The biases that make you sell at the worst time
Loss aversion, the disposition effect, anchoring, overconfidence: recognising them, and countering them with a rule written in advance.
Lesson 89 min
By the end of this lesson
- Recognise loss aversion, the disposition effect and herding
- Work out the rise needed to wipe out a fall in price
- Ask a question that escapes anchoring on the purchase price
In this lesson4
An investor knows about compound interest, horizon and diversification, and still sells at the worst moment. Decisions do not come from calculations alone: they also come from reflexes that behavioural finance has described. What this lesson teaches: recognising four biases in an investment decision, and countering them with a rule written in advance.
A loss weighs more than a gain
The AMF summarises the work of Kahneman and Tversky: savers give more weight to the risk of loss than to the chance of gain; an investor feels "twice as much pain" from a loss of €100 as pleasure from a gain of the same amount. They also prefer certainty: a sure gain of €100 rather than a bet with one chance in two of winning nothing and one chance in two of winning €200 (AMF, "Stimuler l'investissement de long terme en actions", 2017).
Loss aversion
The tendency to feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same amount, and to decide so as to avoid it.
The AMF's bet, step by stepFictional
- Choice A. You receive €100 for certain.
- Choice B. A coin is tossed: heads, €200; tails, €0.
- The calculation. On average, B pays ½ × 200 + ½ × 0 = €100. Both choices have the same average value.
- The reflex. According to the AMF, people prefer A: the fear of leaving with nothing weighs more than the hope of doubling.
There is nothing irrational about preferring A once. The problem comes when this reflex pushes you, year after year, to flee any investment that can fall, or to sell in a panic.
The disposition effect
Again according to the AMF, investors tend to sell their rising shares, often too early, and to keep their falling ones, often too long (AMF, 2017). The purchase price serves as a reference point, although it says nothing about the company's future: this is also an anchoring effect, which the AMF lists among the biases to know, along with herding (doing what others do) (AMF, 2021).
Disposition effect
The tendency to sell winning investments too early and to hold on to losing ones too long.
Serge, an invented investor, buys two shares at the same price. Follow what he does with them.
Two purchases at the same price
Serge buys 20 shares in Kapok and 20 in Baobab, two fictitious companies, at 5,000 FCFA each.
From memory: why is a 30% fall not made up by a 30% rise?
Looking too often, thinking too highly of yourself
Two more biases complete the list. The AMF cites the "myopia" described by Thaler: savers who check their investments very often become short-sighted about their long-term return (AMF, 2017). It also points to the overconfidence seen in new investors, and to studies finding that the least skilled people in a field tend to overestimate their skills (AMF, 2021).
Overconfidence
The tendency to overestimate your knowledge or your ability to predict markets.
A rule written before you are afraid
A bias does not disappear because you know about it. What helps is deciding coolly, before the fall, what you will do during the fall.
1/4The horizon
The date when the money will be used. As long as it is not close, a fall does not force you to sell.
These rules reduce the effect of biases; they do not protect against losses. A well-kept portfolio can fall sharply, and no rule guarantees that it will recover.
Without looking above: Serge keeps a share that has lost 30% because he 'wants to win it back'. Which two biases do you recognise?
Your turn
Read next: AMF, « Stimuler l’investissement de long terme en actions » (2017)
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.