Skip to content
Criée

Reading a debt crisis: the signals

Debt/GDP, debt service/revenue, reserves in months of imports, credit spread: four calculations and the IMF and World Bank benchmarks.

Lesson 89 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Calculate four signals of a debt crisis from published figures
  • Compare these signals with the sustainability framework’s thresholds and the CEMAC and UEMOA ceilings
  • Say when the IMF framework rates the risk as high
In this lesson3

The crises in the previous lessons did not come out of the blue: each time, public figures had worsened beforehand. The IMF and the World Bank track a handful of them to rate a country's risk. What you will take from this lesson: calculating four signals of a debt crisis, comparing them with official benchmarks, and saying what each one measures.

Four signals

Write DD for public debt, YY for GDP, SS for the year's debt service, TT for the year's government revenue, RR for foreign exchange reserves, MM for the year's imports, ii for the rate at which the State borrows and i∗i^* for the rate of a benchmark judged risk-free with the same maturity.

DYSTc=RM/12e=i−i∗\frac{D}{Y} \qquad \frac{S}{T} \qquad c = \frac{R}{M/12} \qquad e = i - i^*
  1. Debt/GDP: the weight of the debt stock compared with the wealth produced in a year.
  2. Debt service/revenue: the share of the year's revenue that goes on interest and repayments. For the World Bank, debt service is "the sum of principal repayments and interest actually paid" (World Bank, WDI).
  3. Reserves in months of imports: how many months the central bank could pay for imports with its foreign currency (lesson on the 2014 shock).
  4. Credit spread: what lenders demand on top of the risk-free rate, counted in basis points (lesson on the credit spread).

Debt sustainability

A State's ability to pay its debt service, today and tomorrow, without default, without exceptional relief and without a brutal adjustment of its budget.

The official benchmarks

The debt sustainability framework for low-income countries, "developed jointly by the IMF and the World Bank", classifies countries by their debt-carrying capacity, "Weak, Medium, and Strong" (IMF, framework factsheet). Its current thresholds are (IMF, 2026 presentation):

IndicatorWeakMediumStrong
Total public debt / GDP (present value)35%55%70%
External debt service / revenue14%18%23%
External debt service / exports10%15%21%
External debt / exports (present value)140%180%240%

Risk is "Low" if no threshold is breached, even in shock scenarios; "Moderate" if there is a breach in a shock scenario only; "High" if at least one threshold is breached in the baseline scenario (IMF, 2017 document).

The two unions have their own ceiling: in the CEMAC, "le taux d'endettement public est plafonné à 70%", public debt is capped at 70% (BEAC, working paper 09/19); in the UEMOA, debt must stay "inférieur ou égal à 70%", at or below 70% of nominal GDP (French Treasury, 2019). For reserves, "the traditional rule of thumb of 3 months of imports is widely used for low-income countries" (IMF, 2011).

A country with medium debt-carrying capacity spends 20% of its revenue on external debt service. Is it above the threshold?

The step-by-step calculation

Kalao's dashboardFictional

Kalao, a fictional State with medium debt-carrying capacity, publishes its figures for the year (in billions of FCFA, except rates):

  • GDP: 8,000; total public debt: 4,800; government revenue: 1,200; external debt service: 252; foreign exchange reserves: 900; imports: 4,320; rate on its 5-year bonds: 9.5%; 5-year risk-free benchmark rate: 4.0%.
  1. Debt/GDP. 4,800 ÷ 8,000 = 0.60, or 60%. Below the union's 70% ceiling, but above the framework's 55% benchmark for medium capacity (which applies to the present value of debt: if part of it is very concessional, the present value is lower).
  2. External debt service/revenue. 252 ÷ 1,200 = 0.21, or 21%. Above the 18% threshold.
  3. Reserves. Imports per month: 4,320 ÷ 12 = 360. Cover: 900 ÷ 360 = 2.5 months. Below the 3-month rule.
  4. Credit spread. 9.5% − 4.0% = 5.5 points, or 550 basis points: lenders demand a large premium.
  5. The reading. One threshold breached in the baseline scenario is enough to rate the risk as high. Kalao certainly breaches one (service/revenue), perhaps a second (debt/GDP, depending on the present value of its debt) and is short of reserves: this is the profile of a country that must act before it has to restructure.

No single signal is enough. A country can have high but long and cheap debt; another, modest debt that must be repaid in foreign currency next year. That is why the IMF combines several indicators with shock scenarios, and why the lessons on refinancing and on rolling over debt in the UEMOA also look at maturities.

The sustainability framework was revised in September 2026 and the new version is due to apply fully in summer 2027: it keeps only three external debt indicators and adds some on overall debt. The thresholds in the table are those of the 2017 framework, still in use. No official definition (IMF, World Bank, central bank) of the sovereign spread measured by market indices was found; the lesson sticks to the definition of the credit spread.

From memory: name the lesson's four signals and the benchmark attached to each.

Your turn

Debt of 3,000, GDP of 5,000. The debt-to-GDP ratio is...

1Debt of 3,000, GDP of 5,000. The debt-to-GDP ratio is...

Reserves of 600, imports of 3,600 a year. Cover is...

2Reserves of 600, imports of 3,600 a year. Cover is...

Bond at 8.2%, risk-free benchmark at 3.7%. The credit spread is...

3Bond at 8.2%, risk-free benchmark at 3.7%. The credit spread is...

In the IMF framework, one threshold breached in the baseline scenario rates the risk...

4In the IMF framework, one threshold breached in the baseline scenario rates the risk...

Medium debt-carrying capacity, external debt service equal to 21% of revenue. This ratio is...

5Medium debt-carrying capacity, external debt service equal to 21% of revenue. This ratio is...

Read next: FMI, fiche « IMF-World Bank Debt Sustainability Framework for Low-Income Countries »

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further