Forward prices: the cost-of-carry model
The forward price is calculated: spot, minus income, plus costs, compounded at the riskless rate.
Lesson 29 min
By the end of this lesson
- Calculate a forward price allowing for income and storage costs
- Build the spot-against-forward arbitrage in both directions
- Calculate the basis and explain its sign
In this lesson4
A buyer who wants a share in a year's time has two routes: sign a forward contract today, or buy the share now with borrowed money and hold it. Both end in the same place, with the share in hand at expiry. Under no-arbitrage, they must cost the same. What you will learn: calculate the forward price of an asset from its spot price, the interest rate, the income and the holding costs, and build the arbitrage when the quoted price moves away from it.
Two routes to the same asset
MIT's finance course sets out the comparison like this: the forward contract costs at expiry; buying spot with borrowed money costs the loan repayment, plus storage costs, minus any income; under no-arbitrage, these two methods must cost the same. The differences between them are costs (storage, for commodities) and benefits (dividends, for financial assets) (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, lecture 8, slides 18 to 20).
Cost of carry
What it costs to hold an asset until a future date: interest on the money tied up, storage and insurance, less the income the asset pays in the meantime.
The CFTC glossary defines carrying charges (or "cost of carry") as the cost of storing a physical commodity or holding a financial instrument over a period of time: insurance, storage and interest (CFTC Glossary).
Forward price
The price, set today, at which a forward contract will exchange the asset at expiry. Without arbitrage, it equals the spot price plus the cost of carry.
In plain wordsThe sack of rice in the granary
A trader wants a sack of rice in six months. She can order it today at an agreed price, delivered in six months. Or she can buy it straight away with borrowed money and keep it in the granary: she then pays the interest on the loan, the guard and the insurance. Both routes give the same sack on the same day, so the agreed price must equal today's price plus these keeping costs. If the goods earned something while waiting, like a share's dividend, it would be taken off.
Writing for the forward price, for the spot price, for the present value of income paid to the holder before expiry (dividends, coupons), for the present value of storage and insurance costs, for the annual riskless rate and for the time in years:
is subtracted because the forward buyer does not receive income paid before expiry; is added because they do not have to pay for storage.
Fictitious share with a dividendFictional
A fictitious share is priced at 20,000 XAF. It will pay a dividend of 1,000 XAF in one year. Riskless rate: 6% a year. One-year forward contract.
- Present value of the dividend: = 1,000 ÷ 1.06 = 943.40 XAF.
- Spot price net of income: 20,000 − 943.40 = 19,056.60 XAF.
- Compound over one year: 19,056.60 × 1.06 = 20,200 XAF.
- Check by the other route: borrow 20,000, repay 21,200 in a year, less the 1,000 dividend received: 20,200. Same result.
A fictitious share is worth 10,000 XAF, pays nothing, and the rate is 5%. What is its one-year forward price? And if it paid a 300 XAF dividend in one year?
When the quoted price moves away
The course's problem session takes oil priced at 50 dollars, with a rate of 3.8%: if the one-year forward price moves from 50.40 to 51 dollars, selling forward, buying spot and borrowing earns 0.60 dollar a barrel with no money put up (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, recitation 4). Back to the fictitious share, whose no-arbitrage forward price is 20,200 XAF.
1/4Today
Borrow 20,000 XAF at 6%, buy the share, sell the share forward at 20,500. Money put up: 0.
This strategy is called "cash and carry": buy spot and carry the asset. If the quoted price is too low, you do the reverse.
1/4Today
Borrow the share and short-sell it for 20,000 XAF, deposit the 20,000 at 6%, buy the share forward at 19,900. Money put up: 0.
A forward price above 20,200 triggers the first strategy, a price below it the second: only 20,200 leaves no riskless gain.
Commodities: storage costs
Fictitious cocoa at six monthsFictional
A fictitious tonne of cocoa is worth 1,500,000 XAF spot. Storage and insurance for six months: present value 30,000 XAF. Rate: 5% a year.
- Spot plus costs: 1,500,000 + 30,000 = 1,530,000 XAF.
- Six-month factor: 1.05 to the power 0.5 = 1.024695.
- Forward price: 1,530,000 × 1.024695 = 1,567,783 XAF.
For a commodity held to be used, the reverse strategy requires selling your stock, which its holders do not always do. MIT's course then adds a "convenience yield", the benefit of holding the physical commodity: if it exceeds storage costs, the forward price can sit below the compounded spot price (MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401, recitation 4). The cost-of-carry formula remains exact for financial assets held as investments.
The gap between spot and forward: the basis
Basis
The gap between the spot price of an asset and the forward price for the nearest expiry, usually calculated as spot minus forward.
The definition and the direction of the calculation are the CFTC's, which notes that the basis tends to narrow as delivery approaches: this is convergence (CFTC Glossary). The cost-of-carry model explains it: as shrinks, tends to 1 and the remaining income and costs dwindle, so meets on expiry day.
For the fictitious share: basis = 20,000 − 20,200 = − 200 XAF. It is negative because the borrowing rate (6%, i.e. 1,200 XAF) costs more than the dividend brings in (1,000 XAF).
The sign of the basis depends on the convention: the CFTC calculates it as spot minus forward, but some markets express it as forward minus spot. Check the convention before comparing two figures.
From memory: write the forward price formula with income and costs, and say which strategy exploits a forward price quoted too high.
Your turn
Read next: MIT OpenCourseWare, 15.401 Finance Theory I, cours 8 « Forward and Futures Contracts » (A. Lo, 2008)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.