up collapsing?
Your turn
Read next: AMF, « Éviter les arnaques » (2023)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.