Commodities, a price that runs through a country
The oil price is set on a world market. When it falls, earnings, budget and reserves follow, as in the CEMAC after 2014.
Lesson 49 min
By the end of this lesson
- Explain why a standard commodity has a world price
- Put figures on a price shock’s effect on exports and reserves
- Explain the negative WTI price in 2020 and the shock the CEMAC went through
In this lesson4
Oil, cocoa, coffee, timber, metals: these goods sell everywhere at the same benchmark price, set on world markets. What this lesson gives you: understanding that a change in that price does not stay on the market. It runs through the incomes of those who produce, all the way to the budget and reserves of a whole country.
A standard good, a world price
A commodity is a raw, interchangeable good: a barrel of oil of a given grade is worth another barrel of the same grade. That is what makes it possible to set its price on an exchange, mostly through futures contracts. The US regulator describes them as agreements to buy or sell a specific quantity of a commodity at a set price on a future date; listed contracts have a fixed size and expiry date, and a clearing house acts as the single counterparty to every trade (SEC, Investor.gov, "Commodities"). Lesson 5 covers these contracts.
Commodity
A raw, interchangeable good (oil, cocoa, metal) whose price is formed on world markets, usually through futures contracts.
A saver can be exposed to that price in three ways: by trading futures contracts (lesson 5); by buying listed products backed by commodities, which the SEC distinguishes from ordinary ETFs (SEC); or indirectly, by owning shares in companies that produce or use these goods.
The day oil was worth less than nothing
A futures contract is not just a bet on a number: at expiry, someone has to deliver or take delivery. The US Energy Information Administration describes what that led to on Monday 20 April 2020: the WTI crude oil futures contract traded at a negative price for the first time since trading began in 1983, as low as −$40.32 a barrel. Contract holders had to take delivery of the oil at Cushing, Oklahoma, where storage tanks were nearly full; lacking buyers, some holders had to pay to hand over their contracts rather than receive oil they could not store (EIA, 27 April 2020).
Why was a negative price possible that day?
From barrel to budget: a shock that runs through a country
Take a made-up country, Estuaria, which lives mainly on its oil. Choose the world price of a barrel and follow the effect on its exports, its budget and its foreign reserves. All the figures are fictional.
World price of a barrel (fictional)
- Oil exports per year
- 1,200bn F
- Budget revenue (40%)
- 480bn F
Foreign reserves, in months of imports
At the starting price, exports pay exactly for imports: reserves stay at 9 months.
Estuaria loses a quarter of the barrel priceFictional
Estuaria exports 20 million barrels a year. It imports 1,200 billion F of goods each year and holds 900 billion F of foreign reserves. The state receives 40% of the value of oil exports.
- Exports. At 60,000 F a barrel: 20,000,000 × 60,000 = 1,200 billion F. At 45,000 F: 900 billion. A 25% fall in price wipes out 25% of export earnings.
- Budget. 40% of 1,200 = 480 billion F; 40% of 900 = 360 billion. The state loses 120 billion a year.
- Reserves. Imports cost 1,200 billion a year, i.e. 100 billion a month: 900 billion of reserves cover 9 months. With 900 billion of exports, 300 billion is missing every year: reserves fall to 600, then 300, then 0 billion, i.e. 6, 3, then 0 months of imports.
In reality a country reacts before it gets that far: it imports less, borrows, cuts spending. That is what the CEMAC zone went through.
What the CEMAC went through after 2014
The International Monetary Fund describes the same chain in the CEMAC zone after the sharp fall in oil prices from 2014. With oil revenue collapsing, governments turned to direct financing from the BEAC in 2015 and 2016; foreign reserve coverage fell from 5.8 months of imports at the end of 2014 to 2.2 months at the end of 2016, and the zone's growth dropped to −1% in 2016. In December 2016, at an extraordinary summit, the heads of state agreed on a coordinated response and to seek IMF support (IMF, country report no. 17/389).
A price set thousands of kilometres away, on a market where neither the state nor the farmers have a say, thus weighed on the reserves of the shared central bank.
In what order does an oil price shock pass through to an exporting country?
Commodity prices can move abruptly, and April 2020 shows that a futures contract can lose more than the price on display. The CFTC, the US futures regulator, warns against offers of high returns on futures, options or forex, which are common areas of fraud (SEC).
Your turn
Read next: FMI, rapport pays n°17/389, CEMAC (2017)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.