Skip to content
Criée

Refinancing: rolling over debt and borrowing in foreign currency

Repaying one loan with another brings refinancing and interest rate risk; borrowing in dollars adds exchange rate risk.

Lesson 710 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Explain the refinancing risk and interest rate risk of a maturing debt
  • Work out the effect of an exchange rate change on a foreign-currency debt
  • Explain why a debt in euros carries little exchange rate risk for a CEMAC State
In this lesson4

A State rarely repays its debt out of taxes: when a loan matures, it often issues a new one to repay the old. It "rolls over" its debt. This everyday move carries two risks, not finding lenders or finding them at a higher rate, and a third one when it borrows in a foreign currency. What you will take from this lesson: explaining these risks and putting a figure on what a change in rates or exchange rates costs the borrower.

Rolling over the debt

Refinancing

Borrowing again to repay a loan that has matured, at the going rate.

The IMF and the World Bank, in their guidelines for public debt management, describe three risks (Revised Guidelines for Public Debt Management, 2014, Box 1):

  • Refinancing risk: the risk that debt will have to be refinanced "at an unusually high cost or, in extreme cases, cannot be refinanced at all". Being unable to refinance maturing debt can trigger or worsen a debt crisis.
  • Interest rate risk: the risk that the cost of debt rises with interest rates, when fixed-rate debt is refinanced or when floating-rate debt has its rate reset. Short-term or floating-rate debt is therefore seen as riskier than long-term fixed-rate debt.
  • Exchange rate risk: the risk that the cost of debt, counted in the national currency, rises when the exchange rate moves.

Refinancing risk

The risk that a borrower can refinance maturing debt only at a very high cost, or not at all.

Interest rate risk

The risk that the cost of a debt rises when interest rates go up, at the moment it is refinanced or its floating rate is reset.

The same guidelines list the indicators to watch: the average time to maturity of the debt, and the share falling due within 12, 24 and 36 months. They add that emerging and low-income countries, whose market access is limited, should give "higher priority to refinancing risk".

Rolling over BTAs when rates riseFictional

The fictional Treasury of Kalao has 100 billion FCFA of 26-week BTAs, issued at 5% a year. At maturity, it repays them by issuing new BTAs of the same amount, but the SVTs now ask for 7%. To keep it simple, 26 weeks = half a year.

  1. Cost before: 100 × 5% × 0.5 = 2.5 billion for six months.
  2. Cost after: 100 × 7% × 0.5 = 3.5 billion for six months.
  3. Extra cost: 3.5 − 2.5 = 1 billion per half-year, or 2 billion a year if rates stay at 7%.
  4. A 10-year fixed-rate OTA, issued at 5%, would have kept its cost of 5 billion a year for ten years: interest rate risk falls on short-term debt.
  5. The worst case: if the SVTs offer only 60 billion, Kalao must find 40 billion elsewhere to repay. That is refinancing risk.

Why is a debt made mostly of BTAs more exposed to interest rate risk than a debt made of long fixed-rate OTAs?

Borrowing in foreign currency: Eurobonds

A State can also borrow outside its own area, on international markets, in dollars or euros. These securities are often called Eurobonds, even when they are denominated in dollars.

Eurobond

A bond issued by a State or a company on the international market, in a currency other than its own, most often the dollar or the euro.

Exchange rate risk

The risk that the cost of a foreign-currency debt, counted in the national currency, rises because the national currency loses value against the borrowed currency.

In plain wordsA debt in someone else's currency

Imagine a family that borrows from a cousin living abroad, in his country's currency, and repays him with money earned at the market, in CFA francs. If the CFA franc loses value against that currency, more goods must be sold to repay the same sum: the debt grows without a single extra franc being borrowed. That is exchange rate risk. For a CEMAC State, a debt in euros escapes it as long as the fixed parity holds; a debt in dollars does not.

For a CEMAC State, the euro is not a currency like the others: the CFA franc's parity is fixed, 1 euro = 655.957 FCFA since the euro was created (Banque de France, "Les coopérations monétaires Afrique-France"). A debt in euros therefore costs no more CFA francs as long as the parity holds; a debt in dollars does.

