Market manipulation: pump and dump and decoy orders
Two manipulations replayed in the book by the engine, what they earn, whom they cost and what gives them away.
Lesson 410 min
By the end of this lesson
- Recognise a pump and dump and a spoofing order in an order book
- Calculate a manipulator’s gain over a series of orders
- Spot the shares and the rumours that open the door to manipulation
A price is meant to sum up what all buyers and all sellers think. The manipulator manufactures a false summary: fake demand, fake news, fake trades, in order to buy or sell at a price he has moved himself. What this lesson teaches: recognising in an order book the two most common schemes, the pump and dump and the decoy order, and saying what gives them away.
What the rule says
In the CEMAC, Regulation No. 01/22, art. 261 targets two families of behaviour:
- spreading information, including over the internet, that gives false or misleading signals about supply, demand or price, “including spreading rumours”, when one knew or ought to have known it was false;
- placing orders or trades that give such signals, set the price at an abnormal or artificial level, or use “fictitious devices or any other form of deception or contrivance”.
The financial penalty is at least 10,000,000 FCFA, and may not exceed ten times the gain obtained, without prejudice to criminal proceedings.
Market manipulation
Distorting the picture of supply, demand or price of a security, through false information or misleading orders.
Two schemes in the book
Choose a scheme and follow it order by order. The book, the trades and the surveillance indicators are computed by the portal's matching engine; to read a book, see the lesson “Reading an order book”.
Traded prices, in order
Yellow plate: last price. Blue, Z: one of Zacharie’s orders in the book (a long bar is cut off). Stock, people and prices are fictional.
A thin book
Fictional stock Raphia, last price 5,000. Best bid 4,950, best ask 5,000. Few shares at each price: a handful of orders is enough to move the price.
The pump and dump. The SEC describes it like this: fraudsters spread false or misleading information to create a buying frenzy that “pumps” up the price, then “dump” their own shares at the inflated price; when the promotion stops, the price falls and investors lose. Small, poorly documented stocks are the most exposed (SEC Investor.gov, “Pump and Dump Schemes”). The AMF points out that the promoter does not say he holds large quantities of shares, and that the practice “is prohibited, as it constitutes market manipulation” (AMF, 2024 annual report).
The decoy order. In the United States, the law defines spoofing as placing an order “with the intent to cancel the bid or offer before execution”; mere recklessness is not enough, intent is required (CFTC, 2013 final rule). In the CEMAC, this behaviour falls under orders that give “false or misleading signals” about demand (art. 261).
From memory: in the animation's pump and dump, whom does Zacharie sell his shares to at the top?
What manipulation earns, and whom it costsFictional
The figures are those the engine computes in the animation.
- Pump: Zacharie holds 70 shares bought at 4,800 (336,000 FCFA). He buys 30 at 5,000, 20 at 5,050 and 20 at 5,100: 353,000 FCFA.
- Dump: he sells 140 shares for 40 × 5,500 + 40 × 5,450 + 60 × 5,400 = 762,000 FCFA.
- Zacharie's gain: 762,000 − 353,000 − 336,000 = 73,000 FCFA.
- Awa's loss: she paid 30 × 5,200 + 30 × 5,300 = 315,000 FCFA; she sells back for 30 × 4,950 + 30 × 4,900 = 295,500 FCFA; a loss of 19,500 FCFA.
- Decoy: without his fake order, Zacharie would have sold his 60 shares to the original buyers, 30 × 4,950 + 30 × 4,900 = 295,500 FCFA. With the decoy he gets 40 × 5,050 + 20 × 5,000 = 302,000 FCFA: 6,500 FCFA taken from the misled buyers.
What alerts surveillance
The EU regulation requires trading venues and intermediaries to have detection systems and to report suspicious orders and transactions without delay, cancellations included (MAR, art. 16). The clues in the animation are the ones those systems look for:
- one account making most of the purchases during the rise, then selling at the top;
- a sharp rise with no information published by the issuer, right after an unsourced message;
- a high share of orders cancelled unexecuted, the cancellation following closely a trade on the other side of the book.
The obligation for a CEMAC brokerage firm to report orders suspected of manipulation to the COSUMAF, and its terms, was not found in the articles read; only the EU obligation is confirmed here. A message promising an imminent rise in a small stock, with no verifiable source, is the classic sign of a pump and dump: the SEC and the AMF advise caution. Nothing in this section is investment advice; to recognise misleading promises of gain, see the lesson “Scams: when a gain is guaranteed”.
Without looking back: what are the three clues that betray manipulation in the book?
Your turn
Read next: SEC Investor.gov, « Pump and Dump Schemes »
A question? Ask your teacher, or an AI assistant, giving it the title of this lesson.