Comparing: risk, return, liquidity, fees
Four criteria for any investment, and the only one known in advance, fees, worked out over twenty years.
Lesson 89 min
By the end of this lesson
- Compare investments on risk, return, liquidity and fees
- Calculate the effect of annual fees and explain why they compound
- Read the 1 to 7 risk indicator of a key information document
In this lesson4
Faced with two products, the question "which earns more?" is not enough. What this lesson gives you: comparing any investments on four criteria, always the same ones, and putting a figure on the only one you know for certain in advance, the fees.
Four questions, in this order
- Risk. How much can I lose, and how often? The SEC sums it up: "generally, the higher the potential return, the higher the risk of loss" (SEC).
- Return. What can I hope for, and is it promised (a coupon) or only possible (a rise, a dividend)?
- Liquidity. How quickly can I get my money back, and at what price? See Liquidity and spread.
- Fees. How much does the product cost me each year, whether I gain or lose?
What are the four criteria, and which one is known for certain before investing?
A grid for the products in this section
- Bond. Main risk: issuer default, price fall if rates rise (AMF); return: coupon set in the contract; liquidity: resale on the exchange, if a buyer turns up; fees: brokerage.
- Share. Main risk: partial or total loss (AMF); return: dividend and rise, never promised; liquidity: resale on the exchange, if a buyer turns up; fees: brokerage.
- Fund (UCITS). Main risk: that of the basket's securities, spread out; return: the basket's, less fees; liquidity: bought back by the fund at net asset value (art. 383); fees: entry, exit, ongoing charges.
- ETF. Main risk: that of the index copied; return: the index, less fees; liquidity: on the exchange, during the session; fees: ongoing charges, brokerage.
- Structured product. Main risk: barrier and issuer (ACPR-AMF); return: per the formula, often capped; liquidity: check the documents; fees: check the documents.
- Crypto-asset. Main risk: total loss possible (ESMA); return: no promised income; liquidity: depends on the platform, which can freeze; fees: depends on the platform.
The "liquidity" column deserves a local figure. On the BVMAC, the equity market saw 594 trades in the whole of 2025, and the value of bond trading, 12.8 billion F, stayed far below the 99.4 billion F of coupons paid (BVMAC annual report 2025): selling a listed security can take time. A fund unit, by contrast, is bought back by the fund itself, at the pace of its net asset value, daily for some funds, weekly or monthly for others (bulletin no. 2586).
A number for risk
For products sold in Europe, the key information document (KID) shows a risk indicator from 1 to 7: 1 is the lowest level, "which does not mean there is no risk"; the score combines market risk and credit risk over the recommended holding period, and an emerging-market equity fund will often be at 6 or 7 (AMF, 2 February 2023). This scale belongs to European law; we have not checked for an equivalent required by the COSUMAF.
Fees, the criterion that never forgives
A fund's expense ratio is the percentage of its average net assets used each year to pay its operating expenses (SEC, "Expense Ratio"). It is charged whether the market rises or falls. Two fictional funds, same basket, same gross return of 7% a year: only their fees differ.
Kapokier Fund
0.5% fees a year
1,000,000 F
fees paid: 0 F
Moabi Fund
2.5% fees a year
1,000,000 F
fees paid: 0 F
Nadège and Zoé each invest 1,000,000 F in funds that hold the same basket, at 7% gross a year (fictional).
The first year, then the twentiethFictional
Nadège and Zoé each invest 1,000,000 F. The basket earns 7% gross a year. Nadège's fund charges 0.5% in fees, Zoé's 2.5%.
- Year 1, before fees. 1,000,000 × 1.07 = 1,070,000 F for both.
- Year 1, after fees. Nadège: 1,070,000 × 0.005 = 5,350 F of fees, leaving 1,064,650 F. Zoé: 1,070,000 × 0.025 = 26,750 F of fees, leaving 1,043,250 F. Gap: 21,400 F.
- The following years. The same sum starts again each year from the previous year's value, fees already taken out. After 20 years: 3,500,557 F for Nadège, 2,332,211 F for Zoé. The gap, 1,168,346 F, is larger than the starting stake.
Writing for the amount invested, for the gross annual return, for the fee rate and for the number of years, the value after fees is:
Why does the gap between the two funds grow faster than 20 times the first year's gap?
A grid does not choose for you: it helps you ask the right questions. The right product depends on your time horizon, how soon you may need the money and the loss you can bear. The AMF advises investing only savings you can do without for several years, at least ten years for equity funds (AMF). Nothing in this section is investment advice.
Your turn
Read next: AMF, « Document d’informations clés : comprendre l’information sur le risque du placement » (2023)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.