A dollar EurobondFictional

Kalao, a fictional CEMAC State, borrows 100 million dollars over 5 years, 6% coupon, bullet repayment. The dollar is worth 600 FCFA on the issue date (fictional rate).

  1. Received at issue: 100 × 600 = 60 billion FCFA.
  2. Annual coupon: 6% × 100 = 6 million dollars, that is 6 × 600 = 3.6 billion FCFA at the start.
  3. The dollar rises to 660 FCFA (+10%): the same coupon costs 6 × 660 = 3.96 billion, and the final repayment 100 × 660 = 66 billion instead of 60.
  4. Extra cost of repayment: 66 − 60 = 6 billion FCFA, without the interest rate having moved.
  5. Same loan in euros: 100 million euros are worth 65.6 billion FCFA (100 × 655.957) at issue and at maturity, as long as the fixed parity is kept.

The case of Cameroon

Cameroon has issued two Eurobonds, in 2015 and 2021. According to the government daily Cameroon Tribune, the 2021 bond, announced on 22 June, sought 450 billion FCFA, or 685 million euros, at 5.95%, to finance in part the repayment of the 2015 bond, issued at 9.50%; demand reached 2.258 billion euros (Cameroon Tribune, "An Economic Relief"). A lower rate to replace expensive debt: that is successful refinancing.

The Caisse autonome d'amortissement confirms the outcome in its end-June 2026 accounts: the 2015 Eurobond no longer appears in the outstanding debt since January 2026, the 2021 bond stays at 449.3 billion FCFA, and a private placement made through the London Stock Exchange in February 2026 accounts for 29.7% of commercial debt. Its risk indicators give an average time to maturity of 6.9 years, 13.8% of the debt to be repaid in the coming year, and 68.8% of the debt denominated in currencies other than the FCFA; but currency exposure comes down to 37.5% of the portfolio once euro debt, 31.3% of the total, is set aside (CAA, public debt report no. 06/26).

The amounts and rates of the 2015 and 2021 Eurobonds (685 million euros, 5.95%, 9.50%) come from a government daily, not from a release by the Ministry of Finance or the CAA: their exact term and the amount bought back in 2021 are not confirmed here. The other CEMAC States are not covered, for lack of an official source read. The fixed parity between the CFA franc and the euro removes exchange rate risk on the euro as long as it is kept; it has been changed before, with the 50% devaluation of the CFA francs in January 1994 (same source).

From memory: name the three risks of a debt according to the IMF and the World Bank, and say why a debt in euros exposes a CEMAC State less than a debt in dollars.

Key points

  • Refinancing means rolling over the debt: repaying the old loan with a new one, at the going rate.
  • Refinancing risk: finding no lenders, or only at a very high cost. Interest rate risk: paying more when refinancing. Short-term debts are the most exposed.
  • Foreign-currency debt adds exchange rate risk; for the CEMAC, the euro stands apart thanks to the fixed parity.
  • Cameroon refinanced its 2015 Eurobond with the 2021 one, at a lower rate.

Your turn

A State cannot find enough lenders to repay a matured loan. This is...

1A State cannot find enough lenders to repay a matured loan. This is...

Which debt is most exposed to interest rate risk?

2Which debt is most exposed to interest rate risk?

A debt of 50 million dollars. The dollar goes from 600 to 630 FCFA. The debt in FCFA rises by...

3A debt of 50 million dollars. The dollar goes from 600 to 630 FCFA. The debt in FCFA rises by...

For a CEMAC State, a debt in euros carries little exchange rate risk because...

4For a CEMAC State, a debt in euros carries little exchange rate risk because...

Replacing a 9.50% Eurobond with a 5.95% one mainly makes it possible to...

5Replacing a 9.50% Eurobond with a 5.95% one mainly makes it possible to...

Read next: FMI et Banque mondiale, « Revised Guidelines for Public Debt Management » (2014)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further