Skip to content
Criée

Rating agencies and a State’s rating

What a State’s rating measures, the sovereign ceiling, African agencies and their licences, and the link between rating and borrowing cost.

Lesson 910 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain what a State’s rating measures and what the sovereign ceiling is
  • Name African rating agencies and the regulator that licenses them
  • Link a State’s rating to its borrowing cost
In this lesson5

The lesson on credit ratings showed the rating scale, the BBB−/BB+ line and what a rating does not guarantee. This one looks at a particular issuer: the State. Its rating matters for it, but also for every company in its country. What you will take from this lesson: what a State's rating measures, what the sovereign ceiling is, who rates in Africa under which licence, and how the rating shows up in the cost of borrowing.

What a State's rating measures

Sovereign rating

The rating of a State: an agency's opinion on its ability to pay the interest and principal of its public debt on time.

According to a World Bank note, the sovereign rating helps investors and bondholders assess the risks of a country's ability "to honor its public debt obligations"; it also serves as a comparable indicator of its public finances (World Bank, Economic Premise no. 63, 2011). The same note pointed out that in mid-2011, 58 developing countries were not rated by any of the three big international agencies, S&P, Moody's and Fitch.

A State can be rated for its local-currency debt and for its foreign-currency debt. The information document of Cameroon's 2023 bond thus states that Fitch had confirmed Cameroon's rating "at B with a stable outlook" on 26 May 2023 for its local and foreign-currency bonds; Moody's gave an equivalent rating in 2021, and S&P had lowered its outlook from "stable" to "negative" in 2020 (ECMR 2023 information document). A B rating is speculative grade.

Is Cameroon's B rating in 2023 investment grade or speculative grade? How many notches would it need to gain to reach BB+?

The sovereign ceiling

Sovereign ceiling

The agencies' practice of not rating a company, bank or local authority above the State where it is located, especially for its foreign-currency debt.

In plain wordsThe village's only bridge

Imagine a village linked to the town by a single bridge, which only the chief can open or close. The best trader in the village may be perfectly honest: if the bridge is shut, she can no longer pay her suppliers in town. Rating agencies reason the same way: when the State runs short of foreign currency or blocks transfers abroad, even a sound company can no longer pay its foreign creditors. So its foreign-currency rating rarely goes above its State's. Except that this ceiling is not absolute, and local-currency debt, which never has to cross the bridge, usually escapes it.

The World Bank puts it this way: even when the State issues no bonds, its rating "often acts as a 'ceiling' for the foreign currency rating of bonds issued by firms and banks located in the country" (Economic Premise no. 63). The reason: if the State runs short of foreign currency or restricts transfers, a sound company may no longer be able to pay its foreign creditors.

The ceiling is not absolute. A 2016 World Bank working paper finds that agencies have relaxed it since 2001, that ratings sometimes "pierce" the ceiling, and that local-currency debt, which is typically not subject to convertibility and transfer risks, does not appear to be subject to the ceiling (World Bank, Policy Research Working Paper 7618).

Who rates, in Africa

Three groups of agencies exist side by side.

  • The international agencies: S&P, Moody's and Fitch, supervised in the European Union by ESMA (ESMA).
  • African agencies with a pan-African reach. GCR, founded in 1996, took a majority stake in the West Africa Rating Agency (WARA) in 2021 to cover French-speaking Africa; Moody's acquired 51% of GCR in 2022, then 100% in 2024; GCR says it is present in Mauritius, South Africa, Nigeria, Kenya and Senegal, and licensed as a regional rating agency by AMF-UMOA, the regulator of the West African Monetary Union (GCR, "About us"). Bloomfield Investment Corporation, based in Abidjan, presents itself as French-speaking Africa's first rating agency (Bloomfield).
  • An agency licensed in the CEMAC. To rate on the regional market, an agency must be licensed by the COSUMAF and have its registered office in a member State (article 653 of the 2023 COSUMAF General Regulation). According to the press, on 7 August 2026 the COSUMAF granted Geneva Investment Corporation a rating agency licence, reference COSUMAF-AGN-01/2026, described as the first in the area (Sika Finance, 13 August 2026).

Licence (agrément)

The regulator's prior authorisation without which a firm may not operate on the market; it can be limited or withdrawn.

In 2022, Bloomfield's head said his agency had been present in the CEMAC for more than ten years, and that none of the agencies rating there had been licensed by the COSUMAF, "because it was never necessary" (EcoMatin, 25 October 2022).

The COSUMAF website could not be consulted (access blocked to robots): the licence of 7 August 2026 and its reference are known only from the press. No up-to-date official list of agencies licensed by the COSUMAF or by AMF-UMOA has been read; the licensing of Bloomfield and WARA by the West African regulator is not confirmed by an official source. This section quotes no current rating of the CEMAC States: the Cameroon rating quoted dates from 2023.

From rating to borrowing cost

The 2016 World Bank working paper sums up the link: the sovereign rating serves as a benchmark for fundraising by both the public and private sectors "by affecting their borrowing spreads", especially on international markets and for foreign-currency debt. On the CEMAC Treasury securities market, where all States borrow in the same currency, the average cost of OTAs in July 2026 ranged from 7.36% for Cameroon to 11.90% for Chad (BEAC, July 2026 statistics): lenders do not judge every borrower the same way. The lesson on the credit spread does the calculation.

The ceiling and the cost, in a fictional countryFictional

The fictional State of Kalao is rated B. The fictional company Baobab, the soundest in Kalao, would on its own be rated BB+. Risk-free benchmark rate: 5% (fictional). Spreads required by rating (fictional): BB+, 250 basis points; B, 500 basis points.

  1. Baobab's foreign-currency debt: the sovereign ceiling brings it down to Kalao's rating, B. Required rate: 5% + 5.00% = 10%.
  2. Without the ceiling, at BB+: 5% + 2.50% = 7.5%.
  3. Cost of the ceiling on a 20 billion loan: (10% − 7.5%) × 20 = 0.5 billion a year.
  4. If Kalao is upgraded to BB, with a fictional spread of 350 basis points: Baobab borrows in foreign currency at 5% + 3.50% = 8.5%, and saves 1.5 points, or 0.3 billion a year on 20 billion.
  5. In local currency, the ceiling applies less: Baobab can sometimes be rated above Kalao there.

From memory: what is the sovereign ceiling, and why does it apply mainly to foreign-currency debt?

Key points

  • The sovereign rating judges a State's ability to honour its public debt; it may differ between local and foreign currency.
  • Sovereign ceiling: a company is rarely rated above its State for its foreign-currency debt.
  • International agencies (S&P, Moody's, Fitch), African groups (GCR, which controls the former WARA; Bloomfield); in the CEMAC, a COSUMAF licence is required.
  • Better rating, narrower spread, cheaper borrowing, for the State and for its companies alike.

Your turn

A sovereign rating mainly judges a State's ability to...

1A sovereign rating mainly judges a State's ability to...

The sovereign ceiling mainly concerns the rating of...

2The sovereign ceiling mainly concerns the rating of...

To rate on the CEMAC financial market, an agency must...

3To rate on the CEMAC financial market, an agency must...

Which group took control of the West African agency WARA in 2021?

4Which group took control of the West African agency WARA in 2021?

Risk-free 5%, spread required for the State's rating 400 basis points. The required rate is...

5Risk-free 5%, spread required for the State's rating 400 basis points. The required rate is...

Read next: Banque mondiale, Policy Research Working Paper 7618, « Impacts of Sovereign Rating on Sub-Sovereign Bond Ratings » (2016)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further