Owning or lending: shares and bonds
A shareholder is an owner, a bondholder a creditor. On the day of a bankruptcy, lenders come before owners.
Lesson 18 min
By the end of this lesson
- Tell an owner’s position from a creditor’s for any security
- Calculate how a liquidation is shared, lenders first, shareholders next
- Explain why a share can bring in more than a bond
In this lesson3
Almost every product in this section, however complicated it looks, rests on two building blocks: owning a piece of a company or lending it money. What this lesson gives you is the ability to tell, for any security, which side you are on, and what that changes on the day everything goes wrong.
Two building blocks
A share makes you the owner of part of a company's capital: you receive dividends if it makes profits and pays them out, and you can lose part or even all of your stake if it goes bankrupt (AMF guide to shares). The First steps path covers it in A share, a piece of a company.
A bond makes you a lender: subscribing to a bond means granting a loan, you receive a coupon and get your money back at maturity, "unless the issuer goes bankrupt" (AMF guide to bonds). See A bond is a loan and, for the arithmetic, Bonds: coupon, accrued interest, yield.
Creditor
Someone who is owed money. A bondholder is a creditor of the issuer; a shareholder is an owner.
| Share | Bond | |
|---|---|---|
| You are | an owner | a lender (creditor) |
| What you receive | a dividend, if one is declared | a coupon, set in the contract |
| At the end | nothing is planned: you sell | the stake is repaid at maturity |
| If all goes well | your stake can gain a lot of value | you receive what was promised, no more |
Without looking at the table: what does a bond contract provide that a share does not?
The day everything goes wrong
When a company goes bankrupt and its assets are sold, the money raised is not shared out equally. The US regulator describes the general rule: common shareholders are last in line; bondholders are paid first, and the shareholder gets whatever is left, "which may be nothing" (SEC, Investor.gov, "Stocks").
This is the rule the SEC describes in the United States. In the CEMAC zone, bankruptcy falls under OHADA law, and the exact order among creditors (employees, the state, banks, bondholders) has not been checked for this section: remember the principle, lenders before owners, not a detailed ranking.
Choose how much the sale of the assets of Okoumé SA, a made-up company, raises, and watch the order in which the tanks fill.
Selling its assets raises
1. Lenders: 6,000 bonds
60m F
2. Owners: 4,000 shares
0m F
Dashes: the debt, 60m F (6,000 bonds of 10,000 F).
Everything goes to repay the lenders, down to the last franc. Nothing is left for the shareholders.
Okoumé SA is wound up, step by stepFictional
Okoumé SA issued 6,000 bonds of 10,000 F: it owes its lenders 60 million F. Its capital is divided into 4,000 shares. Selling its assets raises 90 million F.
- Lenders first. They are repaid in full: 60 million. That leaves 90 − 60 = 30 million.
- Owners next. 30,000,000 ÷ 4,000 = 7,500 F per share.
- And if the sale raises only 30 million? Everything goes to the lenders: 30,000,000 ÷ 6,000 = 5,000 F per bond, half the stake. Shareholders get nothing.
This split explains a rule you will meet throughout this section: the position most exposed to losses is also the one that can gain the most. The lender is served first but never receives more than was promised; the owner comes last, but everything above the debts goes to them. In the example, at 150 million, each share receives 22,500 F, and the bond still 10,000 F.
The sale raises exactly 60 million. What do the bondholder and the shareholder receive?
Reading the next products with these two blocks
- A fund buys shares and bonds for you: you own units of the basket (lesson 2).
- A structured product can be a debt security: you are then a lender to the institution that issues it, and the formula is only worth something if it can pay (lesson 6).
- A crypto-asset is neither: no issuer owes you a dividend or a repayment (lesson 7).
Your turn
Read next: SEC, Investor.gov, « Stocks »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.