Skip to content
Criée

Inside information and insider dealing

Three criteria to recognise inside information, two separate breaches, and the sanction range of Regulation 01/22.

Lesson 39 min

By the end of this lesson

  • Recognise inside information by its three criteria
  • Distinguish insider dealing from an unlawful disclosure
  • Calculate the penalty ceiling from the gain obtained
In this lesson3

Whoever knows before everyone else that a price is about to jump can win for certain, and that gain is taken from those who sell to them without knowing. That is why the law forbids using inside information. What this lesson teaches: recognising inside information by its three criteria, and working out the sanction range set in the CEMAC.

Three criteria, not one fewer

Regulation No. 01/22, art. 259 defines inside information as “information of a precise nature which has not been made public, relating, directly or indirectly, to one or more issuers or to one or more financial instruments, and which, if it were made public, would be likely to have a significant effect on the price”. The definition is word for word that of the EU Market Abuse Regulation, art. 7.

Inside information

Precise information, not yet public, that would move the price significantly if it were known.

CriterionYesNo
Precise“A takeover offer at 12,000 was received on Monday”“I have a feeling it will rise”
Not publicKnown only to the boardPublished in an announcement
Significant effectTakeover, loss of a major client, results far from expectationsChange of paper supplier

Two separate breaches

The same article 259 punishes insider dealing: using the information to buy or sell, for oneself or for someone else, and even to cancel or amend an order already placed; recommending or inducing someone to do so is punished in the same way. Article 260 punishes unlawful disclosure: passing on the information outside the normal course of work or duties, even without buying anything oneself.

In everyday language people say “insider trading”; Regulation No. 01/22 speaks of insider dealing (opération d'initié), sanctioned by the COSUMAF “without prejudice to the applicable criminal provisions”.

Insider dealing

Buying, selling, cancelling or amending an order using inside information, on one's own account or for someone else.

The US SEC follows the same logic and lists the profiles already prosecuted: managers, relatives who receive a “tip”, employees of law firms, banks or printers, public officials (SEC Investor.gov, “Insider Trading”). The preamble of the EU regulation sums up the reason: the advantage is unfair because it is gained “to the detriment of third parties who are unaware of such information” (MAR, recital 23).

From memory: Cédric, an accountant, tells his cousin about a secret takeover plan but buys nothing. Has he committed a breach?

The life of a piece of inside information

Follow a takeover plan for the fictional company Okoumé, from the boardroom to the sanction.

The life of a piece of inside information1/7

The information is born

The board of the fictional company Okoumé receives a takeover offer at 12,000 per share, while the price is 9,000. The information is precise, not public, and would move the price: it is inside information.

Two prevention tools appear in the scene. The insider list records everyone with access to the information, advisers and accountants included; it is kept up to date and sent to the COSUMAF. Information barriers separate, within a brokerage firm, the departments that hold inside information from the others (Regulation No. 01/22, arts. 279 and 280).

The sanction range, step by stepFictional

Mballa bought 500 shares at 9,000 FCFA; after the announcement, the price is 11,800.

  1. Gain obtained: 500 × (11,800 − 9,000) = 500 × 2,800 = 1,400,000 FCFA.
  2. Floor: article 259 sets a financial penalty “greater than or equal to ten million” FCFA, i.e. 10,000,000.
  3. Ceiling: it may not “exceed ten times the gain obtained”, i.e. 10 × 1,400,000 = 14,000,000 FCFA.
  4. Range: between 10,000,000 and 14,000,000 FCFA, “without prejudice to the applicable criminal provisions”.

Mballa therefore risks paying up to ten times what he gained. Cédric, who disclosed the information, faces the same amounts under article 260.

Writing qq for the quantity bought, C0C_0 for the purchase price, C1C_1 for the price after the announcement, AA for the gain obtained and Smax⁡S_{\max} for the ceiling of the financial penalty:

A=q (C1−C0)Smax⁡=10×AA = q \, (C_1 - C_0) \qquad S_{\max} = 10 \times A

Two points are not confirmed by the texts read. First, how the 10,000,000 FCFA floor and the ten-times ceiling combine when the gain is below 1,000,000 FCFA (ten times the gain then falls below the floor). Second, whether managers of BVMAC-listed issuers face a ban on trading before results: the European Union imposes a 30-day one (MAR, art. 19(11)); no equivalent text was found in the CEMAC.

Without looking back: an insider buys 200 shares at 5,000 and the price moves to 6,500 after the announcement. What is the ceiling of the penalty?

Your turn

Which of these can be inside information?

1Which of these can be inside information?

An insider cancels a sell order after learning secret good news. That is...

2An insider cancels a sell order after learning secret good news. That is...

Gain obtained: 2,000,000 FCFA. Ceiling of the financial penalty?

3Gain obtained: 2,000,000 FCFA. Ceiling of the financial penalty?

What is an insider list for?

4What is an insider list for?

Passing inside information to a friend, without buying anything, is...

5Passing inside information to a friend, without buying anything, is...

Read next: Règlement n°01/22/CEMAC/UMAC/CM/COSUMAF du 21 juillet 2022

A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.

Share:WhatsAppLinkedIn

Going further