Skip to content
Criée

Retail forex: leverage and scams

Leverage multiplies losses, most individuals lose money, and promises of guaranteed gains signal a scam.

Lesson 810 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Work out the position and the loss of a leveraged forex account
  • Quote the maximum leverage set by ESMA on major pairs
  • Recognise the warning signs of a forex scam
In this lesson5

On social media, videos promise you can "live off forex" from your phone. The currency market is real, but what is sold to individuals is not what banks do. What this lesson teaches: understanding how leverage multiplies the losses of a forex account, and recognising the signs of a scam.

This section explains a mechanism; it gives no investment advice. The AMF writes that, because of the risks of fraud and of loss, even on authorised and reputable sites, "it is better to avoid Forex" (AMF, "Forex : attention danger !").

What you are really buying

An individual who "trades forex" on a platform usually does not buy any currency. Most often they go through CFDs, "contracts for difference", which the AMF classes as derivatives (AMF): as the name says, you settle the difference in price with the broker, without receiving the currencies. The CFTC, the US derivatives regulator, points out three consequences (CFTC, "Eight Things You Should Know Before Trading Forex"):

  • you trade against your broker, who gains when you lose;
  • the prices on your screen come from the broker, not from an exchange;
  • your deposits are not protected if the broker fails.

Leverage, a magnifying glass on losses

Leverage

Taking a position larger than the money deposited: with leverage of 30, €1,000 deposited exposes you to €30,000 of currency. Gains and losses are calculated on €30,000.

The CFTC gives an example: a 2% margin lets you open a $100,000 position with $2,000 in your account, and you can lose all your margin, and more. The AMF notes that leverage can multiply losses "sometimes up to 400 times" (AMF, "Forex, options binaires : trading à haut risque").

In 2018, ESMA, the European markets authority, restricted CFDs sold to individuals (ESMA, 27 March 2018):

  • leverage of 30 at most on major currency pairs, 20 on the others;
  • automatic close-out of the position when margin falls to 50% of the minimum margin;
  • no negative balance: you cannot lose more than the account.

Set the leverage, move the rate, then remove the European protections.

A leveraged forex account (made-up €1,000)

Leverage

Account equity

€800

Dashed line: your €1,000 deposit.

A €10,000 position with €1,000 deposited. The rate moves −2.0%: the result is −€200, i.e. −20.0% on your deposit.

A 1% move with leverage of 30, step by stepFictional

You deposit €1,000 (made-up amount) and take leverage of 30 on EUR/USD.

  1. The position. 1,000 × 30 = €30,000.
  2. The rate falls by 1%. 30,000 × 1% = €300 lost.
  3. On your deposit. 300 ÷ 1,000 = 30% lost, for a 1% move.
  4. The rate falls by 2%. The loss would reach €600, but the account drops to €500, half the minimum margin: the position is closed automatically. You have lost half your deposit.

Leverage does not change the probability that the rate goes up or down; it only changes the size of what you lose or gain.

With leverage of 20, how far must the rate move against you for you to lose your whole deposit, with no automatic close-out?

Writing MM for the deposit, LL for the leverage, Δc\Delta c for the percentage move in the rate and Δm\Delta m for the percentage change in the deposit, before any automatic close-out:

position=L×MΔm=L×Δc\text{position} = L \times M \qquad \Delta m = L \times \Delta c

What the figures say

  • ESMA (2018): according to national regulators' analyses, 74 to 89% of retail accounts lose money on CFDs.
  • AMF (2023): at brokers authorised in Europe, 7 to 8 clients out of 10 lose money on forex through CFDs.
  • AMF (2014 study of 2009-2012): 9 clients out of 10 lost money, with an average loss of €10,900 per client.
  • CFTC: two customers out of three lose money at registered US dealers.

Recognising a scam

The AMF and the CFTC describe the same warning signs (AMF, 2023; CFTC):

  1. Fast, high or guaranteed gains, often promoted by influencers.
  2. "Training courses", free or paid, supposed to turn you into a trader.
  3. Small gains at the start, there to push you to deposit more.
  4. A conversation moved to a private messaging app, customer service reachable only by messaging, no verifiable address.
  5. Payment demanded in crypto-assets, or fees to pay before any withdrawal.
  6. Leverage above legal limits.

The AMF adds that a second layer of fraud awaits victims: fake firms promising to recover their losses.

Name three warning signs common to the AMF's and the CFTC's warnings.

And in the CEMAC area?

The regulation of the Central African financial market states that no one may operate on the regional financial market without prior approval, authorisation or registration from the COSUMAF, which keeps the list of approvals (Regulation No. 01/22, arts. 22 to 24, text published by the BVMAC). The COSUMAF has issued warnings against players offering investments without approval, according to the business press (Financial Afrik, 2020).

No COSUMAF warning specifically about forex was found, and the rules that apply in the CEMAC to a forex platform based abroad are not established by the sources consulted. Before handing over money, check with the COSUMAF that the intermediary appears on its list of approvals; a platform missing from that list falls under no regional protection.

Your turn

With leverage of 10, you deposit €2,000. Your position is worth...

1With leverage of 10, you deposit €2,000. Your position is worth...

Leverage of 30, the rate falls 0.5% against you. Loss as a percentage of your deposit?

2Leverage of 30, the rate falls 0.5% against you. Loss as a percentage of your deposit?

What maximum leverage does ESMA allow individuals on a major currency pair?

3What maximum leverage does ESMA allow individuals on a major currency pair?

On an over-the-counter forex CFD, your counterparty is...

4On an over-the-counter forex CFD, your counterparty is...

A “mentor” promises a guaranteed 20% a month and asks for a deposit in crypto-assets. This is...

5A “mentor” promises a guaranteed 20% a month and asks for a deposit in crypto-assets. This is...

Read next: ESMA, restrictions sur les CFD et options binaires (27 mars 2018)

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further